The Neoplatonic Roots of Apophatic Theology in Medieval Islam on the Example of Maqāmāt aṭ-ṭuyūr/Manṭiq aṭ-ṭayr (The Conference of the Birds) by ʿAṭṭār Nīšāpūrī (ca. 1145–1221)
Krzysztof Kościelniak
Uniwersytet Jagielloński w Krakowie , Polskahttps://orcid.org/0000-0002-3915-335X
Abstrakt
This study will focus on the metaphysical and theological thought of Farīd ad-dīn ʿAṭṭār Nīšāpūrī, i.e. Abū Hamīd bin Abū Bakr Ibrāhīm (ca. 1145/6–1221). ʿAṭṭār’s best known masterpiece, Maqāmāt aṭ-ṭuyūr (Arabic Manṭiq aṭ-ṭayr), The Conference of the Birds, is seen as the finest example of Sufi love poetry in the Persian language after Rūmī. His thought is distinguished by its provocative and radical theology of love, as well as elements of apophaticism. ʿAṭṭār Nīšāpūrī’s vision of God should be analyzed in the context of Neoplatonism, which in a special way contributed to the development of apophatic Muslim thought. This approach challenged classical Islamic theism, whose representatives were convinced that they had sufficient knowledge of God from the Quran and Sunna. Aṭṭār’s doctrine focused on God who is a part of the universe. In other words, this author believed that whatever exists is part of God.
Słowa kluczowe:
apophatic theology, Neoplatonism, ʿAṭṭār Nīšāpūrī, Sufism, Sufi thought, the One – God, tawḥīd – Sīmurġ, Maqāmāt aṭ-ṭuyūr, Manṭiq aṭ-ṭayr, The Conference of the Birds, Talab, Išq, Maʿrifa, Fuqur, Fanāʾ, medieval Muslim theology, Islamic thoughtBibliografia
Sources
ʿAṭṭār, Farīd ad-dīn [al-], Muslim Saints and Mystics. Episodes from the Tadhkirat al-Auliya’ (trans. A.J. Arberry; London: Taylor & Francis 2008).
ʿAṭṭār, Farīd ad-dīn [al-], Wisdom of the East. The Persian Mystics ʿAṭṭār (ed. M. Smith; London: Murray 1932).
ʿAṭṭār, Farīd ad-dīn [al-], Fifty Poems of ʿAṭṭār (trans. K.S. Avery – A. Alizadeh; Melbourne: Re.press 2007).
ʿAṭṭār, Farīd ad-dīn [al-], The Ilahi-Nama (or Book of God) (trans. J.A. Boyle; Manchester: Manchester University Press 1976).
ʿAṭṭār, Farīd ad-dīn [al-], Conference of the Birds. A Seeker’s Journey to God (ed. R.P. Masani; York Beach, ME: Weiser Books 2001).
ʿAṭṭār, Farīd ad-dīn [al-], The Conference of the Birds (eds. A. Darbandi – D. Davis: Harmondsworth: Penguin Books 1986).
ʿAṭṭār, Farīd ad-dīn [al-], The Conference of the Birds. Mantiq ut-tair (ed. C.S. Nott; London: Routledge & Kegan 1978).
ʿAṭṭār, Farīd ad-dīn [al-], The Conference of the Birds. A Sufi Allegory, Being an Abridged Version of Farid-ud-Din Attar’s Mantiq-ut-Tayr (London: Routledge & Kegan 1961).
ʿAṭṭār, Farīd ad-dīn [al-], The Allegorical ‘Conference of the Birds’ is Attar’s Most Famous Work (trans. G. de Tassy – S. Nott) http://oldpoetry.com/opoem/24929-Farid-al-Din-Attar-Conference-Of-The-Birds (access: 28.05.2022).
ʿAwfi, M., Lubāb al-albāb (ed. S. Nafisi; Tihrān: Kitābhāna-i Ibn Sīnā 1956).
Balyānī, Awḥad ad-Dīn [al-], Whoso Knoweth Himself (London: Beshara in collaboration of Muhyiddin Ibn ‘Arabi Society 1976).
Dāraquṭnī, ʿAlī ibn ʿUmar [al-], Kitāb aṣ-ṣifāt (Al-Riyāḍ: Dār al-Ṣamīʿī 2005).
Ğāmī, ʿAbd al-Raḥmān b. Aḥmad Ğāmī, Nafaḥāt al-uns min ḥaḍarāt al-quds (ed. M. Tawḥīdī Pūr; Tihrān: Kitābfurūšī-i Maḥmūdī 1957).
