Jesus, Magician or Miracle Worker?


Abstrakt

This paper sets out to answer the question, was Jesus considered a magician? And if so, why? In the face of a current inconclusive debate, using unsuitable definitions of magic, and likely entangled with twenty-first-century definitions, the second-century data is engaged to help re-sensitize a reading of the gospel data. There are clear charges of magic in the second century that enable twenty-first-century readers to see that observers of Jesus’ ministry charged him with magic, but not for the reasons usually assumed. Some contemporary implications of this study are taken up in a contemporary coda.


Słowa kluczowe

Beelzebul Controversy; Charismatics; defining magic; Jesus; magic; miracle worker; Pentecostals

Alana, O.E., “Jewish-Hellenistic Magical Influence on Some of Jesus’ Healing Techniques: An Appraisal [in Greek],” Deltio Biblikon Meleton 19 (2000) 90–102.
Anderson, G., Sage, Saint, and Sophist (London – New York: Routledge 1994).
Aune, D.E., “‘Magic’ in Early Christianity and Its Ancient Mediterranean Context: A Survey of Some Recent Scholarship,” Annali distoria dell'esegesi 24 (2007) 229–294.
Aune, D.E., “Magic in Early Christianity,” Aufstieg und Niedergang der römischen Welt 2/23/2 (1980) 1507–1557.
Aune, D.E., Apocalypticism, Prophecy and Magic in Early Christianity: Collected Essays (Tübingen: Mohr Siebeck 2006).
Baldwin, B., Suetonius (Amsterdam: Hakkert 1983).
Bammel, E., “John Did No Miracle,” Miracles: Cambridge Studies in Their Philosophy and History (ed. C.F.D. Moule) (London: Mowbray 1965) 181–202.
Bammel, E., “Zum Testimonium Flavianum (Jos Ant 18, 63–64),” Josephus-Studien. Untersuchingen zu Josephus, dem antiken Judentum und dem Neuen Testament, O. Michel Festschrift (eds. O. Betz – K. Haacker – M. Hengel) (Göttingen: Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht 1974) 9–22.
Bammel, E., Judaica: kleine Schriften (WUNT 1/37; Tübingen: Mohr 1986) I.
Barrett, C.K., The Gospel According to St John (London: SPCK 1978).
Bell, A.A., “Josephus the Satirist: A Clue to the Original Form of the Testimonium Flavianum,” The Jewish Quarterly Review 67 (1976) 16–22.
Benko, S., “Pagan Criticism of Christianity During the First Two Centuries A.D.,” Aufstieg und Niedergang der römischen Welt 2/23/2 (1980) 1055–1118.
Bermejo-Rubio, F., “Was the Hypothetical Vorlage of the Testimonium Flavianum a ‘Neutral’ Text? Challenging the Common Wisdom on Antiquitates Judaicae 18.63–64,” Journal for the Study of Judaism 45 (2014) 326–365.
Betz, H.D., The Greek Magical Papyri in Translation, Including the Demotic Spells. I. Texts (Chicago – London: University of Chicago Press 1986, 2nd ed. 1992).
Blass, F. – Debrunner, A., – Funk, R.W., A Greek Grammar of the New Testament and Other Early Christian Literature (Chicago: University of Chicago Press 1961) (= BDF).
Borret, M., “Sources et Influence du ‘Discours Véritable’,” Origène, Contre Celse (ed. M. Borret) (SC 227; Paris: Cerf 1976) 183–198.
Borret, M., Origène Contre Celse (SC 132, 136, 147, 150, 227; Paris: Cerf 1967–1976) I-V.
Brashear, W.M., “Out of the Closet: Recent Corpora of Magical Texts,” Classical Philology 91 (1996) 372–383.
Broer, I., Die Urgemeinde und das Grab Jesu. Eine Analyse der Grablegungsgeschichte im Neuen Testament (SANT 31; Munich: Kösel 1972).
Brown, R.E., The Death of the Messiah (ABRL; New York: Doubleday 1994) I-II.
Brown, R.E., The Gospel According to John (AB 29/29A; London: Chapman 1971) I-II.
Bruce, F.F., The Acts of the Apostles, 3rd ed. (Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans – Leicester, UK: Apollos 1990).
Busch, P., “War Jesus ein Magier?,” Zeitschrift Für Neues Testament 4 (2001) 25–31.
Carleton Paget, J., “Some Observations on Josephus and Christianity,” Journal of Theological Studies 52 (2001) 539–624.
Chadwick, H., Origen: Contra Celsum (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press 1965).
