Deposing Popes and Kings: the Praxis of Tyranny during the Great Western Schism (1378–1417)
Joëlle Rollo-Koster
University of Rhode Island , United StatesAbstract
This essay summarises the evolution of the concept of tyranny from classical antiquity through late medieval Europe, examining its application to both secular and ecclesiastical figures. Beginning with Aristotle’s characterisation of tyranny as unconstitutional rule, the essay explores how classical definitions influenced early Christian thought, particularly through the writings of Isidore of Seville. Isidore’s adaptation of tyranny to ecclesiastical contexts paved the way for later medieval thinkers like John of Salisbury and Bartolus de Sassoferato to articulate theories of illegitimate power in both secular and religious spheres. The essay then delves into the Great Western Schism (1378–1417), during which the papacy was divided between rival claimants, leading to accusations of tyranny against popes and secular rulers alike. Through detailed analysis of historical sources and contemporary accounts, the essay demonstrates how charges of tyranny were leveraged to justify the deposition or elimination of political and religious figures, including Pope Urban VI, King Richard II of England, King Wenceslaus of Germany, and Pope Benedict XIII. I conclude with the case of King Władysław II Jagiełło of Poland. Drawing parallels between these cases, the article highlights common themes found in accusations of tyranny, such as abuse of power, financial mismanagement, refusal of counsel, and religious dissent. By examining the rhetoric and political dynamics surrounding these events, the essay argues that the concept of tyranny served as a powerful tool for legitimising political action and shaping public discourse.
Keywords:
Great Western Schism, tyranny, King Richard II of England, King Wenceslaus IV of Bohemia and Germany, King Władysław II Jagiełło of PolandReferences
Chronique du religieux de Saint-Denys: Contenant le rčgne de Charles VI de 1380 ŕ 1422, ed. and trans. Louis-Francois Bellaguet and Bernard Guenee, 3 vols. Editions du Comite des travaux historiques et scientifiques (Paris: Impremerie de Crapelet, 1894).
Decrees of the Ecumenical Councils, ed. and trans. Norman Tanner, 2 vols. (London: Sheed & Ward, 1990).
Deutsche Reichstagsakten unter König Wenzel (1397–1400), ed. Julius Weizsacker (Munich: Oldenbourg, 1877).
Dietrich of Nieheim, De scismate libri tres, ed. Georg Erler (Leipzig: Veit & Comp., 1890).
Isidore of Seville, Sententiae, trans. Thomas L. Knoebel. Ancient Christian Writers 73 (New York: The Newman Press, 2018).
A Companion to the Great Western Schism (1378–1417), ed. Joelle Rollo-Koster and Thomas Izbicki (Leiden and Boston: Brill, 2009).
Baluze, Etienne and Guillaume Mollat, Vitae paparum avenionensium: Nouvelle édition et étude critique, 4 vols. (Paris: Letouzey et Ane, 1914–1922).
Bar, Přemysl, “A Tortuous Path to Reconciliation and Justice: Sigismund of Luxembourg as Arbiter in the Dispute between the Teutonic Knights and Poland (1412–1420),” Zeitschrift für Ostmitteleuropa-Forschung 66.1 (2017): 3–40.
Barney, Stephen A., W. J. Lewis, J. A. Beach and Oliver Berghof, The Etymologies of Isidore of Seville (Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press, 2006).
Boockman, Heinrich, Johannes Falkenberg, der deutsche Orden und die polnische Politik (Gottingen: Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht, 1975).
Cable, Martin John, “[Review of ] Joelle Rollo-Koster, The Great Western Schism, 1378–1417: Performing Legitimacy, Performing Unity,” H-France Review 23 (2023): 1–5, https://h-france.net/vol23reviews/vol23_no165_Cable%20LT.pdf.
Carlson, David R., The Deposition of Richard II: “The Record and Process of the Renunciation and Deposition of Richard II” (1399) and Related Writings (Toronto: Pontifical Institute of Mediaeval Studies, 2007).