Ġazālī, Abū Ḥāmid [al-], Minhāğ al-ʿābidīn (Aṭ-Ṭabʿah 3; Bayrūt: Dār al-Bashāʾir 2001).
Ġazālī, Abū Ḥāmid [al-], Al-Ǧawāhir al-ġawālī min rasāʾil al-Imām Ḥuǧat al-Islam al-Ġazzālī (Al-Qāhira: Muḥyi al-Din Ṣabri al-Kurdi 1934).
Ğīlānī, ʿAbd al-Qādir [al-], Al-Fatḥ ar-Rabbānī wa al-Fayḍ ar-Raḥmānī (Bayrūt: Dār al-Kutub al-‘Ilmīyah 2006).
Ḥāmidī, Ibrāhīm ibn al-Ḥusayn [al-], Die ismailitische Theologie des Ibrāhīm ibn al-Ḥusain al-Hāmidī (Wiesbaden: Steiner 1971).
Ḫarkūšī, ʿAbd al-Malik ibn Muḥammad [al-], Kitāb Tahḏīb al-Asrār (Al-Imārāt al-ʿArabīyah: Al-Mağmaʿ al-Ṯaqāfī 1999).
Ibn ʿArabī, Muhyī ad-Dīn Abū ʿAbd Allāh Muhammad ibn ʿAlī, “Kitāb al-Masāʾil,” Rasāʾil Ibn al-ʿArabī (Bayrūt: Dār al-Kutub al-ʿIlmīyyah 2007) 303–321.
Ibn ʿArabī, Muhyī ad-Dīn Abū ʿAbd Allāh Muhammad ibn ʿAlī, “Kitāb at-Tağalliyāt,” Rasāʾil Ibn al-ʿArabī (Bayrūt: Dār al-Kutub al-ʿIlmīyyah 2007) 322–354.
Ibn ʿArabī, Muhyī ad-Dīn Abū ʿAbd Allāh Muhammad ibn ʿAlī, “Kitāb Iṣṭilāḥ aṣ-ṣūfiyyah,” Rasāʾil Ibn al-ʿArabī (Bayrūt: Dār al-Kutub al-ʿIlmīyyah 2007) 407–417.
Ibn ʿArabī, Muhyī d-Dīn Abū ʿAbd Allāh Muhammad ibn ʿAlī, “Kitāb Manzil al-Quṭb wa Maqāmihi wa Ḥālihi,” Rasāʾil Ibn al-ʿArabī (Bayrūt: Dār al-Kutub al-ʿIlmīyyah 2007) 250–260.
Ibn ʿArabī, Muhyī ad-Dīn Abū ʿAbd Allāh Muhammad ibn ʿAlī, Šarḥ Risālat Rūḥ al-Quds fī Muḥāsabat an-Nafs min Kalām aš-Šayḫ al-Akbar Muḥyī ad-Dīn Ibn al-ʿArabī (Al-ṭabʿah 2; Dimašq: Dar al-Īmān 1994).
Ibn ʿArabī, Muhyī ad-Dīn Abū ʿAbd Allāh Muhammad ibn ʿAlī, Sufis of Andalusia (trans. R.W.J. Austin; London: Routledge 2008).
Iḫwān aṣ-Ṣafāʾ, Ar-Risāla al-ūlā ila ‘r-risāla al-ḫāmisa min al-qism aṯ-ṯāliṯ fi ‘l-ʿulūm annafsānīya al-ʿaqlīya (eds., trans. P.E. Walker et al.; Oxford: Oxford University Press 2015).
ʿIrāqī, Faḫr al-Dīn, Divine Flashes (trans. W.C. Chittick; New York: Paulist Press 1982).
Kalābāḏī, Muḥammad ibn Ibrāhīm [al-], Kitāb at-Taʿarruf li-Maḏhab ahl al-Taṣawwuf (Bayrūt: Dār al-Kutub al-ʿIlmīyyah 1993).
Plotinus, Enneades, in Plotinus, Enneads (ed. H. Armstrong; Loeb Classical Library 444; London: Heinemann 1984) V/1–9.
Qušayrī, ʿAbd al-Karīm ibn Hawāzin [al-], Al-Qushayrī’s Epistle on Sufism. Ar-Risāla al-Qushayrīyya fi ʿilm at-taṣawwuf (trans. A. Knysh; Reading: Garnet 2007).
Rifāʿī, Aḥmad ibn ʿAlī [al-], Ḥālat Ahl al-ḥaqīqah maʿa Allāh Taʿāla (Aṭ-Ṭabʿah 1; Bayrūt: Dār al-Kutub al-ʿIlmīyah 2004).
Rifāʿī, Aḥmad ibn ʿAlī [al-], Kitāb al-Burhān al-Muʿayyad (Al-Qāhira: Maṭba’at al-Ẓāhir 1904).