Chapman, D.W. – Schnabel, E.J., The Trial and Crucifixion of Jesus: Texts and Commentary (WUNT 344; Tübingen: Mohr Siebeck 2015).
Craig, W.L., “The Guard at the Tomb,” New Testament Studies 30 (1984) 273–281.
Cueva, E.P., “Recent Texts on the Ancient World and the Occult,” Classical Bulletin 82 (2006) 181–207.
Daly-Denton, M., “Singing Hymns to Christ As to A God (cf. Pliny Ep. X, 96),” The Jewish Roots of Christological Monotheism (eds. C.C. Newman – J.R. Davila – G.S. Lewis) (SJSJ 63; Leiden: Brill 1999) 277–292.
Danker, F.W. – Bauer, W., – Arndt, W.F. – Gingrich, F.W., “γόης,” Greek-English Lexicon of the New Testament and Other Early Christian Literature, 3rd ed. (Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press 2000) 204.
Danker, F.W. – Bauer, W., – Arndt, W.F. – Gingrich, F.W., “ἔργον,” Greek-English Lexicon of the New Testament and Other Early Christian Literature, 3rd ed. (Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press 2000) 390–391.
Danker, F.W. – Bauer, W., – Arndt, W.F. – Gingrich, F.W., Greek-English Lexicon of the New Testament and Other Early Christian Literature, 3rd ed. (Chicago: University of Chicago Press 2000).
Davies, W.D. – Allison, D.C., The Gospel According to Saint Matthew (ICC; Edinburgh: Clark 1988–1997) I-III.
Day, J., Yahweh and the Gods and Goddesses of Canaan (JSOTSup 265; London – New York: Sheffield Academic Press – Continuum 2002).
Dessau, H., Inscriptiones Latinae Selectae (Berlin: Weidmannos 1902) II/1.
Eisler, R., The Messiah Jesus and John the Baptist (New York: Dial 1931).
Evans, C.A., “Jesus in Non-Christian Sources,” Studying the Historical Jesus: Evaluations of the State of Research (eds. B.D. Chilton – C.A. Evans) (New Testament Tools and Studies 19; Leiden: Brill 1998) 443–478.
Evans-Pritchard, E.E., Witchcraft, Oracles and Magic among the Azande (Oxford: Clarendon 1937).
Feldman, L.H. – G. Hata (eds.), Josephus, Judaism, and Christianity (Detroit, MI: Wayne State University Press 1987).
Feldman, L.H., “On the Authenticity of the Testimonium Flavianum Attributed to Josephus,” New Perspectives on Jewish Christian Relations (eds. E. Carlebach – J.J. Schechter) (Leiden: Brill 2012) 14–30.
Feldman, L.H., Josephus (LCL; Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press – London: Heinemann 1981) IX.
Fitzmyer, J.A., The Acts of the Apostles (AB 31; New York – London: Doubleday 1998).
Foakes Jackson, F.J. – Lake, K. (eds.), The Beginnings of Christianity. Part I. The Acts of the Apostles (London: Macmillan 1920–1933) I–V.
Foster, P., “The Apology of Quadratus,” Expository Times 117 (2006) 353–359.
Frankfurter, D., “Luke’s μαγεία and Garrett’s ‘Magic',” Union Seminary Quarterly Review 47 (1993) 81–89.
Frend, W.H.C., Martyrdom and Persecution in the Early Church (Oxford: Blackwell 1965).
Fuchs, H., “Der Bericht über die Christen in den Annalen des Tacitus,” Tacitus (ed. V. Pöschl) (Weg der Forschung 97; Darmstadt: Wissenschaftliche Buchgesellschaft 1969) 558–604.
Furneaux, H., Cornelii Taciti: Annalium ab Excessu Divi Augusti Libri. The Annals of Tacitus (Oxford: Oxford University Press 1896, Oxford: Clarendon 1907) I–II.
Gaston, L., “Beelzebul,” Theologische Zeitschrift 18 (1962) 247–255.
Gemeinhardt, P., “Magier, Weiser, Gott. Das Bild Jesu bei pagenen antiken Autoren,” Jesus in apokryphen Evangelienüberlieferungen: Beiträge zu außerkanonischen Jesusüberlieferungen aus verschiedenen Sprach- und Kulturtraditionen (eds. J. Frey – J. Schröter) (WUNT 254; Tübingen: Mohr Siebeck 2010) 467–492.
Glare, P.G.W. – Stray, C., Oxford Latin Dictionary (Oxford: Oxford University Press 2012).
Goldberg, G.J., “The Coincidences of the Emmaus Narrative of Luke and the Testimonium of Josephus,” Journal for the Study of the Pseudepigrapha 13 (1995) 59–77.
