Negative Theology: Its Use and Christological Function in Late Antiquity and Subsequent Developments
Abstract
This article discusses the historical development of negative theology from its formulations in early Christianity to its later forms in Medieval Neo-Platonism. First analyzing how in early Christian thought negative theology was often used for a Christological purpose, the article goes on to discuss the implications of the Neo-Platonic notion of God as beyond being. While primarily applying a historical methodology, the article concludes by encouraging a rediscovery of the Christological orientation for negative theology found in its early Christian formulations.
Keywords:
negative theology, Christology, Clement of Alexandria, Gregory of Nazianzus, Gregory of Nyssa, Neo-PlatonismReferences
Alfsvåg, K., “Luther as a Reader of Dionysius the Areopagite,” Studia Theologica – Nordic Journal of Theology 65/2 (2011) 101–114. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/0039338X.2011.628124. (Crossref)
Aristides, Apologia, in Aristide, Apologie (eds. M.-J. Pierre – B. Outtier – B. Pouderon; Sources chrétiennes 470; Paris: Cerf 2003).
Athanasius, Contra Gentes, in Athanasius, Contra Gentes. De incarnatione (ed. R.W. Thomson; Oxford Early Christian Studies; Oxford: Clarendon 1971).
Athanasius, Orationes tres contra Arianos, in Patrologiae cursus completus. Series Graeca (ed. J.-P. Migne; Paris: Migne 1857–1866) 26.
Avilla, C., Ownership. Early Christian Teaching (London: Sheed & Ward 1983).
Barth, K., Church Dogmatics (Edinburgh: Clark 1957) II/2.
Barth, K., Prayer, 50th Anniversary Edition (Louisville, KY: Westminster John Knox 2002).
Basilius Magnus, Epistulae, in Basil, Letters (ed. R.J. Defferari; Loeb Classical Library 190; London: Heinemann – Harvard University Press 2015) I.
Carabine, D., The Unknown God: Negative Theology in the Platonic Tradition (Louvain: Eerdmans 1995).
Clemens Alexandrinus, Excerpta ex Theodoto, in Clemens, Stromata VII and VIII. Excerpta ex Theodoto (eds. O. Stählin – L. Früchtel; Berlin: Akademia-Verlag 1970).
Clemens Alexandrinus, Paedagogus, in Clemens, Protrepticus und Paedagogus (eds. O. Sẗahlin – U. Treu; Berlin: Akademie-Verlag 1972).
Clemens Alexandrinus, Stromateis 1–6, in Clemens, Stromata I–VI (eds. O. Stählin – L. Früchtel – U. Treu; Berlin: Akademie-Verlag 1985).
Clemens Alexandrinus, Stromateis 7–8, in Clemens, Stromata VII and VIII. Excerpta ex Theodoto (eds. O. Stählin – L. Früchtel; Berlin: Akademia-Verlag 1970).
Clement XIII, Encyclical Letter In Agro Dominico (1761).
Cyrillus Hierosolymitanus, Catecheses ad illuminandos, in Cyrille de Jérusalem, Catéchèses mystagogiques (eds. A. Piédagnel – P. Paris; Sources chrétiennes 126; Paris: Cerf 1988).
Denck, H., Religiöse Schriften (Gütersloh: Mohn 1960) II.
Dionysius Areopagita, De divinis Nominibus, in Pseudo-Denys l’Aréopagite, Les Noms divins. Chapitres V–XIII. La Théologie mystique (ed. Y. De Andia; Sources chrétiennes 579; Paris: Cerf 2016).
Dionysius Areopagita, De mystica Theologia, in Pseudo-Denys l’Aréopagite, Les Noms divins.
Chapitres V–XIII. La Théologie mystique (ed. Y. De Andia; Sources chrétiennes 579; Paris: Cerf 2016).
Douglass, S., Theology of the Gap. Cappadocian Language Theory and the Trinitarian Controversy (New York: Lang 2005).
Eckhart, Predigten, in J. Quint (ed.), Die deutschen Werke (Stuttgart: Kohlhammer 1958, 1971) I–II.
Eckhart, Von abegescheidenheit, in J. Quint (ed.), Die deutschen Werke (Stuttgart: Kohlhammer 1963) V.
Epistola Ad Diognetum, in Anonyme, A Diognète (ed. H.-I. Marrou; Sources chrétiennes 33; Paris: Cerf 1965).
Godínez, H.S., “The Deity’s Nothingness Towards a Nihilistic Mysticism of Eckhartian Inheritance,” International Journal of Philosophy and Theology 3/2 (2015) 73–86. DOI: https://doi.org/10.15640/ijpt.v3n2a8. (Crossref)
Gregorius Nazianzenus, Orationes, in Grégoire de Nazianze, Discours 27–31. Discours théologiques (eds. P. Gallay – M. Jourjon; Sources chrétiennes 250; Paris: Cerf 1978).
