The Current Debate on the Relationship between Sin and Sickness in John 5:14
Adam Kubiś
The John Paul II Catholic University of Lublin , Polandhttps://orcid.org/0000-0003-4961-2254
Abstract
The article focuses on the understanding of sin in John 5:14, as well as the relationship between sin and sickness presented in this verse. It provides a thorough status quaestionis on both of these issues. After examining various hypotheses regarding the meaning of sin in John 5:14, the Johannine notion of sin as unbelief is expounded as the most convincing. This sin encompasses the past, present, and future life of the healed man. Thus, contrary to the exegetical opinio communis, the cause-and-effect relationship between sin and sickness does not apply to John 5:14. In light of this explanation, the messages of John 5:14 and 9:2–3 do not contradict each other. Jesus’ words in 5:14, intentionally pronounced in the temple, should be understood as an invitation to follow him in faith.
Keywords:
sin, sickness, John 5:14, the Gospel of JohnReferences
Asiedu-Peprah, M., Johannine Sabbath Conflicts as Juridical Controversy. An Exegetical Study of John 5 and 9:1–10:21 (Wissenschaftliche Untersuchungen zum Neuen Testament 2/132; Tübingen: Mohr Siebeck 2001).
Barrett, C.K., The Gospel According to St John. An Introduction with Commentary and Notes on the Greek Text. Second Edition (London: SPCK 1978).
Beasley-Murray, G.R., John, 2 ed. (Word Biblical Commentary 36; Dallas, TX: Word Books 1999).
Bernard, J.H., A Critical and Exegetical Commentary on the Gospel According to St John (The International Critical Commentary; Edinburgh: Clark 1928) I.
Beutler, J., A Commentary on the Gospel of John (Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans 2017).
Boismard, M.-É. – Lamouille, A., L’Évangile de Jean (Synopse des Quatre Évangiles en français 3; Paris: Cerf 1987).
Borchert, G.L., John 1–11 (The New American Commentary 25A; Nashville, TN: Broadman & Holman 1996).
Brant, J.-A., John (Paideia; Grand Rapids, MI: Baker Academic 2011).
Brown, R.E., The Gospel According to John (I–XII). Introduction, Translation and Notes (Anchor Bible 29; New York: Doubleday 1966).
Bruce, P., “John 5:1–18 the Healing at the Pool: Some Narrative, Socio-Historical and Ethical Issues,” Neotestamentica 39/1 (2005) 39–56.
Bryan, S.M., “Power in the Pool: The Healing of the Man at Bethesda and Jesus’ Violation of the Sabbath ( Jn. 5:1–18),” Tyndale Bulletin 54/2 (2003) 7–22. (Crossref)
Carson, D.A., The Gospel According to John (The Pillar New Testament Commentary; Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans 1990).
Cook, W.F., John. Jesus Christ is God (The Focus on the Bible Commentary Series; Fearn, U.K.: Christian Focus Publications 2016).
Croteau, D.A., “Repentance Found? The Concept of Repentance in the Fourth Gospel,” The Master’s Seminary Journal 24/1 (2013) 97–123.
Cullmann, O., Early Christian Worship (Studies in Biblical Theology 10; London: SCM 1953).
Culpepper, R.A., “John 5.1–18: A Sample of Narrative-Critical Commentary,” The Gospel of John as Literature. An Anthology of Twentieth-Century Perspectives (ed. M.W.G. Stibbe) (New Testament Tools and Studies 17; Leiden: Brill 1993) 193–207. (Crossref)
Cyprianus, De habitu virginum. Pseudo-Cyprianea I (eds. P. Mattei – L. Ciccolini) (Corpus Christianorum Series Latina 3F; Turnhout: Brepols 2016).
Cyprianus, Opera. I. Ad Quirinum. Ad Fortunatum. De lapsis. De ecclesiae catholicae unitate (eds. R. Weber – M. Bévenot) (Corpus Christianorum Series Latina 3; Turnhout: Brepols 1972).
De Witt Burton, E., Syntax of the Moods and Tenses in New Testament Greek, 3 ed. (Edinburgh: Clark 1898).
Di Luccio, P., “Priestly Traditions in the Gospel”, Revue biblique 122 (2015) 84–103.
Duprez, A., Jésus et les dieux guérisseurs. Á propos de Jean V (Cahiers de la Revue Biblique 12; Paris: Gabalda 1970).
Finegan, J., The Archeology of the New Testament. The Life of Jesus and the Beginning of the Early Church. Revised Edition (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press 1992). (Crossref)
Ford, D.F., The Gospel of John. A Theological Commentary (Grand Rapids, MI: Baker Academic 2021).