Goranson, S., “Celsus of Pergamum: Locating a Critic of Early Christianity,” The Archaeology of Difference: Gender, Ethnicity, Class and the ‘Other’ in Antiquity: Studies in Honor of Eric M. Meyers (eds. D.R. Edwards – C.T. McCollough) (Boston, MA: American Schools of Oriental Research 2007) 363–369.
Graf, F., Magic in the Ancient World (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press 1997).
Grant, M., Tacitus: The Annals of Imperial Rome (London: Penguin 1989).
Grant, R.M., “Quadratus, The First Christian Apologist,” A Tribute to Arthur Vöörbus: Studies in Early Christian Literature and Its Environment, Primarily in the Syrian East (ed. R.H. Fischer) (Chicago, IL: Lutheran School of Theology 1977) 177–183.
Grant, R.M., Gnosticism and Early Christianity, 2nd ed. (New York – London: Columbia University Press 1966).
Gray, R., Prophetic Figures in Late Second Temple Jewish Palestine: The Evidence from Josephus (New York – Oxford: Oxford University Press 1993).
Green, P., “The Methods of Ancient Magic,” Times Literary Supplement April 19 (2002) 5–6.
Gundry, R.H., Matthew (Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans 1982).
Hagner, D.A., Matthew 14–28 (WBC 33B; Nashville, TN: Nelson 1995).
Hoffmann, R.J., Celsus On the True Doctrine: A Discourse Against the Christians (New York – Oxford: Oxford University Press 1987).
Horbury, W., “The Benediction of the Minim and Early Jewish-Christian Controversy,” Journal of Theological Studies 33 (1982) 19–61.
Horsley, R.A., Jesus and Magic: Freeing the Gospel Stories from Modern Misconceptions (Eugene, OR: Cascade 2014).
Hull, J.M., Hellenistic Magic and the Synoptic Tradition (Studies in Biblical Theology 2/28; London: SCM 1974).
Jastrow M., Dictionary of the Targumim, Talmud Bavli, Talmud Yerushalmi and Midrashic Literature (New York: Judaica Press 2004).
Johnson, L.T., Among the Gentiles: Greco-Roman Religion and Christianity (AYBRL; New Haven, CT – London: Yale University Press 2009).
Johnston, S.I., “Describing the Undefinable: New Books on Magic and Old Problems of Definition,” History of Religions 43 (2003) 50–54.
Kee, H.C., Medicine, Miracle and Magic in New Testament Times (SNTSMS 55; Cambridge, UK – New York: Cambridge University Press 2005).
Keener, C.S., A Commentary on the Gospel of Matthew (Grand Rapids, MI – Cambridge, UK: Eerdmans 1999).
Kierkegard, S., Papers and Journals: A Selection (London: Penguin 1996).
Kollmann, B., “Jesus and Magic: The Question of Miracles,” Handbook for the Study of the Historical Jesus (eds. T. Holmén – S.E. Porter) (Leiden: Brill 2011) IV, 3057–3085.
Konieczny, P., “Teaching with Wikipedia in a 21st-Century Classroom: Perceptions of Wikipedia and Its Educational Benefits,” Journal of the Association for Information Science & Technology 67/7 (2016) 1523–1534. DOI 10.1002/asi.23616.
Koskenniemi, E., The Old Testament Miracle-Workers in Early Judaism (WUNT 2/206; Tübingen: Mohr Siebeck 2005).
Krenkel, M., Josephus und Lucas: Der schriftstellerische Einfluss des jüdischen Geschichts-schreibers auf den christlichen Nachgewesen (Leipzig: Haessel 1894).
Lambrechet, J. “ἐξίστημι,” Exegetical Dictionary of the New Testament (ed. H. Balz – G. Schneider) (Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans 1991) II, 7–8.
Lampe, W.H. (ed.), “ἔργον,” Patristic Greek Lexicon (Oxford: Clarendon 1961) 546–547.
Lee, G.M., “Guard at the Tomb,” Theology 72 (1969) 169–175.
Lewis, C.S., The Magician’s Nephew (New York: Macmillan 1955).
Lewis, C.T. – Short, C., A Latin Dictionary (Oxford: Clarendon 1879).
Liddell, H.G. – Scott, R. – Jones, H.S., A Greek-English Lexicon, 9th ed. with revised supplement (Oxford: Clarendon 1996) (= LSJ).
Lindars, B., The Gospel of John (London: Oliphants – Marshall, Morgan & Scott 1972).
Lona, H.E., Die ‘Wahre Lehre’ des Kelsos (Kommentar zu frühchristlichen Apologeten 1; Freiburg – Basel – Vienna: Herder 2005).
Maier, J., Jesus von Nazareth in der talmudischen Überlieferung (EdF 82; Darmstadt: Wissenschaftliche Buchgesellschaft 1978).
