An Aristotelean Argument for Unity of Regimes in Dominican and Jesuit Papalist Writings
Abstract
Aristotle, arguing for the ‘Unmoved Mover’ in the Metaphysics, quoted Homer on the need for one leader. The Metaphysics, in Latin, included that quotation. Thomas Aquinas used examples from daily life in interpreting the Metaphysics. However, Dominicans, followed by the Jesuits, reversed this argument, saying Aristotle indicated the need for a single ruler in any polity. According to them, that ruler was the pope in the Church. In the sixteenth century this argument was attacked by John Calvin. Robert Bellarmine replied, rejecting Calvin’s interpretation of Aristotle’s text. However, in the seventeenth century, the entire argument from the Metaphysics ceased to have a place in political discourse.
Keywords:
Aristotle, Thomas Aquinas, medieval papalism, Dominicans, JesuitsReferences
Albertus Magnus, De animalibus libri XXVI, nach den Cölner Urschrift, ed. Hermann Stadler (Münster: Aschendorff, 1920).
Aristotle, Metaphysics, ed. W. D. Ross, 2 vols. (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1924).
The Metaphysics, Volume II: Books 10–14. Oeconomica. Magna Moralia, trans. Hugh Tredennick. Loeb Classical Library 287 (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1935).
Metaphysica, Lib. I–XIV: recensio et translatio Guillemi de Moerbeka, Editio textus, ed. Gudrun Vuillemin-Diem. Aristoteles Latinus XXV 3.2 (Leiden: Brill, 1995).
Augustine of Ancona, Summa de potestate ecclesiastica (Lyon: Petrus Ungarus, 1484).
Dante, Monarchia, trans. Richard Key (Toronto: Pontifical Institute of Medieval Studies, 1998).
Francisco de Vitoria, Relectiones theologicae R. P. Fr. Francisci Victoriae, 2 vols. (Madrid: Manuel Martin, 1765).
Political Writings, ed. and trans. Anthony Pagden and Jeremy Lawrence (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1991).
Francisco Suárez, Selections from Three Works, ed. Thomas Pink (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1976).
Hervaeus Natalis, Hervei Natalis Britonis in quattuor libros sententiarum commentaria (Farnborough: Gregg, [1647] 1966).
Homer, Iliad. Books 1–12, trans. A. T. Murray and William F. Wyatt. Loeb Classical Library 170 (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1999).
John Calvin, Institutio christianae religionis (Geneva: apud Iacobum Stoer, 1618).
Institutes of the Christian Religion, trans. John Allen, 2 vols. (Philadelphia: Presbyterian Board of Christian Education, 1909).
John of Ragusa, Tractatus de ecclesia, ed. Franjo Šanjek (Zagreb: Hrvatska Dominikanska Provincija, 1983).
Juan de Torquemada, Questiones spiritualis conuiuij delicias preferentes super euangeliis tam de tempore quam de sanctis (Lyon: Gueynard, 1509).
Summa de ecclesia (Venice: Michael Tramezinus, 1561).
Apparatus super decretum Florentinum unionis Graecorum, ed. Emmanuel Candal (Rome: Pontificium Institutum Orientalium Studiorum, 1942).
Oratio synodalis de primatu, ed. Emmanuel Candal (Rome: Pontificium Institutum Orientalium Studiorum, 1954).
Marsilius of Padua, The Defender of Peace: The Defensor Pacis, trans. Alan Gewirth (New York: Columbia University Press, 1956).
Petrus Paludanus, Tractatus de potestate papae (Bibl. de la Ville, 744), ed. Petrus T. Stella (Zürich: Pas-Verlag, 1966).
Ptolemy of Lucca, On the Government of Rulers, De regimine principum, trans. James M. Blythe (Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 1997).
Robert Bellarmine, Opera omnia, 6 vols. (Naples: apud Josephum Giuliano, 1856–1862).
Thomas Aquinas, Opera omnia, 50 vols. (Rome: Editio Leonina, 1889–2000).
Summa theologiae… tomus primus, complectens primam partem (Ottawa: Studii Generalis O. P., 1953).