Fuzinato, S., Tra fede e incredulità. Studio esegetico-teologico di Gv 5 in chiave comunicativa (Tesi gregoriana. Serie teologia 212; Roma: Editrice Pontificia Università Gregoriana 2014).
Giambrone, A., “Jesus and the Paralytics. Memorializing Miracles in the Greco-Roman World of the Gospels,” The Biblical Annals 10/3 (2020) 389–404. (Crossref)
Gibson, S., “The Pool of Bethesda in Jerusalem and Jewish Purification Practices of the Second Temple Period,” Proche-Orient Chrétien 55/3–4 (2005) 270–293.
Gibson, S., “The Excavations at the Bethesda Pool in Jerusalem: Preliminary Report on a Project of Stratigraphic and Structural Analysis (1999–2009),” Proche-Orient Chrétien Numéro Spécial (2011) 17–44.
de Goedt, M., “Un schème de révélation dans le quatrième évangile,” New Testament Studies 8 (1961–1962) 142–150. (Crossref)
Grayston, K., The Gospel of John (Philadelphia, PA: Trinity Press International 1990).
Grelot, P., „L’interprétation pénitentielle du lavement des pieds: examen critique,” L’homme devant Dieu.
Mélanges offerts au Père Henri de Lubac. I. Exégèse et patristique (Théologie 56; Paris: Aubier 1963) 75–91.
Haenchen, E., John 1. A Commentary on the Gospel of John. Chapters 1–6 (Hermeneia; Philadelphia, PA: Fortress 1984).
Harris, M.J., John (Exegetical Guide to the Greek New Testament; Nashville, TN: B&H Academic 2015).
Hendricksen, W., The Gospel According to John (Grand Rapids, MI: Baker Book House 1953).
Hoskyns, E.C., The Fourth Gospel (ed. F.N. Davey) (London: Faber & Faber 1947).
Jeremias, J., The Rediscovery of Bethesda. John 5:2 (New Testament Archaeology Monograph 1; Louisville, KY: Southern Baptist Theological Seminary 1966).
John Chrysostom, St., Discourses against Judaizing Christians (trans. P.W. Harkins) (The Fathers of the Church.
A New Translation 68; Washington, DC: Catholic University of America Press 1979) (= FC).
John Chrysostom, St., On the Incomprehensible Nature of God (trans. P.W. Harkins) (The Fathers of the Church.
A New Translation 72; Washington, DC: Catholic University of America Press 1984) (=FC).
John Chrysostom, St., Commentary on Saint John the Apostle and Evangelist. Homilies 1–47 (trans. T.A. Goggin) (The Fathers of the Church. A New Translation 33; Washington, DC: Catholic University of America Press 2017) (= FC).
Karakolis, C., “«Afterwards, Jesus found him in the Temple». Looking for Implicit Motifs in John 5:14a,” Louvain Studies 42 (2019) 175–189.
Keener, C.S., The Gospel of John. A Commentary (Grand Rapids, MI: Baker Academic 2003).
Klink, E.W., John (Zondervan Exegetical Commentary on the New Testament; Grand Rapids, MI: Zondervan 2016).
Koester, C.R., Symbolism in the Fourth Gospel. Meaning, Mystery, Community, 2 ed. (Minneapolis, MN: Fortress 2003).
Köstenberger, A.J., The Signs of the Messiah. An Introduction to John’s Gospel (Bellingham, WA: Lexham Press 2021).
Kruse, C.G., John. An Introduction and Commentary (Tyndale New Testament Commentaries 4; Downers Grove, IL: InterVarsity 2017).
Kubiś, A., „Interpretacja pokutna Janowego opisu obmycia stóp uczniom przez Jezusa. Cz. 1: Interpretacje sakramentalne na tle współczesnych wyjaśnień J 13,1–20”, The Biblical Annals 8/3 (2018) 379–420. (Crossref)
Kubiś, A., „Interpretacja pokutna Janowego opisu obmycia stóp uczniom przez Jezusa. Cz. 2: Argument odwołujący się do antropologii kulturowej”, The Biblical Annals 8/4 (2018) 567–586. (Crossref)
Kysar, R., John (Augsburg Commentary on the New Testament; Minneapolis, MN: Augsburg 1986).
Lee, D.A., The Symbolic Narratives of the Fourth Gospel. The Interplay of Form and Meaning ( Journal for the Study of the New Testament Supplement Series; Sheffield: JSOT 1994).
Lenski, R.C.H., The Interpretation of St. John’s Gospel (Minneapolis, MN: Augsburg 1961).
