Extraterritorial application of the right to life on the high sea . Commentary to the Views adopted by the Human Rights Committee of 27 January 2021, A.S., D.I., O.I. and G.D. against Italy, Communication No. 3042/2017
Abstract
The subject matter of this commentary, which instigates the Views of the Human Rights Committee of 27 January 2021, is the protection of one of the fundamental human rights – the right to life. The Committee, as an authority appointed to oversee compliance with the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, had to decide on the issue of Italy’s responsibility for failing to provide assistance to a boat in distress, even if the area in which the vessel was located was not within the territory of this state and other acts of international law attribute the responsibility for executing the rescue operation to a third country. According to the Committee’s views, which applied extraterritorial approach to the protection of the right to life, whenever states have the opportunity to take action for the protection of human rights they should do everything possible in a given situation to help people in need.
Keywords:
Human Rights Committee, right to life, extraterritoriality, Italy, migration, UN, positive obligationsReferences
Busco P., Not All that Glitters Is Gold: the Human Rights Committee’s Test for the Extraterritorial Application of the ICCPR in the Context of Search and Rescue Operations, Opinio Juris, https://opiniojuris.org/2021/03/02/not-all-that-glitters-is-gold-the-human-rightscommittees-test-for-the-extraterritorial-application-of-the-iccpr-in-the-context-ofsearch-and-rescue-operations/ [access: 05.05.2021].
Callamard A., Report of the Special Rapporteur of the Human Rights Council on Extrajudicial,Summary or Arbitrary Executions, https://undocs.org/en/A/75/384 [access: 3.05.2021].
Citroni G., No More Elusion of Responsibility for Rescue Operations at Sea: the Human Rights Committee’s Views on the Case A.S., D.I., O.I. and G.D. v. Italy and Malta, Opinio Juris, https://opiniojuris.org/2021/03/09/no-more-elusion-of-responsibility-for-rescue-operations-at-seathe-human-rights-committees-views-on-the-case-a-s-d-i-o-i-and-g-d-v-italy-and-malta/[access: 4.05.2021].
Directorate-General for Communication (European Commission), UE a kryzys uchodźczy, DOI:10.2775/090543.
Gliszczyńska-Grabias A., in: Międzynarodowy pakt praw obywatelskich (osobistych) i politycznych. Komentarz, ed. R. Wieruszewski, Warszawa 2012.
International Organization for Migration, Missing Migrants Project, https://missingmigrants.iom.int/region/mediterranean [access: 3.05.2021].
Komitet Praw Człowieka ONZ. Wybór orzecznictwa, eds. R. Wieruszewski, A. Gliszczyńska, K. Sękowska-Kozłowska, Warszawa 2009.
Latos B., Klauzula derogacyjna i limitacyjna w Europejskiej konwencji o ochronie praw człowieka i podstawowych wolności, Warszawa 2008.
Mavropoulou E., The Right to Life: Italy Found by UN in Violation of the Right to Life of Migrants at Sea, Human Rights at Sea, https://www.humanrightsatsea.org/2021/01/28/the-right-to-life-italy-found-by-un-in-violation-of-the-right-to-life-of-migrants-at-sea/ [access: 5.05.2021].
Milanovic M., Drowning Migrants in the Mediterranean and the ICCPR, Again, Blog of the European Journal of International Law, https://www.ejiltalk.org/drowningmigrants-in-the-mediterranean-and-the-iccpr-again/ [access: 5.05.2021].
Milanovic M., Drowning Migrants, the Human Rights Committee, and Extraterritorial Human Rights Obligations, Blog of the European Journal of International Law, https://www.ejiltalk.org/drowning-migrants-the-human-rights-committee-and-extraterritorialhuman-rights-obligations/ [access: 5.05.2021].
Momigliano A., Italian Forces Ignored a Sinking Ship Full of Syrian Refugees and Let More than 250 Drown, Says Leaked Audio, The Washington Post, https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/worldviews/wp/2017/05/09/italian-forces-ignored-a-sinking-ship-full-ofsyrian-refugees-and-let-more-than-250-drown-says-leaked-audio/ [access: 4.05.2021].
Wielka Encyklopedia Prawa, vol. 4. Prawo międzynarodowe publiczne, eds. J. Symonides, D. Pyć, Warszawa 2014.
Wieruszewski R., Komitet Praw Człowieka, in: Mechanizmy ochrony praw człowieka w ramach ONZ. Analiza systemowa, ed. R. Wieruszewski, Warszawa 2017.
Uniwersytet Szczeciński https://orcid.org/0000-0002-4328-4491
License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
The Author declares that the Work is original and does not infringe any personal or proprietary rights of third parties, and that She/He has unlimited rights to the Work which are the subject of the Agreement signed with the Publisher.
Author of the publication transfers to the Publisher the economic copyrights to the Work (article) submitted for publication, free of charge, without time and territorial restrictions in the following fields of use:
a) production, recording and reproduction of the copies of the Work by a specific technique, including printing, magnetic recording and digital technology;
b) marketing, lending or rental of the original or copies of the Work, and distribution in the form of open access, in accordance with the license Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (also known as CC BY), available at: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/legalcode.pl;
c) inclusing the Work in the composition of the collective work;
d) publishing on the website of the journal, public performance, exhibition, display, reproduction, broadcasting and rebroadcasting, and making the Work available to the public in such a way that everyone can have access to them in a place and at a time chosen by them;
e) uploading the Work in an electronic form to electronic platforms or other uploading of the Work in an electronic form to the Internet or other network.
The proprietary copyright to the Work is transferred to the Publisher free of charge upon signing the contract wit the Publisher.
