The sons of Hagar. Byzantine views on the Arab army in military treatises of 9th and 10th century

Teresa Wolińska

Uniwersytet Łódzki , Poland


Abstract

Arab military expansion was a real challenge to the Byzantine Empire. The defeats sustained in wars with the Arabs, whom the Byzantines called sometimes Hagarenes to refer to Biblical Hagar, forced new method of war waging. That knowledge was taken predominantly directly from battlefield. The Arab menace increased during the reign of Leo VI the Wise (886-912). Albeit not a soldier himself, he took an attempt to reorganize the Byzantine army and navy. Although it did not bring an immediate effect, the Empire gradually be­gan to initiative. The situation changed for better during the reign of Constantine VII Porphyrogennetos (911-959) and Romanos I Lekapenos (919-959). A peace with the Bulgarians allowed to collect substantial forces on the eastern border of the empire. The weakening of the Abbasids gave way to the Hamdanid dynasty from northern Iraq and Syria to grow to the most serious Byzantine adversary in mid- 10th century, particularly during the reign of Sayf al-Dawla (945-967), who re­corded some remarkable victories over the Byzantine forces. In 955 Nikephoros II Phokas took over the post of domesticos of the East. Along with his brother Leo, Strategos of Cappadocia and John Tzimiskes, they were able to change the course of war, winning some battles in northern Syria. The struggle with the Muslims resulted in a number of military treatises, the most known of which were attributed to emperors Leo VI and Nikephoros II Pho­kas. Although it is not certain if they were written by them themselves, they were certainly created on their behalf. Among several treatises of Leo VI, the Tactica seems to be the most interest­ing. The work divided in 20 chapters was meant as a handbook for military com­manders. It discussed the organization of infantry, cavalry and navy, and their use in war, as well as that of sieges, ambushes etc. Much attention was paid to Arab logistics. Remarkably little, if any attention was paid to religious grounds as a rea­son for expansion. Not too surprisingly, much of the work was dedicated to the methods of efficient struggle against Muslims; the author correctly identified both strong and week sides of the Byzantine army. Some points clearly suggest a desire to take over certain elements of organization and war art from the adversary. Also the treatise by Nikephoros Phokas represents equally good value as Tactica. In this work we find a number of details regarding both military and non-military customs of the Arabs, which is not surprising, as the author was a military commander, experienced in battles against the Muslims. For this reason we should respect even more the military knowledge of Leo’s Tactica, if we remember that the author was not a professional soldier. Interestingly enough, with the notable exception of Nikephoros Phokas, the authors of other treatises added little to the information contained in Leo’s work. The reason for that was explicitly laid out by an anonymous author of still another treatise, Βιβλίον τακτικόν, who wrote that the chiefs knew so much about the raids on the lands of the Hagarenes that there was no use to discuss them in detail.

Keywords:

Byzantium, Arabs, art of war (polemology), military treatises (tactica), Nicephor II Phocas, Leo VI the Wise

An Nuwayri, Dal Nibayat ‘al ‘arib, trad. da M. Amari: Il sommo sforzo di chi conosce le varie parti dell’erudizione, w: Bibliotheca arabo-sicula: versione italiana, raccolta da M. Amari, vol. 1, Torini – Roma 1880

Anonymus Byzantinus, De re strategica 21 i 32, ed. G.T. Dennis: Anonymous Book of Tactics, w: Three Byzantine Military Treatises, text, translation and notes by G.T. Dennis, Dumbarton Oaks Texts 9, CFHB (Series Washingtonensis) 25, Washington 1985

Bartholomaeus Edessenus, Elenchus et confutatio Agareni, PG 104

Browning R., Byzantium and Bulgaria. A Comparative Study across the Early Medieval Frontier, London 1975

Vasiliev A.A., Histoire de l’Empire Byzantin, t. 1: (324-1081), trad. P. Brodin – A. Bourguina, Paris 1932

Canard M., Histoire de la dynastie des Hamdanides de Jazîra et de Syrie, Alger 1951