Lincoln, A.T., The Gospel According to Saint John (Black’s New Testament Commentaries 4; Peabody, MA: Hendrickson 2005).
Lindars, B., The Gospel of John (New Century Bible; Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans – London: Marshall, Morgan & Scott 1972).
Lysias, Lysias (trans. W.R.M. Lamb) (Loeb Classical Library 244; Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press 1930).
MacGregor, G.H.C., The Gospel of John (The Moffatt New Testament Commentary; London: Hodder & Stoughton 1928).
Martyn, L.J., History and Theology in the Fourth Gospel, 3 ed. (The New Testament Library; Louisville: Westminster John Knox 2003).
Merrill, M.C., John. The Gospel of Belief. An Analytic Study of the Text (Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans 1976).
Metzger, B.M., A Textual Commentary on the Greek New Testament, 2 ed. (Stuttgart: Deutsche Bibelgesellschaft 2002).
Michaels, J.R., The Gospel of John (The New International Commentary on the New Testament; Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans 2010).
Mollat, D., L’Évangile et les Épîtres de Saint Jean (La Sainte Bible traduite en français sous la direction de l’École Biblique de Jérusalem 34; Paris: Cerf 1953).
Moloney, F.J., Signs and Shadows. Reading John 5–12 (Minneapolis, MN: Fortress 1996).
Moloney, F.J., The Gospel of John (Sacra Pagina 4; Collegeville, MN: Liturgical Press 1998).
Montanari, F., The Brill Dictionary of Ancient Greek (Leiden – Boston, MA: Brill 2015).
Morris, L., The Gospel According to John. Revised Edition (The New International Commentary on the New Testament; Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans 1995).
Moulton, J.H. – Howard, W.F. –Turner, N., A Grammar of New Testament Greek (Edinburg: Clark 1909).
Murphy, E., “Sin no more: Healing, Wholeness, and the Absent Adulteress in Cyprian’s Use of John,” Revue d’études augustiniennes et patristiques 64 (2018) 1–15. (Crossref)
Murphy-O’Connor, J., “Saint Anne of Jerusalem. La Piscine Probatique de Jésus à Saladin. Le Projet Béthesda (1994–2010),” Revue biblique 119 (2012) 429–433.
Newman, B.M. – Nida, E.A., A Handbook on the Gospel of John (UBS Handbook Series; New York: United Bible Societies 1980).
O’Day, G.R., “The Gospel of John. Introduction, Commentary, and Reflections,” R.A. Culpepper – G.R. O’Day, The New Interpreter’s Bible (Nashville, TN: Abingdon 1995) IX, 491–865.
Osborne, G.R., The Gospel of John (Cornerstone Biblical Commentary 13; Carol Stream, IL: Tyndale House 2007).
Robertson, A.T., A Grammar of the Greek New Testament in the Light of Historical Research, 3 ed. (London: Hodder & Stoughton 1919).
Schaff, P. (ed.) A Select Library of the Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers of the Christian Church. IX. Saint Chrysostom. On the Priesthood; Ascetic Treatises; Select Homilies and Letters; Homilies on the Statues (New York: The Christian Literature Company 1889) (= NPNCC).
Schnackenburg, R., The Gospel According to St John. II. Commentary on Chapters 5–12 (New York: Crossroad 1990).
Seneca, Moral Essays. III. De Beneficiis (trans. J.W. Basore) (Loeb Classical Library 310; Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1935).
Staley, J.L., “Stumbling in the Dark, Reaching for the Light: Reading Character in John 5 and 9,” Semeia 53 (1991) 55–80.
Swartley, W.M., John (Believers Church Bible Commentary; Harrisonburg, VA: Herald Press 2013).
Szkredka, S., “Postmortem Punishment in the Parable of Lazarus and the Rich Man (Luke 16:19–31): Between Coherence and Indeterminacy of Luke’s Eschatology,” Verbum Vitae 36 (2019) 109–132. (Crossref)
Szymik, S., “Jesus’ Intitulation of God as Abba: Its Sources and Impact on the Idea of the Fatherhood of God in the New Testament,” Verbum Vitae 38/2 (2020) 485–502. (Crossref)
Theodore of Mopsuestia, Commentary on the Gospel of John (trans. M. Conti) (Ancient Christian Texts; Downers Grove, IL: IVP Academic 2010) (= ACT).
Thomas Aquinas, St., Commentary on the Gospel of John (Thomas Aquinas in Translation; Washington, DC: Catholic University of America Press 2010) I.
Thomas, J.C., Footwashing in John 13 and the Johannine Community ( Journal for the Study of the New Testament Supplement Series 61; Sheffield: JSOT Press 1991).