Martin, R.P., A Hymn of Christ: Philippians 2:5–11 in Recent Interpretation & in the Setting of Early Christian Worship (Downers Grove, IL: InterVarsity 1997).
Martyn, J.L., History and Theology in the Fourth Gospel, 3rd ed. (NTL; Louisville – London: Westminster John Knox 2003).
Mason, S., Josephus and the New Testament, 2nd ed. (Peabody, MA: Hendrickson 2003).
Mason, S., Josephus, Judea, and Christian Origins: Methods and Categories (Peabody, MA: Hendrickson 2009).
Meier, J.P., A Marginal Jew: Rethinking the Historical Jesus. I. The Roots of the Problem and the Person (New York: Doubleday 1991).
Nock, A.D., Conversion: The Old and the New in Religion from Alexander the Great to Augustine of Hippo (Oxford: Oxford University Press 1933).
Olson, K.A., “A Eusebian Reading of the Testimonium Flavianum,” Eusebius of Caesarea: Tradition and Innovations (eds. A. Johnson – J. Schott) (Hellenic Studies 60; Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press – Center for Hellenic Studies 2013) 97–114.
Olson, K.A., “Eusebius and the Testimonium Flavianum,” The Catholic Biblical Quarterly 61 (1999) 305–322.
Osman, K., “The Free Encyclopaedia that Anyone can Edit: The Shifting Values of Wikipedia Editors,” Culture Unbound: Journal of Current Cultural Research 6/3 (2014) 593–607. DOI 10.3384/cu.2000.1525.146593.
Pelletier, A., “Ce que Josèphe a dit de Jésus (Ant. XVIII 63–64),” Revue des Études juives 124 (1965) 9–21.
Pervo, R.I., Acts (Hermeneia; Minneapolis, MN: Fortress 2009).
Phillips, C.R., “Nulum Crimen sine Lege: Socioreligious Sanctions on Magic,” Magika Hiera: Ancient Greek Magic and Religion (eds. C.A. Faraone – D. Obbink) (New York – Oxford: Oxford University Press 1991) 260–276.
Porter, S.E., “How Do We Know What We Think We Know? Methodological Reflections on Jesus Research,” Jesus Research: New Methodologies and Perspectives (ed. J.H. Charlesworth) (Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans 2014) 82–99.
Preisker, H., “μαίνομαι,” Theological Dictionary of the New Testament (eds. G. Kittel – G. Friedrich) (Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans 1967) IV, 360–361.
Rajak, T., Josephus (London: Duckworth 2002).
Reimer, A.M., “Virtual Prison Breaks: Non-Escape Narratives and the Definition of ‘Magic’,” Magic in the Biblical World: From the Rod of Aaron to the Ring of Solomon (ed. T.E. Klutz) (London – New York: Clark 2003) 125–139.
Reimer, A.M., Miracle and Magic: A Study in the Acts of the Apostles and the Life of Apollonius of Tyana (JSNTSup 235; London: Sheffield Academic Press 2002).
Salzmann, J.C., “Pliny (ep. 10,96) and Christian Liturgy – A Reconsideration,” Studia patristica 20 (1989) 389–395.
Schäfer, P., “Magic and Religion in Ancient Judaism,” Envisioning Magic: A Princeton Seminar and Symposium (eds. P. Schäfer – H.G. Kippenberg) (Leiden – New York – Cologne: Brill 1997) 19–43.
Schäfer, P., Jesus in the Talmud (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press 2009).
Schreckenberg, H., “Flavius Josephus und die lukanischen Schriften,” Wort in der Zeit: Neutestamentliche Studien, Festgabe für Karl Heinrich Rengstorf (eds. W. Haubeck – M. Bachmann) (Leiden: Brill 1980) 179–209.
Sherwin-White, A.N., The Letters of Pliny: A Historical and Social Commentary (Oxford: Oxford University Press 1998).
Sherwin-White, A.N., Roman Society and Roman Law in the New Testament (Oxford: Oxford University Press 1963).
Smallwood, E.M., “Domitian’s Attitude towards the Jews and Judaism,” Classical Philology 51 (1956) 1–13.
Smith, J.Z., “Trading Places,” Ancient Magic and Ritual Power (eds. M. Meyer – P. Mirecki) (RGRW 129; Leiden: Brill 1995) 13–27.
Smith, M., Jesus the Magician (London: Gollancz 1978).
Smith, M., Jesus the Magician (San Francisco, CA: Hampton Roads – Red Wheel – Weiser 2014).
Smith, M., Jesus the Magician: Charlatan or Son of God? (Berkeley, CA: Seastone 1998).
