Antioch and Alexandria – were they always theologically polarized? The problem of God’s transcendence and immanence in the theology of Cyril of Alexandria and John Chrysostom
Viktor Zhukovskyy
Ukraiński Katolicki Uniwersytet we Lwowie , UkraineAbstract
Cyril of Alexandria did not treat the problem of God’s transcendence and immanence as extensively and profoundly as did John Chrysostom, due to the fact that the question was not as relevant in Cyril’s time as is was in the time of Chrysostom. However, the ideas of the latter are present in the writings of Cyril, who draws a distinction between the inner being of God and His work. This similarity can be traced in two main points. First, God in His essential nature surpasses everything. This inner life of God is above and beyond any knowledge and reach, any concept and reasoning. All that we know about the nature of God is that He acts in the world and this action is performed by the Father through the Son in the Spirit. Second, in order to outline God’s action, Cyril uses the terms „power” and „energy” indistinguishably. For both authors the method of antinomy is a primary system of coordinates in which they combine the two fundamentally opposite poles of God’s being: the transcendent and the immanent. So, in this point the Oriental Theological Schools of Alexandria and Antioch are internally consonant.
Keywords:
Cyril of Alexandria, John Chrysostom, God’s transcendence, God's immanenceReferences
Atanazy, Orationes adversus Arianos, PG 26
Contos L.C., The Essence-Energies Structure of Saint Gregory Palamas with a Brief Examination of its Patristic Foundation, GOT 12 (1967)
Cyrillus Alexandrinus, De incarnatione Unigeniti, ed. G.M. de Durand, SCh 97, Paris 1964
Cyrillus Alexandrinus, De sancta et consubstantiali Trinitate dialogi, ed. G.M. de Durand, SCh 231, Paris 1976
Cyrillus Alexandrinus, Quod unus sit Christus
Cyrillus Alexandrinus, Thesaurus de sancta et consubstantiali Trinitate, PG 75
Damian T., A Few Considerations of the Uncreated Energies in St. Gregory Palamas’ Theology and His Continuity with the Patristic Tradition, „The Patristic and Byzantine Review” 15 (1996-1997)
Evdokimov P., Eschatological Transcendence, w: Orthodoxy: Life and Freedom, Essays in honour of Archbishop Iakovos, ed. A.J. Philippou, Oxford 1973
Florowski G., St. Gregory Palamas and the Tradition of the Fathers
Florovsky G., The Concept of Creation in St. Athanasius, StPatr 6 (1962)
Gregorius Palamas, Capita CL: physica, theologica, moralia et practica, PG 150
Gregorius Palamas, Theophanes, PG 150
Habra G., The Patristic Sources of the Doctrine of Gregory Palamas on the Divine Energies, „Easter Christian Quarterly” 12 (1957)
Joannes Chrysostomus, Catecheses ad illuminandos
Joannes Chrysostomus, Commentarius in Iob, ed. H. Sorlin – L. Neyrand, SCh 346, Paris 1988
Joannes Chrysostomus, De capto Eutropio et de divitiarum vanitate hom., PG 52
Joannes Chrysostomus, De incomprehensibili Dei natura contra Anomoeos, PG 48
Joannes Chrysostomus, Expositio in Ps., PG 55
Joannes Chrysostomus, In Acta Apostolorum hom.
Joannes Chrysostomus, In Epistulam ad Colossenses hom., PG 62
Joannes Chrysostomus, In Joannem hom., PG 59
Nadal J.S., La critique par Akindynos de l’herméneutique patristique de Palamas, „Istina” 19 (1974)
Papadopoulos S.G., The Holy Trinity and the Parousia of the Holy Spirit according to St. John Chrysostom
Russell N., The Doctrine of Deification in the Greek Patristic Tradition, Oxford 2006
Thomas de Aquino, Summa theologica
Гренц С. – Олсон Р., Богословие і богословы ХХ века, перев. О. Розенберг, Колоквиум 2011
Карташев В., Вселенские Соборы, Москва 1994
Лосский В., Очерк мистического богословия Восточной Церкви, перев. В.А. Рещиковой, Москва 1991
Мейендорф И., Введение в святоотеческое богословие, Киев 2002
Ukraiński Katolicki Uniwersytet we Lwowie
License
Pursuant to the Act on Copyright and Related Rights of February 4, 1994, the Author of the publication grants the Publisher of the journal "Vox Patrum" a non-exclusive and free license to use the Work submitted for publication for an indefinite period of time on an unlimited territory in the following fields of use:
a. In the field of recording and reproducing the work - producing copies of the work using a specific technique, including printing, reprographic, magnetic recording and digital technology;
b. Within the scope of trading in the original or copies on which the work has been recorded - marketing, lending or renting the original or copies;
c. In the scope of disseminating the work in a manner other than specified in point b - public performance, exhibition, display, reproduction, broadcasting and rebroadcasting, as well as making the work available to the public, so that everyone can have access to it at a place and time chosen by them.
Moreover, the Author allows the Publisher free of charge to use and dispose of the compilations of the Works.
The publisher may grant sub-licenses.
Third parties may use the Works and other materials containing or based on the Works in accordance with the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 (also known as CC-BY-NC 4.0) license pattern.