Gregorius Nyssenus, De Beatitudinibus, in J.F. Callahan (ed.), Opera exegetica In Exodum et Novum Testamentum. II. De oratione dominica. De beatitudinibus (Gregorii Nysseni Opera 7/2; Leiden: Brill 1992).
Gregorius Nyssenus, De vita Moysis, in H. Musurillo (ed.), Opera exegetica In Exodum et Novum Testamentum. I. De Vita Moysis (Gregorii Nysseni Opera 7/1; Leiden: Brill 1991).
Gregorius Nyssenus, Contra Eunomium, in Gregorii Nysseni, Contra Eunomium libri. I. Libri I et II (vulgo I et XII B) (ed. W. Jaeger; Gregorii Nysseni Opera 1; Leiden: Brill 2002).
Gregorius Nyssenus, In Ecclesiastem, in Gregorii Nysseni, In Inscriptiones Psalmorum. In Sextum Psalmum. In Ecclesiasten Homiliae (eds. J. McDonough – P. Alexander; Gregorii Nysseni Opera 5; Leiden: Brill 1986).
Gregorius Nyssenus, Refutatio confessionis Eunomii, in Gregorii Nysseni, Contra Eunomium libri. II. Liber III (vulgo III–XII) (ed. W. Jaeger; Gregorii Nysseni Opera 2; Leiden: Brill 2002).
Hägg, H.F., Clement of Alexandria and the Beginnings of Christian Apophaticism (Oxford: Oxford University Press 2006). (Crossref)
Hilarius, De Trinitate, in Hilaire de Poitiers, La Trinité (eds. J. Doignon et al.; Sources chrétiennes 448; Paris: Cerf 2000) II.
Iohannes Scottus Eriugena, Periphyseon. Liber secundus (ed. E. Jaeuneau; Corpus Christianorum Continuatio Mediaevalis 162; Turnhout: Brepols 1997).
Jüngel, E., God as the Mystery of the World. On the Foundation of the Theology of the Crucified One in the Dispute Between Theism and Atheism (London: Bloomsbury 2014).
Justin Martyr, Apologia, in D. Minnis – P. Parvis (eds.), Justin, Philosopher and Martyr. Apologies (Oxford Early Christian Texts; Oxford: Oxford University Press 2009).
Justin Martyr, Apologia Secunda, in D. Minnis – P. Parvis (eds.), Justin, Philosopher and Martyr. Apologies (Oxford Early Christian Texts; Oxford: Oxford University Press 2009).
Laird, M., “Gregory of Nyssa and the Mysticism of Darkness: A Reconsideration,” The Journal of Religion 79/4 (1999) 592–616. (Crossref)
Laird, M., “‘Whereof We Speak’: Gregory of Nyssa, Jean-Luc Marion and the Current Apophatic Rage,” Heythrop Journal 42/1 (2001) 1–12. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/1468-2265.00151. (Crossref)
Louth, A., The Origins of the Christian Mystical Tradition (Oxford: Clarendon 1981).
Luther, M., D. Martin Luthers Werke (Weimar: Böhlaus 1964) XXII.
Marius Victorinus, Ad Candidum, in Marius Victorinus, Traités théologiques sur la Trinité (eds.P. Henry – P. Hadot; Sources chrétiennes 68; Paris: Cerf 1960) I.
Marius Victorinus, Adversus Arium, in Marius Victorinus, Traités théologiques sur la Trinité (eds. P. Henry – P. Hadot; Sources chrétiennes 68; Paris: Cerf 1960) I.
Maximus, Capita de Caritate, in Maxime le Confesseur, Centuries sur la charité (ed. J. Pegon; Sources chrétiennes 9; Paris: Cerf 1945).
Mjaaland, M.T., The Hidden God (Bloomington, IN: Indiana University Press 2016).
Moltmann, J., The Crucified God (Minneapolis, MN: Fortress 2015).
Mortley, R., Connaissance religieuse et herméneutique chez Clément d’Alexandrie (Leiden: Brill 1973). (Crossref)
Mortley, R., From Word to Silence. II. The Way of Negation, Christian and Greek (Bonn: Hanstein 1986).
Palmer, D.W., “Atheism, Apologetic, and Negative Theology in the Greek Apologists of the Second Century,” Vigiliae Christianae 37/3 (1983) 234–259. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1163/157007283X00098. (Crossref)
Philo, De mutatione nominum, in G.P. Goold (ed.), Philo (trans. F.H. Colson – G.H. Whitaker; Loeb Classical Library 275; London: Heinemann 1934) V, 142-285.