Stanton, G.N., “Jesus of Nazareth: A Magician and a False Prophet who Deceived God’s People?,” Jesus of Nazareth: Lord and Christ: Essays on the Historical Jesus and New Testament Christology (eds. J.B. Green – M. Turner) (Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans – Carlisle, UK: Paternoster 1994) 164–180.
Stanton, G.N., “Jesus of Nazareth: A Magician and a False Prophet who Deceived God’s People?,” G.N. Stanton, Jesus and Gospel (Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press 2004) 127–147.
Stauffer, E., “ἐπιτιμάω, ἐπιτιμία,” Theological Dictionary of the New Testament (ed. G. Kittel – G. Friedrich) (Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans 1964) II, 623–627.
Stewart, A.C., “The Christological Form of the Earliest Syntaxis: The Evidence of Pliny,” Studia Liturgica 41 (2011) 1–8.
Stratton, K.B., Naming the Witch: Magic, Ideology, & Stereotype in the Ancient World (New York: Columbia University Press 2007).
Thackeray, H.St.J., Josephus, The Man and the Historian (New York: Ktav 1967).
Tripp, D.H., “Pliny and the Liturgy – Yet Again,” Studia patristica 15 (1984) 581–585.
Trzcionka, S., Magic and the Supernatural in Fourth-Century Syria (London: Routledge 2007).
Twelftree, G.H., “Beelzebul,” New Interpreter’s Dictionary of the Bible (ed. K. Doob Sakenfeld) (Nashville: Abingdon 2006) I, 417–418.
Twelftree, G.H., “Jesus in Jewish Traditions,” The Jesus Tradition Outside the Gospels (ed. D. Wenham) (Gospel Perspectives 5; Sheffield, UK: JSOT 1984) 289–341.
Twelftree, G.H., “Jesus the Baptist,” Journal for the Study of the Historical Jesus 7 (2009) 103–125.
Twelftree, G.H., “Jesus the Exorcist and Ancient Magic,” A Kind of Magic. Understanding Magic in the New Testament and its Religious Environment (eds. M. Labahn – B.J. Lietaert Peerbolte) (LNTS 306; London – New York: Clark 2007) 57–86.
Twelftree, G.H., Jesus the Exorcist: A Contribution to the Study of the Historical Jesus (WUNT 2.54; Tübingen: Mohr Siebeck 1993).
Twelftree, G.H., Jesus the Miracle Worker: A Historical and Theological Study (Downers Grove, IL: InterVarsity 1999).
Urch, E.J., “Early Roman Understanding of Christianity,” The Classical Journal 27 (1932) 255–262.
Versnel, H.S., “Some Reflections on the Relationship Magic–Religion,” Numen 38 (1991) 177–197.
Wallace-Hadrill, A., Suetonius: The Scholar and His Caesars (New Haven, CT – London: Yale University Press 1984).
Walsh, J.J., “On Christian Atheism,” Vigiliae Christianae 45 (1991) 255–277.
Waters, D., “What Happened to Dungeons and Dragons?,” BBC News Online (26 April, 2004), http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/magazine/3655627.stm.
Wenham, D., “The Resurrection Narratives in Matthew’s Gospel,” Tyndale Bulletin 24 (1973) 21–54.
Whealey, A., “Josephus, Eusebius of Caesarea, and the Testimonium Flavianum,” Josephus und das Neue Testament (eds. C. Böttrich – J. Herzer) (Tübingen: Mohr Siebeck 2007) 73–116.
Whealey, A., “The Testimonium Flavianum in Syriac and Arabic,” New Testament Studies 54 (2008) 573–590.
Whealey, A., Josephus on Jesus: The Testimonium Flavianum Controversy From Late Antiquity to Modern Times (Studies in Biblical Literature 36; New York: Lang 2003).
Winter, P., “Excursus II: Josephus on Jesus and James: Ant. xviii 3, 3 (63–4) and xx 9, 1 (200–3),” The History of the Jewish People in the Age of Jesus Christ (ed. E. Schürer et al.) (Edinburgh: Clark 1973) I, 428–241.
Wright, N.T., Jesus and the Victory of God (London: SPCK 1996).
Zeitlin, S., “The Christ Passage in Josephus,” Jewish Quarterly Review (1927–1928) 231–255.
Zeitlin, S., Josephus on Jesus, with Particular Reference to the Slavonic Josephus and the Hebrew Josippon (Philadelphia: Dropsie College for Hebrew and Cognate Learning 1931).
Zeller, E., “Das odium generis humani der Christen,” Zeitschrift für wissenschaftliche Theologie 34 (1891) 356–367.