Thomas, J.C., “«Stop Sinning Lest Something Worse Come Upon You»: The Man at the Pool in John 5,” Journal for the Study of the New Testament 59 (1995) 3–20. (Crossref)
Thompson, M.M., John. A Commentary (The New Testament Library; Louisville, KY: Westminster John Knox 2015).
Thompson, R., “Healing at the Pool of Bethesda: A Challenge to Asclepius?,” Bulletin for Biblical Research 27/1 (2017) 65–84. (Crossref)
Van den Bussche, H., “Guérison d’un paralytique à Jérusalem le jour du sabbat: Jean 5,1–18,” Bible et Vie Chrétienne 61 (1965) 18–28.
Van Tilborg, S., Imaginative Love in John (Biblical Interpretation Series 2; Leiden: Brill 1993). (Crossref)
Von Wahlde, U.C., “The Pool of Siloam: The Importance of the New Discoveries for Our Understanding of Ritual Immersion in Late Second Temple Judaism and the Gospel of John,” John, Jesus, and History. II. Aspects of Historicity in the Fourth Gospel (eds. P.N. Anderson – F. Just – T. Thatcher) (Early Christianity and Its Literature 2; Atlanta, GA: Society of Biblical Literature 2009) 155–173. (Crossref)
Von Wahlde, U.C., “The Pool(s) of Bethesda and the Healing in John 5: A Reappraisal of Research and of the Johannine Text,” Revue biblique 116 (2009) 111–136.
Von Wahlde, U.C., The Gospel and Letters of John. I. Introduction, Analysis, and Reference (The Eerdmans Critical Commentary; Grand Rapids, MI – Cambridge, U.K.: Eerdmans 2010).
Von Wahlde, U.C., The Gospel and Letters of John. II. Commentary on the Gospel of John (The Eerdmans Critical Commentary; Grand Rapids, MI – Cambridge, U.K.: Eerdmans 2010).
Von Wahlde, U.C., “The Great Public Miqvaot at Bethesda and Siloam, the Development of Jewish Attitudes Toward Ritual Purity in Late Second Temple Judaism, and Their Implications for the Gospel of John,” Rediscovering John. Essays on the Fourth Gospel in Honour of Frédéric Manns (ed. L.D. Chrupcała) (Milano: Terra Sacta 2013) 267–281.
Wallace, D.B., Greek Grammar Beyond the Basics. An Exegetical Syntax of the New Testament (Grand Rapids, MI: Zondervan 1996).
Weinrich, W.C., John 1:1–7:1 (Concordia Commentary. A Theological Exposition of Sacred Scripture; St. Louis, MO: Concordia 2015).
Wengst, K., Das Johannesevangelium. I. Kapitel 1–10, 2 ed. (TKNT 4; Stuttgart: Kohlhammer 2004).
Westcott, B.F., The Gospel According to St. John. Introduction and Notes on the Authorized Version (London: Murray 1908).
Whitacre, R.A., John (The IVP New Testament Commentary Series 4; Downers Grove, IL: InterVarsity 1999).
Wilkin, R.N., “The Gospel According to John,” The Grace New Testament Commentary. I. Matthew–Acts (ed. R.N. Wilkin) (Denton, TX: Grace Evangelical Society 2010) 357–479.
Witherington, B., John’s Wisdom. A Commentary on the Fourth Gospel (Louisville, KY: Westminster John Knox 1995).
Witkamp, L.T., “The Use of Traditions in John 5.1–18,” Journal for the Study of the New Testament 25 (1985) 19–47. (Crossref)
The John Paul II Catholic University of Lublin https://orcid.org/0000-0003-4961-2254
License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
- Pursuant to the Act on Copyright and Related Rights of February 4, 1994, the Author of the publication grants to the Publisher of the journal „The Biblical Annals” e a non-exclusive and royalty-free license to use the Work submitted for publication, without time and territorial restrictions in the following fields of use:
a) record the Work and copy it by means of any technique (including printing and electronic recording) on all known data carriers (including IT, electronic and polygraphic), and in all IT systems (in particular those available online);
b) enter the Work into computer memory, disseminate the Work and its copies, as well as market the Work and its copies;
c) publicly perform, replay, display and screen the Work, as well as lend, rent and lease the Work and its copies;
d) make available, market and disseminate the Work and its copies via IT networks, and in particular via the Internet, including the promotion or advertising of the Work, the journal or the Publisher. - The Author shall further grant his/her consent for the Publisher to use and dispose of derivative works.
- The Publisher may sublicense the work.
- Third parties may use the articles and other materials containing the Works, or developed on the basis of the Works in line with the model Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (also referred to as CC BY 4.0).