Canard M., Mutanabbi et la guerre byzantino-arabe. Intérêt historique de ses poesies, w: Al Mutanabbi: Recueil publié à l’occasion de son millénaire, Mémoires de l’Institut Français de Damas, Beyrouth 1936

Cheynet J.-C., Les Phocas, w: Le traité sur la guérilla (De velitatione bellica) de l’empereur Nicéphore Phocas (963- 969), texte établi par G. Dagron – H. Mihaescu, traduction et commentaire par G. Dagron, Le Mond Byzantin, Paris 1986

Christides V., Once Again Camitiates’ Capture of Thessaloniki, ByZ 74 (1981)

Christides V., Saracens’ Prodosia in Byzantine Sources, „Byzantion” 40 (1970)

Constantinus Porphyrogenitus, Tres tractatus de expeditionibus militaribus imperatoris, ed. J.F. Haldon: Three Treatises on Imperial Military Expeditions, CFHB (Series Vindobonensis) 28, Vienna 1990

Constantinus Porphyrogemitus Imperator, De thematibus, ed. A. Pertusi: Costantino Porfirogenito, De thematibus, introduzione, testo critico, commento a cura di A. Pertusi, Studii e Testi 160, Città del Vaticano 1952

Dagron G., Byzance et le modèle islamique au Xe siècle. A propos des Constitutions tactiques de l’empereur Léon VI, „Comptes Rendus des Séances de l’Académie des Inscriptions et Belles-Lettres” 127 (1983) nr 2

Dain A., Les stratégistes byzantins, „Travaux et Mémoires” 2 (1967)

Dennis G.T., Campaign Organization and Tactics, w: tenże, Three Byzantine Military Treatises, text, translation and notes by G.T. Dennis, Dumbar¬ton Oaks Texts 9, CFHB (Series Washingtonensis) 25, Washington 1985

Dennis G.T., Skirmishing. Introduction, w: Three Byzantine Military Treatises, text, translation and notes by G.T. Dennis, Dumbarton Oaks Texts 9, CFHB (Series Washingtonensis) 25, Washington 1985

Dolley R.H., The Lord High Admiral Eustathios Argyros and the Betrayal of Taormina to the African Arabs in 902, w: Atti del VIII Congresso Internazionale di Studi Bizantini (Palermo, 3-10 April 1951), ed. S.G. Mercati, vol. 1, Studi Bizantini e Neoellenici 7, Roma 1953

Farag W.A., Some Remarks on Leo of Trypolis’ Attack on Thessaloniki in 904 A.D., ByZ 82 (1989)

Georgius Monachus, Vitae imperatorum recen¬tiorum, rec. I. Bekker, CSHB 31, Bonnae 1838

Grégoire H., Le communiqué arabe sur la prise de Thessalonique (904), „Byzantion” 22 (1953) 373-378

Georgius Monachus, Chronicon, ed. C. de Boor, vol. 2, Lipsiae 1904

Georgius Monachus, Vitae imperatorum recentiorum, CSHB 31

Grosdidier de Matons J., Trois études sur Léon VI, „Travaux et Mémoires” 5 (1973)

Hauziński J., Burzliwe dzieje kalifatu bagdadzkiego, Warszawa – Kraków

Ibn al-Athir, Kitāb al-Kāmil al-Tawārīkh, trad. da M. Amari: Cronaca compiuta, w: Biblio-theca arabo-sicula, vol. 1

Ibn-Khaldûn, Kîtâb el-’Iber, trad. da M. Amari: Libro dei concetti storici, w: Biblioteca arabo-sicula, vol. 1

Janin R., Un Arabe ministre a Byzance: Samonas, EO 34 (1935) 307-318

Jenkins R., The Chronological Accurancy of the „Logothete” for the years a A 867-913, DOP 19 (1965)

Jenkins R., The Flight of Samonas, „Speculum” 23 (1948) nr 2, 217-235

Joannes Diaconus, Translatio sancti Severini 2, ed. G. Waitz, MGH Scriptores Rerum Langobardicarum et Italicarum saec. VI-IX, Hannoverae 1878