Clarke, Maude V., The Medieval City State: An Essay on Tyranny and Federation in the Later Middle Ages (Oxford: Routledge, 2016).
Coste, Jean., Boniface VIII en procčs: Articles d’accusation et dépositions des témoins (1303–1311) (Rome: L’Erma di Bretschneider, 1995).
Emerton, Ephraim, Humanism and Tyranny: Studies in the Italian Trecento (Gloucester: P. Smith, 1964).
Frost, Robert I., The Oxford History of Poland-Lithuania, vol. 1: The Making of the Polish-Lithuanian Union, 1385–1569 (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2018).
Kalisz, Tomasz, Ego praedicator. Zarys biografii Jana Falkenberga OP (Krakow: Dominikański Instytut Historyczny and Wydawnictwo W drodze, 2021).
Kaminsky, Howard, Simon de Cramaud: De substraccione obediencie (Cambridge, MA: The Medieval Academy of America, 1984).
Klaniczay, Gabor, “Representation of the Evil Ruler in the Middle Ages,” in European Monarchy: Its Evolution and Practice from Roman Antiquity to Modern Times, ed. Heinz Duchhardt, Richard A. Jackson and David Sturdy (Stuttgart: Franz Steiner Verlag, 1992).
Knoll, Paul W., “Religious Toleration in Sixteenth-Century Poland: Political Realities and Social Constraints,” in Diversity and Dissent: Negotiating Religious Difference in Central Europe, 1500–1800, ed. Howard Louthan, Gary B. Cohen and Franz A. J. Szabo (New York: Berghahn Books, 2011).
Masolini, Serena, “Public Authority and Right to Kill in the ‘Petit’ and ‘Falkenberg Affairs’ at the Council of Constance (1414–1418),” Freiburger Zeitschrift für Philosophie und Theologie 67.2 (2020): 383–412.
Mickūnaiė, Giedrė, Making a Great Ruler: Grand Duke of Lithuania (New York: Central European University Press, 2006).
Mollat, Guillaume, Étude critique sur les vitae paparum avenionensium (Paris: Letouzey et Ane, 1917).
Muhlethaler, Jean-Claude, “Le tyrant a table: Intertextualite et reference dans l’invective politique a l’epoque de Charles VI,” in Représentation, pouvoir et royauté ŕ la fin du Moyen Âge. Actes du Colloque organisé par l’Université du Maine les 25 et 26 mars 1994, ed. Joel Blanchard, postface Philippe Contamine (Paris: Picard, 1995).
Nederman, Cary J., “A Duty to Kill: John of Salisbury’s Theory of Tyrannicide,” The Review of Politics 50.3 (1988): 365–389.
“There Are No ‘Bad Kings’: Tyrannical Characters and Evil Counsellors in Medieval Political Thought,” in Evil Lords: Theories and Representations of Tyranny from Antiquity to the Renaissance, ed. Nikos Panou and Hester Schadee (New York: Oxford Academic, 2018).
“Three Concepts of Tyranny in Western Medieval Political Thought,” Contributions to the History of Concepts 14.2 (2019): 1–22.
“Tyranny,” in Encyclopedia of Medieval Philosophy, ed. Henrik Lagerlund (Dordrecht: Springer, 2017).
Niewiński, Andrzej, “The Teutonic Propaganda and the Activity of the Polish Diplomacy at the Beginning of the 15th Century,” in War in History: The History of Polish and General Military Science, ed. Andrzej Niewiński (Lublin: Wydawnictwo Episteme, 2017).
Oertel, Christian, “Wenceslaus alter Nero. Die Darstellung Wenzels IV. in der Historiographie des spaten 14. und 15. Jahrhunderts,” Deutsches Archiv für Erforschung des Mittelalters 75 (2018): 673–702.
Ożog, Krzysztof, “Poloni […] sunt Deo odibiles heretici et impudici canes: Refleksje nad poglądami Jana Falkenberga OP († ok. 1435) o Polakach i Polsce,” in Dominikanie o Polsce i Polakach od XIII do XX wieku, ed. Tomasz Gałuszka and Katarzyna Matyja (Krakow: Dominikański Instytut Historyczny and Wydawnictwo W drodze, 2020).