Philo, De somniis, in G.P. Goold (ed.), Philo (trans. F.H. Colson – G.H. Whitaker; Loeb Classical Library 275; London: Heinemann 1934) V, 285–580. DOI: https://doi.org/10.4159/DLCL.philo_judaeus-dreams.1934. (Crossref)
Plato, Parmenides, in J. Burnet (ed.), Platonis Opera (Oxford: Oxford University Press 1901) II.
Plato, Respublica, in J. Burnet (ed.), Platonis Opera (Oxford: Oxford University Press 1902) IV.
Plato, Timaeus, in Platonis Opera (Oxford: Oxford University Press 1901) II.
Plotinus, Enneades, in Plotinus, Ennead (trans. A.H. Armstrong; Loeb Classical Library 444, 468; Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press 1984, 1988) V, VII.
Porphyrius, Sententiae, in Porphyre, Sentences. Études d’introduction, texte grec et traduction française, commentaire (eds. L. Brisson et al.; Paris: Vrin 2005) II.
Proclus, In Platonis Parmenidem Commentaria, in C. Steel – L. Van Campe (eds.), Procli In Platonis Parmenidem Commentaria (Oxford Classical Texts; Oxford: Clarendon Press 2009) III.
Sandbeck, L., “God as Immanent Transcendence in Mark C. Taylor and John D. Caputo,” Studia Theologica – Nordic Journal of Theology 65/1 (2011) 18–38. (Crossref)
Sokolowski, R., The God of Faith and Reason. Foundations of Christian Theology (Washington, DC: Catholic University of America Press 1994).
Steenbuch, J., “Frelse og forsoning i kappadokisk teologi,” Fønix (2023) 1–21.
Steenbuch, J., Negative Theology. A Short Introduction (Eugene: Cascade Books 2022).
Steenbuch, J., “På sporet af ‘intet’: Negativ teologi og negativismens genealogi,” Fønix (2020) 123–142.
Steenbuch, J., Participation og negation (København: Fønix 2023).
Stępień, T. – Kochańczyk-Bonińska, K., Unknown God, Known in His Activities. Incomprehensibility of God during the Trinitarian Controversy of the 4th Century (Frankfurt am Main: Lang 2018). (Crossref)
Tertullianus, Apologeticum, in Tertullian, Apology. De Spectaculis. Minucius Felix: Octavius (eds. T.R. Glover – G.H. Rendall; Loeb Classical Library 250; Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press 1931) 2–229. DOI: https://doi.org/10.4159/DLCL.tertullian-apology.1931. (Crossref)
Torrance, T.F., The Trinitarian Faith. The Evangelical Theology of the Ancient Catholic Church (2 ed.; London: Clark 1991).
Troutner, T., “Beyond Silence: Toward an Eschatology of Praise,” Modern Theology 37/4 (2021) 913–933. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/moth.12699. (Crossref)
Troutner, T., “The Eclipse of the Word: Five Theses on Apophaticism,” Theopolis April 6 (2023) https://theopolisinstitute.com/conversations/the-eclipse-of-the-word-five-theses-onapophaticism/ (access: 26.05.2023).
Turner, J.D., Sethian Gnosticism and the Platonic Tradition (Québec: Presses de l’Université Laval 2001).
Turner, D., The Darkness of God. Negativity in Western Mysticism (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press 1999).
Wissink, J., “Two Forms of Negative Theology Explained Using Thomas Aquinas,” Flight of the Gods. Philosophical Perspectives on Negative Theology (eds. I.N. Bulhof – L. ten Kate; New York: Fordham University Press 2000).
Wolfson, H.A., Philo. Foundations of Religious Philosophy in Judaism, Christianity, and Islam, (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press 1962) II.
Wolfson, H.A., “Negative Attributes in the Church Fathers and the Gnostic Basilides,”
Harvard Theological Review 50/2 (1957) 145–156. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/S0017816000028467. (Crossref)
Independent Scholar
Johannes Aakjær Steenbuch - Ph.D., Cand.Mag. in philosophy from the University of Copenhagen and the secretary of the Danish Patristics Association. He has recently published Negative Theology: A Short Introduction (Cascade Books 2022). A member of the International Association of Patristic Studies and Collegium Patristicum Lundense.
https://orcid.org/0000-0002-6826-1421
License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
The author(s) grant (s) to the Licensee a non-exclusive and royalty-free license in accordance with the provisions of the Appendix: LICENSE TO USE THE WORK