Joannes Cameniata, De excidio Thessalonicensi, rec. I. Bekker, CSHB 31, 487-600

Kazhdan P., Some Questions Addressed to the Scholars who Believe in the Authencity of Kamitiates’ Capture of Thessalonica, ByZ 71 (1978) 301-317

Leo Grammaticus, Chronographia, rec. I. Bekker, CSHB 42, Bonnae 1842

Jenkins R., The Date of Leo VI’s Cretan Expedition, w: Mélanges Kyriakides, Thessalonike 1953

Joannes Scylitzes, Synopsis historiarum, rec. I. Thurn, CFHB (Series Berolinensis) 5, Berolini 1973

Karlin-Hayter P., „When military affairs were in Leo’s hands”: a note on Byzantine foreign policy (886-912), „Traditio” 23 (1967) 15-40

Khoury Odetallah R., Leo Tripolites – Ghulam Zurafa and the Sack of Thessaloniki in 904, „Byzantinoslavica” 54 (1995) nr 1, 97-102

Leo VI Sapiens, Naumachica, ed. A. Dain, Nouvelle Collection de Textes et Documents, Paris 1943

Leo VI Sapiens, Problemata, ed. A. Dain, Nouvelle Collection de Textes et Documents, Limoges – Paris 1935

Leo VI Sapiens, Tactica passim, ed. i tłum. w: The Taktika of Leo VI, text, translation, and commentary by G. Dennis, Dumbarton Oaks Texts 12, CFHB (Series Washingtonensis) 49, Washington 2010

Leon Diakon, Historiae libri decem II 1, rec. C.B. Hase, CSHB 3, Bonnae 1828

Lilie R.-J., Bisanzio. La seconda Roma, trad. di G. Montinari, I Volti della Storia 176, Roma 2005

Luttwak E.N., La grande strategia dell’Impero Bizantino, trad. di D. Giusti – E. Peru, Milano 2009

McGeer E., The Offspring of Hagar, w: tenże, Sowing the Dragon’s Teeth. Byzantine Warfare in the Tenth Century, Dumbarton Oaks Studies 33, Washington 1995

Nicephorus II Phokas, De velitatione bellica 15, ed. G.T. Dennis: Skirmishing, w: Three Byzantine Military Treatises, text, translation and notes by G.T. Dennis, Dumbarton Oaks Texts 9, CFHB (Series Washingtonensis) 25, Washington 1985

Nicephorus II Phocas, Praecepta militaria, ed. E. McGeer: The Praecepta militaria of the Emperor Nicephoros II Phocas, w: McGeer, Sowing the Dragon’s Teeth. Byzantine Warfare in the Tenth Century, Dumbarton Oaks Studies 33, Washington 1995

Nicolaus Myssticus, Epistula, ed. R.H.J. Jenkins – L.G. Westerling: Nicholas I Patriarch of Constantinople [Nicolaus Mysticus], Letters, Dumbarton Oaks Texts 2. CFHB (Series Washingtonensis) 6, Dumbarton Oaks 1973

Nicephorus Ouranos, Tactica, ed. E. McGeer: The Tactica of Nikeforos Ouranos, Chapters 56 through 65, w: tenże, Sowing the Dragon’s Teeth. Byzantine Warfare in the Tenth Century, Dumbarton Oaks Studies 33, Washington 1995

Niketas, Vita sanctae Theoctistae, ed. H. Delehaye – P. Peeters, ASanc Nov. IV, Bruxellis 1925

Philotheus, Cletorologium, ed. J.B. Bury, w: tenże, The Imperial Administrative System in the Ninth Century with the Revised Text of the Kletorologion of Philotheos, The British Academy Supplemental Papers 1, London 1911

Romoaldus, Annales a. 893-1178, ed. W. Arndt, MGH Scriptores 19, Hannoverae 1866

Romualdus Salernitanus, Chronicon (A.m. 130 - A.c. 1178), ed. C.A. Garufi, Rerum Italicarum Scriptores 7/1, Città di Castello – Bologna 1935