Paravicini Bagliani, Agostino, Bonifacio VIII (Torino: Einaudi, 2003). Provvidente, Sebbastian, “The Causa of Johannes Falkenberg and Synodal Praxis at the Council of Constance (1414–1418): Between Council and Pope,” Filosofiya. Zhurnal Vysshey shkoly ekonomiki 6.4 (2022): 61–98.
Rollo-Koster, Joelle, Avignon and Its Papacy (1309–1417): Popes, Institutions, and Society (Lanham: Rowman, 2015).
“Civil Violence and the Initiation of the Schism,” in A Companion to the Great Western Schism (1378–1417),” ed. Joelle Rollo-Koster and Thomas Izbicki (Leiden and Boston: Brill, 2009).
The Great Western Schism, 1378–1417: Performing Legitimacy, Performing Unity (Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press, 2022).
“The Politics of Body Parts: Contested Topographies in Late Medieval Avignon,” Speculum: A Journal of Medieval Studies 78.1 (2003): 66–98.
Raiding Saint Peter: Empty Sees, Violence, and the Initiation of the Great Western Schism (1378) (Leiden and Boston: Brill, 2008).
Skrzypczak, Karol, Occire le tyran: Présentation et édition critique des textes sur la justification du duc de bourgogne (1408–1410) (PhD diss., Universite d’Orleans, 2022).
Thery, Julien, “A Heresy of State: Philip the Fair, the Trial of the ‘Perfidious Templars,’ and the Pontificalization of the French Monarchy,” Journal of Medieval Religious Cultures 39.2 (2013): 117–148.
“The Pioneer of Royal Theocracy. Guillaume de Nogaret and the Conflicts between Philip the Fair and the Papacy,” in The Capetian Century, 1214–1314, ed. William Chester Jordan and Jenna Rebecca Phillips (Turnhout: Brepols, 2017).
Ubl, Karl, “Die Figur des Tyrannen. Herrscherkritik im Zeitalter Philipps des Schonen (1285–1314),” in Gewalt und Widerstand in der politischen Kultur des späten Mittelalters, ed. Martin Kintzinger, Frank Rexroth and Jorg Rogge, Vortrage und Forschungen 80 (Ostfildern: Jan Thorbecke Verlag, 2015).
Ullmann, Walter, The Origins of the Great Schism: A Study in Fourteenth-Century Ecclesiastical History (London: Burns, Oates, and Washbourne, 1948).
Weiss, Stefan, “Luxury and Extravagance at the Papal Court in Avignon and the Outbreak of Great Western Schism,” in A Companion to the Great Western Schism, ed. Joelle Rollo-Koster and Thomas Izbicki (Leiden and Boston: Brill, 2009).
Włodek, Zofia, “La Satire de Jean Falkenberg: Texte inedit avec introduction,” Mediaevalia Philosophica Polonorum 18 (1973): 51–96.
Wunsch, Thomas, Konziliarismus und Polen: Personen, Politik und Programme aus Polen zur Verfassungsfrage der Kirche in der Zeit der mittelalterlichen Reformkonzilien. Konziliengeschichte. Reihe B: Untersuchungen 7 (Paderborn: Brill Schoningh, 1998).
Tomas Baranauskas, “Medieval Lithuania – Sources 1283–1386,” https://web.archive.org/web/20220408111626/http://viduramziu.istorija.net/en/s1283.htm.
“Vladislaus […] rex Polonie, Lithuanieque princeps supremus […].” The Wroblewski Library of the Lithuanian Academy of Sciences, https://elibrary.mab.lt/handle/1/2559.
“Wenceslaus,” in Encyclopedia of World Biography, 2nd ed., vol. 16 (Gale, 2004).
Gale eBooks, link.gale.com/apps/doc/CX3404706806/GVRL?u=rhode&sid=bookmark-GVRL&xid=2be31dc5.
