Peer Review Process

Zeszyty Naukowe Katolickiego Uniwersytetu Lubelskiego Jana Pawła II ("KUL Social Issues", ZNKUL) operates a double-anonymous peer review system. Reviewers are not provided with information that would enable them to identify the authors, and authors are not informed of the reviewers’ identities. Information regarding the journal’s review procedures, the individuals involved in the review process, and the manner in which editorial decisions are made is described in the journal’s policies, in accordance with the principles of transparency promoted by COPE, DOAJ, OASPA, and WAME.
The review procedure is as follows.

1. Manuscript Submission

Authors submit the following files through the OJS platform:
- a fully anonymised manuscript;
- a Title Page;
- an Alt Text file, where applicable;
- supplementary materials, if included as part of the submission.
All files must be prepared in accordance with the Author Guidelines. Correspondence concerning the editorial process is conducted primarily through the OJS platform.

2. Technical Screening

Following submission, the Editorial Secretary verifies the completeness of the documentation and the manuscript’s compliance with the journal’s basic formal requirements. At this stage, the manuscript is also screened for textual similarity using Crossref Similarity Check (iThenticate).

A Similarity Score exceeding 20% or similarity to a single source exceeding 5%, after excluding properly cited quotations, references, and other justified exclusions, is considered a threshold requiring additional verification. These thresholds serve as screening criteria and do not automatically constitute evidence of plagiarism or grounds for rejection. Crossref emphasises that iThenticate detects textual similarity rather than plagiarism itself; therefore, the similarity report must always be assessed in light of its nature and context (https://www.crossref.org/documentation/similarity-check/similarity-report-understand).

If the report identifies similarities that raise concerns, the Editorial Office contacts the author and provides an opportunity to submit explanations or make appropriate revisions. In ambiguous cases, the final decision regarding further processing of the manuscript is made by the Editor-in-Chief based on the similarity report, the nature of the identified overlaps, and the author's explanations.
Following successful completion of the technical screening, the manuscript is forwarded to the Editor-in-Chief, who assigns it to an appropriate Academic Editor.

3. Assignment of an Academic Editor

The Editor-in-Chief assigns the manuscript to an Academic Editor, taking into account the subject matter of the submission and the editor’s area of expertise.

4. Initial Editorial Assessment

The Academic Editor conducts an initial assessment of the manuscript, considering in particular:
- its fit with the journal’s scope;
- its scholarly quality;
- the relevance and significance of the research problem;
- basic methodological soundness.

At this stage, one of the following decisions may be made:
- submission to external peer review;
- rejection without external review (desk rejection);
- rejection of the current version with the possibility of submitting a substantially revised manuscript as a new submission.
The journal aims to complete the period from submission to the initial editorial decision within seven days. This target is organisational in nature and does not constitute a guarantee in every case.

5. Selection of Reviewers

If the manuscript is sent for review, the Academic Editor verifies that anonymisation has been properly implemented and appoints two independent reviewers or, where justified by the circumstances, a third reviewer. Reviewers are selected on the basis of expertise relevant to the manuscript’s subject matter, while also considering their independence and any potential conflicts of interest.
The Academic Editor communicates with reviewers through the OJS platform and provides them with the anonymised manuscript.

The Editor-in-Chief and Academic Editor monitor the progress of the review process within OJS. If the process is not progressing according to schedule, particularly when invited reviewers do not respond or decline to undertake the review, additional reviewers may be invited in order to avoid unnecessary delays.

A reviewer who has accepted the invitation will generally receive no more than three reminders, usually at approximately weekly intervals. If a review is not submitted despite these reminders, the Editor-in-Chief or Academic Editor may discontinue waiting for that reviewer and invite another reviewer.

6. First Round of Peer Review

Reviewers prepare independent evaluations of the manuscript. Reviews should be objective, well reasoned, and address:
- the scholarly value of the work;
- the appropriateness of the methods employed;
- the presentation and interpretation of findings;
- the quality of the argumentation;
- the significance of the conclusions.

If two reviews result in substantially divergent recommendations and do not permit a justified editorial decision, the Editor-in-Chief or Academic Editor may appoint a third reviewer.

7. Decisions Following Peer Review

Following completion of the review round and consideration of the reviewers’ reports, one of the following decisions may be made:

A. - Acceptance – the author implements any requested amendments, and the revised version is assessed by the Editor-in-Chief or Academic Editor without further external review.
B. - Revision without further peer review – the author submits revisions, which are assessed by the Editor-in-Chief or Academic Editor.
C. - Revision requiring further peer review – the revised manuscript and the author’s response to reviewers are returned to one or more reviewers for re-evaluation.
D. - Rejection.

7A–B. Revisions Without Further Peer Review

Where the nature of the comments does not require another round of external review, the author submits through the OJS platform:
- a fully anonymised revised manuscript with tracked changes;
- a fully anonymised clean version of the revised manuscript;
- an anonymised response to reviewers’ comments;
- a response to comments from the Editor-in-Chief or Academic Editor, where applicable;
- an updated Title Page, if amended;
- an updated Alt Text file, if amended.

The revised version is assessed by the Editor-in-Chief or Academic Editor. If the required revisions have been satisfactorily implemented, the manuscript is accepted and transferred to production. If the revisions are insufficient, the author may be asked to make further amendments or the manuscript may be rejected.

7C. Further Round of Peer Review

Where further peer review is required, the author submits through the OJS platform:
- a fully anonymised revised manuscript with tracked changes;
- a fully anonymised clean version of the revised manuscript;
- an anonymised response to reviewers’ comments explaining how each point has been addressed;
- a response to comments from the Editor-in-Chief or Academic Editor, where applicable;
- an updated Title Page, if amended;
- an updated Alt Text file, if amended.

The Academic Editor verifies the completeness of the materials, their anonymisation, and compliance with editorial requirements, and then forwards the revised manuscript and author response to those reviewers whose further assessment is required.

After the additional reviews have been received, a decision is made according to the same principles as after the first review round. Where necessary, the process may involve further rounds of review (Under Review 2, Under Review 3, etc.).

8. Editorial Decision and Production

Reviewers’ reports form an important basis for editorial decisions but do not by themselves determine whether a manuscript is accepted or rejected. The final decision is made by the Editor-in-Chief or Academic Editor on the basis of the complete documentation associated with the manuscript, including reviewer reports, the author’s responses, and the revised manuscript.

Following final acceptance, the Editorial Secretary transfers the manuscript to the production stage and notifies the author of the decision through the OJS platform.

9. Confidentiality and Conflicts of Interest

The manuscript and all materials related to the review process are treated as confidential documents. Reviewers may not use unpublished data, ideas, or information contained in the manuscript for their own purposes.
Reviewers should decline an invitation to review if a conflict of interest exists or if any other circumstances could compromise the independence and impartiality of their assessment.

Download (DOC): Review Form