Did Eustathius the Philosopher Become Eustathius of Sebastea? A Contribution to Federico Fatti’s Hypothesis
Abstract
In 2009, Federico Fatti published a hypothesis that Eustathius the Philosopher, described by Eunapius, converted to Christianity and became bishop of Sebastea and master to Basil the Great. In my article I present Fatti’s hypothesis and solve three important problems that he left unclear: the place of birth of two Eustathiuses, the problem of Letter 35 by Julian and the mystery of the year 358, when Eustathius of Sebastea was already bishop and Eustathius the Philosopher is believed to have been sent by the emperor to Persia despite his Hellenic faith. When those issues that could challenge Fatti’s thesis have been clarified, his claim, I think, gains plausibility close to certainty. The identification of two Eustathiuses helps explain certain mysteries in the life of Eustathius the Philosopher and some peculiar features of the ascetic movement initiated by Eustathius of Sebastea. It is also a milestone in understanding the teaching of the Cappadocian Fathers as it provides us with a direct link between them and Neoplatonism and more specifically its Syrian branch initiated by Iamblichus.
Keywords:
Eustathius the Philosopher, Eustathius of Sebastea, Basil of Caesarea, Eunapius, Neoplatonism, asceticismSupporting Agencies:
National Science Center of PolandReferences
Ammianus Marcellinus, Res gestae, ed. J.C. Rolfe, The surviving books of the History, Cambridge – London 1935.
Basilius Caesariensis, Lettres, ed. Y. Courtonne, v. 1-3, Paris 1957-1966.
Canones Synodi Gangrensis, ed. P.-P. Joannou, Synode de Gangres, in: Fonti, fasc. IX: Discipline generale antique (IVe-IXe s.), v. 1/2: Les canons des Synodes particuliers, Roma 1962, p. 83-99, tr. O.L. Yarbrough, Canons from the Council of Gangra, in: Ascetic Behavior in Greco-Roman Antiquity. A sourcebook, ed. V.L. Wimbush, Minneapolis 1990, p. 449-454.
Eunapio, Vite di filosofi e sofisti, tr. M. Civiletti, Milano 2007.
Eunapius, Vitae sophistarum, ed. G. Giangrande, Eunapii vitae sophistarum, Roma 1956, tr. E.W.C. Wright, in: Philostratus and Eunapius, The lives of the Sophists, London – New York 1922.
Hilarius, Collectanea antiariana parisina, in: S. Hilarii Episcopi Pictaviensis, Opera pars quarta, ed. A.L. Feder, CSEL 65, Vindobonae – Lipsiae 1916, p. 39-177.
Iamblichus, De vita Pythagorica, ed. L. Deubner – U. Klein, Stuttgart 1975, tr. G. Clark, On the Pythagorean Life, Liverpool 1989.
Julianus, Lettres et fragments, ed. J. Bidez, in: L’empereur Julien, Oeuvres complètes, v. 1/2, Paris 1960.
Philostorgius, Kirchengeschichte, ed. J. Bidez, GCS 21, Berlin 1981. (Crossref)
Socrates Scholasticus, Kirchengeschichte, ed. G.C. Hansen, GCS NF 1, Berlin 1995. (Crossref)
Sozomenus, Kirchengeschichte, ed. G.C. Hansen, GCS 50, Berlin 1960.
Baltussen H., Eunapius’ Lives of Philosophers and Sophists: Was He Constructing “Pagan Saints” in the Age of Christianity?, in: Eastern Christianity and Late Antique Philosophy, ed. E. Anagnostou-Laoutides – K. Parry, Leiden – Boston 2020, p. 239‑260. (Crossref)
Becker M., Eunapios aus Sardes Biographien über Philosophen und Sophisten. Einleitung, Übersetzung, Kommentar, Stuttgart 2013. (Crossref)
Buck D.F., Eunapius of Sardis, Oxford 1977 (diss.).
Dam R. van, Families and Friends in Late Roman Cappadocia, Philadelphia 2003.
Fairbairn D., The Synod of Ancyra (358) and the Question of the Son’s Creaturehood, “The Journal of Theological Studies” 64 (2013) p. 110-136. (Crossref)
Fatti F., Eustazio di Sebaste, Eustazio filosofo: un ipotesi sul destinatario di Bas. ep. 1 e sull’identità di Eunap. VS VI, 5, 1–6; 5; 8, 3–9, in: Church, Society and
Monasticism. Acts of the International Symposium, Rome, May 31–June 3, 2006, ed. E. López-Tello García – B. Selene Zorzi, Sankt Ottilien 2009, p. 443-473.
Fatti F., “Fu casta senza superbia”. Ascesi e dinastia in Cappadocia nella Tarda Antichità, “Rivista di storia del cristianesimo” 8/2 (2011) p. 279-304.
Fatti F., Giuliano a Cesarea. La politica ecclesiastica del principe apostate, Roma 2009.
Fatti F., Nei panni del vescovo. Gregorio, Basilio e il filosofo Eustazio, in: Le trasformazioni delle elites in età tardoantica. Atti del Convegno Intemazionale (Perugia, 15-16 marzo 2004), ed. R. Lizzi Testa, Roma 2006, p. 177-238.