Savvides A.G.C., Some notes on the Term Agarenoī, Ismaelītai and Sarakenoī in Byzantine Sources, „Byzantion” 67 (1997) 89-96

Schlumberger G., Un empereur byzantin au Xe siècle, Nicéphore Phocas, Paris 1923

Theodosius Melitenus, Chronographia, ed. Th.L.F. Tafel, Monumenta Saecularia 3/1, Monachii 1859

Theophanes Continuatus, rec. I. Bekker, CSHB 31

Thoynbee A., Constantine Porphyrogenitus and His World, London 1973

Tougher S., The Reign of Leo VI (886-912). Politics and People, Leiden – New York 1997

Treadgold W., A History of the Byzantine State and Society, Stanford 1997

Treadgold W., Bizancjum i jego armia 284- 1081, tłum. A. Grabska-Ryńska, Wodzisław Śląski 2011

Vasiliev A.A., Byzance et les Arabes, t. 2/1: La Dynastie Macédonienne (867-959), trad. M. Canard, Bruxelles 1968

Vieillefond J.-R., Les pratiques religieuses dans l’armée byzantine d’après les traités militaires, REA 37 (1935) 222-230

Vogt A., La jeunesse de Léon VI le Sage, RevH 174 (1934)

Whittow M., The Making of Byzantium, 600-1025, Berkeley – Los Angeles 1996

Wolińska T., Sycylia w polityce bizantyńskiej w VI-IX w., Byzantina Lodziensia 8, Łódź 2005

Yahya ibn Sa’ïd Antiochensis, Annales, ed. et trad. français par I. Kratchkovsky – A. Vasiliev: Histoire de Yahya ibn Sa’ïd d’Antioche continuateur de Sa’ïd ibn Bitriq, PO 18/5, Paris 1957

Zonaras J., Epitomae historiarum, ed. Th. Büttner-Wobst, CSHB 50/3, Bonnae 1897


Published
2015-07-15


Wolińska, T. (2015). The sons of Hagar. Byzantine views on the Arab army in military treatises of 9th and 10th century. Vox Patrum, 63, 397–416. https://doi.org/10.31743/vp.3571

Teresa Wolińska 
Uniwersytet Łódzki



License

Zgodnie z regulacjami prawnymi zawartymi w ustawie o prawie autorskim i prawach pokrewnych z dnia 4 lutego 1994 r., autor przekazuje autorskie prawa majątkowe dotyczące składanego dzieła wydawcy czasopisma "Vox Patrum". Przeniesienie praw autorskich do składanego dzieła następuje na wszystkich polach eksploatacji, w szczególności tych wymienionych w art. 50 ustawy o prawie autorskim i prawach pokrewnych: 1. W zakresie utrwalania i zwielokrotniania utworu – wytwarzanie określoną techniką egzemplarzy dzieła, w tym techniką drukarską, reprograficzną, zapisu magnetycznego oraz techniką cyfrową. 2. W zakresie obrotu oryginałem albo egzemplarzami , na których dzieło utrwalono – wprowadzanie do obrotu, użyczenie lub najem oryginału albo egzemplarzy. 3. W zakresie rozpowszechniania utworu w sposób inny niż określony w pkt. 2 – publiczne wykonanie, wystawienie, wyświetlenie, odtworzenie oraz nadawanie i reemitowanie, a także publiczne udostępnianie utworu, aby każdy mógł mieć do niego dostęp w miejscu i czasie przez siebie wybranym.

Za zgodą Redakcji czasopisma artykuły i recenzje opublikowane w półroczniku "Vox Patrum" mogą być przedrukowywane w innych publikacjach.

Autor, w celach niekomercyjnych, może w dowolny sposób, bez zgody Redakcji, rozpowszechniać swój tekst w wersji elektronicznej.

Redakcja publikuje teksty on-line na licencji Creative Commons Uznanie autorstwa-Bez utworów zależnych 4.0 Międzynarodowe.