Thomas Hobbes, Leviathan or the Matter, Forme & Power of a Commonwealth, Ecclesiastical and Civil, ed. A. R. Waller (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1935).
Thomas of Cantimpré, Bonum universale de apibus (Douai: ex Typographia Baltazaris Belleri, 1627).
Three Tracts on Empire: Engelbert of Admont, Aeneas Silvius Piccolomini and Juan de Torquemada, ed. Cary J. Nederman (Bristol: Thoemmes, 2000).
Berger, Adolf, Encyclopedic Dictionary of Roman Law (Philadelphia: American Philosophical Society, 1968).
Botley, Paul, Latin Translation in the Renaissance: The Theory and Practice of Leonardo Bruni, Giannozzo Manetti and Desiderius Erasmus (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2004).
Canning, Joseph, A History of Medieval Political Thought 300–1450 (London: Routledge, 1996).
Cassell, Anthony K., The Monarchia Controversy: An Historical Study with Accompanying Translations of Dante Alighieris Monarchia, Guido Vernanis Refutation of the Monarchia composed by Dante and Pope John XXIIs Bull, Si fratrum (Washington, DC: Catholic University of America Press, 2004).
Conciliarism and Papalism, ed. J. H. Burns and Thomas M. Izbicki (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1997).
Condren, Conal, “Marsilius of Padua’s Argument from Authority: A Survey of Its Significance in the Defensor pacis,” Political Theory 5 (1977): 205–218.
Dunbabin, Jean, A Hound of God: Pierre de la Palud and the Fourteenth-Century Church (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1991).
Falkheid, Unn, The Avignon Papacy Contested: An Intellectual History from Dante to Catherine of Siena (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 2017).
Jedin, Hubert, “Juan de Torquemada und das Imperium Romanum,” Archivum Fratrum Praedicatorum 12 (1943): 247–278.
Kaeppeli, Thomas and Emilio Panella, Scriptores Ordinis Praedicatorum medii aevi, 4 vols. (Rome: ad S. Sabinae, 1970–1993).
Mansi, Gian Domenico, Sacrorum conciliorum nova, et amplissima collectio, 53 vols. (Graz: Akademische Druck- und Verlagsanstalt, [1901–1927] 1961).
Maritain, Jacques, The Things That Are Not Caesar’s, trans. James Scanlan (London: Sheed & Ward, 1930).
McCready, William D., The Theory of Papal Monarchy in the Fourteenth Century: Guillaume de Pierre Godin, “The Tractatus de causa immediata ecclesiastice potestatis” (Toronto: Pontifical Institute of Medieval Studies, 1982).
Nederman, Cary J., “Aristotle as Authority: Alternative Aristotelian Sources of Late Medieval Political Thought,” History of European Ideas 4 (1987): 31–44.
“Nature, Sin and the Origins of Society: The Ciceronian Tradition in Medieval Political Thought,” Journal of the History of Ideas 49 (1998): 3–26.
Lineages of European Political Thought: Explorations along the Medieval/Modern Divide from John of Salisbury to Hegel (Washington, DC: Catholic University of America Press, 2009).
Oakley, Francis, The Conciliarism Tradition: Constitutionalism in the Catholic Church 1300– 1870 (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2003).
Syros, Vasileios, Die Rezeption der aristotelischen-politischen Philosophie bei Marsilius von Padua: Eine Untersuchung zur ersten Diktion des Defensor pacis (Leiden: Brill, 2008).
Taylor, Andrew, “Introduction: The Translations of Renaissance Latin,” Canadian Review of Comparative Literature 41 (2014): 329–353.
Tierney, Brian, Foundations of the Conciliar Theory: The Contribution of the Medieval Canonists from Gratian to the Great Schism (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1955).
Wilks, Michael, The Problem of Sovereignty in the Later Middle Ages: The Papal Monarchy with Augustinus Triumphus and the Publicists (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1963).
Corpus Thomisticum. Sancti Thomae de Aquino Sententia libri Metaphysicae, XII: https://www.corpusthomisticum.org/cmp12.html
Rutgers University https://orcid.org/0000-0003-4167-6237