Fatti F., Monachesimo anatolico. Eustazio di Sebastia e Basilio di Cesarea, in: Monachesimo orientale. Un’introduzione, ed. G. Filoramo, Brescia 2010, p. 53-91.
Fowden G., Pagan philosophers in late antique society: with special reference to Iamblichus and his followers, Oxford 1979 (diss.).
Frazee C.A., Anatolian Asceticism in the Fourth Century: Eustathios of Sebastea and Basil of Caesarea, “Catholic Historical Review” 66 (1980) p. 16-33.
Gams P.B., Series episcoporum Ecclesiae catholicae, Graz 1873.
Giangrande G., Osservazioni sopra il testo delle Vitae sophistarum di Eunapio, “Bollettino dei classici greci e latini” 3 (1954) p. 77-92.
Goulet R., Eustathe de Cappadoce, in: Dictionnaire des philosophes antiques, v. 3, ed. R. Goulet, Paris 2000, p. 369-378.
Goulet R., Prohérésius le païen et quelques remarques sur la chronologie d’Eunape de sardes, “An Tard” 8 (2000) p. 209-222. (Crossref)
Gribomont J., Saint Basile, Évangile et Église. Mélanges, Bégrolles-en Mauges 1984.
Gribomont J., Eustathe le philosophe et les voyages du jeune Basile de Césarée, “Revue d’histoire ecclésiastique” 54 (1959) p. 115-124.
Hauschild W.-D., Eustathius von Sebaste, in: Theologische Realenzyklopädie, v. 10, Berlin – New York 1982. (Crossref)
Jurgens W.A., Eustathius of Sebaste, Romae 1959.
Kaldellis A., Hellenism in Byzantium. The Transformations of Greek Identity and the Reception of the Classical Tradition, New York 2008. (Crossref)
Quien M. Le, Oriens christianus, in quatuor patriarchatus digestus, v. 1, Parisiis 1740.
Lewin A., Il filosofo Eustazio nelle Vitae Sophistarum di Eunapio di Sardi, “Scripta Classica Israelica” 7 (1983) p. 92-100.
Loofs F., Eustathius von Sebaste und die chronologie der Basilius-Briefe. Eine patristische Studie, Halle 1898.
Malingrey A.-M., Philosophia. Étude d’un groupe de mots dans la littérature grecque, des Présocratiques au IVe siècle après J.-C, Paris 1961.
Marcos M., Julian, Aetius and ‘the Galileans’, “Classical Quarterly” 70/2 (2020) p. 865‑870. (Crossref)
Norton P., Episcopal elections 250-600. Hierarchy and popular will in Late Antiquity, New York 2007. (Crossref)
Penella R.J., Greek Philosophers and Sophists in the Fourth Century A.D. Studies in Eunapius of Sardis, Leeds 1990.
Przyszychowska M., The date of the Council of Gangra – reconsidered (358), “Journal of Early Christian Studies” 30/2 (2022) p. 217-237. (Crossref)
Przyszychowska M., Fatherland (πατρίς) in Basil of Caesarea, “Polish Journal of Political Science” 5/3 (2019) p. 7-27.
Przyszychowska M., Macrina the Younger as a Substitute for Eustathius the Philosopher/Eustathius of Sebastea. Establishing Peter at the See of Sebastea, Warsaw 2022.
Sacks K.S., The Meaning of Eunapius’ History, “History and Theory” 25/1 (1986) p. 52‑67. (Crossref)
Schramm M., Freundschaft im Neuplatonismus: Politisches Denken und Sozialphilosophie von Plotin bis Kaiser Julian, Berlin – Boston 2013. (Crossref)
Seek O., Die Briefe des Libanius zeitlich geordnet, Leipzig 1906.
Suso Frank K., Monastische Reform im Altertum. Eustathius von Sebaste und Basilius von Caesarea, in: Reformatio Ecclesiae. Beiträge zu kirchlichen Reformbemühungen von der Alten Kirche bis zur Neuzeit. Festgabe für Erwin Iserloh, ed. R. Bäumer, Padeborn 1980, p. 35-49.
Tenšek T.Z., L’ascetismo nel Concilio di Gangra. Eustazio di Sebaste nell’ambiente ascetico siriaco dell’Asia Minore nel IV° secolo. Excerpta ex dissertatione ad Doctoratum in Facultatae Theologiae Pontificiae Universitatis Gregorianae, Romae 1991.
Tillemont L.S. Le Nain de, Mémoires pour servir à l’histoire écclésiastique des six premiers siècles, v. 9, Paris 1703.
Watts E., Orality and Communal Identity in Eunapius; Lives of Philosophers and Sophists, “Byzantion” 75 (2005) p. 334-361.
Independent researcher https://orcid.org/0000-0002-7594-073X
License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
Papers published in Vox Patrum are covered by the Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-ND 4.0) licence. Authors and users can use published works licensed under the CC-BY-ND since 2018. For earlier publications, copyrights are available under fair use rights in accordance with the Act of February 4, 1994 on copyrights and related rights.
