Id non culpam, sed poenam esse iudicabam (Confessions VII 3, 5): some questions and reflections of saint Augustine on the origin of evil

Waldemar Turek

Pontificia Università Urbaniana a Roma , Italy


Abstract

In light of the distinction Saint Augustine makes between a committed evil, understood as the result of a mistake in choosing (culpa), and a suffered evil, des­cribed as the effect of a just divine judgment (poena) – a distinction he makes in several texts dealing with the origin of evil – I analyze Augustine’s reflections in the Confessions on his relationship with the unnamed women. He calls the rela­tionship a pactum libidinosi amoris, that is, one aimed at satisfying the passions. The negative moral judgment he passes on this stage of his life is expressed with particular poignancy by the word libido/libidinosus, indicating the passions to which man submits at times. Looking back at his affair with the unnamed woman, he considers the evil committed a culpa; hence one has the impression that he wanted to place the moral responsibility of the evil committed upon himself, thus giving greater witness to the goodness of the merciful God who revealed to him gradually the truth concerning the various phases of his spiritual journey and the pain experienced along the way.

Keywords:

culpa, poena, the origin of evil, evil done (to one), evil endured, free will, divine judgement, libidinous love, the marital covenant

Augustinus, Confessiones, ed. A. Trapè – C. Carena, NBA 1, Roma 1991, tłum. Z. Kubiak: Święty Augustyn, Wyznania, Kraków 2008
Breyfogle T., Pena, w: Agostino. Dizionario enciclopedico, ed. A. Fitzgerald, ed. italiana a cura di L. Alici e A. Pie¬retti, Roma 2007
Evans G.R., Male, w: Agostino. Dizionario enciclopedico, ed. A. Fitzgerald, ed. italiana a cura di L. Alici e A. Pie¬retti, Roma 2007, 882-888
Trapè A., Introduzione, w: NBA 1, LV-LVIII
Wetzel J., Colpa, mancanza, w: Agostino. Dizionario enciclopedico, ed. A. Fitzgerald, ed. italiana a cura di L. Alici e A. Pie¬retti, Roma 2007

Published
2013-01-25


Turek, W. (2013). Id non culpam, sed poenam esse iudicabam (Confessiones VII 3, 5). Niektóre wątpliwości i refleksje św. Augustyna analizującego źródło zła. Vox Patrum, 59, 241–250. https://doi.org/10.31743/vp.4028

Waldemar Turek 
Pontificia Università Urbaniana a Roma



License

Papers published in Vox Patrum are covered by the Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-ND 4.0) licence. Authors and users can use published works licensed under the CC-BY-ND since 2018. For earlier publications, copyrights are available under fair use rights in accordance with the Act of February 4, 1994 on copyrights and related rights.