Opublikowane : 2020-06-15


Twelftree, G. (2020). Jesus, Magician or Miracle Worker?. The Biblical Annals, 10(3), 405-436. https://doi.org/10.31743/biban.9769

Graham H. Twelftree  graham.twelftree@lst.ac.uk
London School of Theology, London, UK  Wielka Brytania




1. Zgodnie z ustawą o prawie autorskim i prawach pokrewnych z dnia 4 lutego 1994r., autor publikacji przekazuje autorskie prawa majątkowe dotyczące składanego dzieła wydawcy czasopisma the Biblical Annals. Przeniesienie praw autorskich do składanego dzieła następuje na wszystkich polach eksploatacji, w szczególności tych wymienionych w art. 50 ustawy o prawie autorskim i prawach pokrewnych:

  • W zakresie utrwalania i zwielokrotniania utworu – wytwarzanie określoną techniką egzemplarzy dzieła, w tym techniką drukarską, reprograficzną, zapisu magnetycznego oraz techniką cyfrową.
  • W zakresie obrotu oryginałem albo egzemplarzami , na których dzieło utrwalono – wprowadzanie do obrotu, użyczenie lub najem oryginału albo egzemplarzy.
  • W zakresie rozpowszechniania utworu w sposób inny niż określony w pkt. 2 – publiczne wykonanie, wystawienie, wyświetlenie, odtworzenie oraz nadawanie i reemitowanie, a także publiczne udostępnianie utworu, aby każdy mógł mieć do niego dostęp w miejscu i czasie przez siebie wybranym.

2. Za zgodą redakcji czasopisma opublikowane artykuły w Biblical Annals mogą być przedrukowywane w innych publikacjach.

3. Redakcja publikuje teksty on line na licencji Creative Commons Uznanie autorstwa-Bez utworów zależnych 3.0 PL.