Samarqandī, Dawlatšāh, Taḏkirat aš-šu‘arā’ (ed. M. Ramḍānī; Tihrān 1344 H.).
Sarrāğ, Abū Naṣr [al-], Kitāb al-Lumaʿ (trans., ed. R.A. Nicholson; Leyden: Brill 1914).
Suhrawardī, Šihāb ad-Dīn Abū Ḥafṣ ʿUmar [al-], Kitāb ʿAwārif al-Maʿārif (Miṣr: al-Maktabah al-ʿAlāmīyah 1939).
Suhrawardī, Šihāb ad-Dīn Abū Ḥafṣ ʿUmar [al-], Rasāʾil Aʿlām al-Hudā wa-ʿAqīdat Arbāb at-Tuqā (Dimashq: Dār al-Anwār 1996).
Sulamī, Abū ʿAbd Ar-Raḥmān As-Sulamī An-Naysabūrī [al-]. Darajāt aṣ-ṣādiqīn. Two Texts from the Path of Blame (trans. K.L. Honerkamp; Louisville, KY: Fons Vitae 2009).
Sulamī, Abū ʿAbd Ar-Raḥmān As-Sulamī An-Naysabūrī [al-], “Risālat al-Malāmatiyyah,” al-Malāmatiyyah wa aṣ-ṣūfiyyah wa Ahl al Futuwwah (ed. ʿAfifi, Abu’l ʿAla, Köln: al-Kamel Verlag 2015) 91–127.
Sulamī, Abū ʿAbd Ar-Raḥmān As-Sulamī An-Naysabūrī [al-], Ḥaqāʼiq al-tafsīr. Tafsīr al-Qurʼān al-ʿAzīz (Bayrūt: Dār al-Kutub al-ʿIlmīyah 2001).
Tustarī, Sahl ibn ʿAbdallāh (al-), Tafsīr at-Tustarī (trans. A. Keeler – A. Keeler; Louisville, KY: Fons Vitae 2011).
Case Studies
Abdur Rabb, M., Abū Yazīd al-Bisṭāmī: His Life and Doctrines (PhD Diss.; McGill University; Montreal 1970).
Afnan, S.M., Philosophical Terminology in Arabic and Persian (Leiden: Brill 1964).
Amir-Moezzi, M.A., The Divine Guide in Early Shiʿism (Albany, NY: SUNY Press 1994).
Anṣārī, A.H., “Ibn Taymiyyah and Sufism,” Islamic Studies 24/1 (1985) 1–12.
Badawi, A.-R. La transmission de la philosophie grecque au monde arabe (Paris: Vrin 1968).
Bashiri, I., “Farid al-Din ‘Attar,” http://www.angelfire.com/rnb/bashiri/Poets/Attar.html (access: 6.05.2022).
Blois, F., Persian Literature – A Bio-Bibliographical Survey. V. Poetry of the Pre-Mongol Period (London: Routledge 2004).
Buana, C., “Nature Symbols and Symbolism in Sufic Poems of Ibn Arabi,” Karsa. Journal of Social and Islamic Culture 25/2 (2018) 434–456. DOI: https://doi.org/10.19105/karsa.v25i2.1304.
Cirlot, J.E., A Dictionary of Symbols (Mineola, NY: Dover 2002).
Corbin, H., Creative Imagination in the Ṣūfism of Ibn ‘Arabī (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press 1970).
Böwering, G., Mystical Vision of Existence in Classical Islam. The Qurʾānic Hermeneutics of the Sufi Sahl At-Tustarī (Berlin: De Gruyter 1980).
Brockelmann, C., Die Transliteration der arabischen Schrift in ihrer Anwendung auf die Hauptliteratursprachen der islamischen Welt. Denkschrift dem 19. Internationalen Orientalistenkongreß in Rom. Vorgelegt von der Transkriptionskommission der Deutschen Morgenländischen Gesellschaft (Leripzig: Brockhaus 1935).
Bulliet, R.W., The Patricians of Nishapur. A Study in Medieval Islamic Social History. (Cambridge: Harvard University Press 1972).
Daftary, F., “Ismailism and Gnosis,” The Gnostic World (eds. G.W. Trompf et al.; Abingdon: Routledge 2020) 337–348.
Danner, V., “Arabic Literature in Iran,” The Cambridge History of Iran. IV. The Period from the Arab Invasion to the Saljuqs (eds. R.N. Frye; Cambridge: Cambridge University Press 1975) 566–594. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/CHOL9780521200936.020.
Dupree, N.H., “An Interpretation of the Role of the Hoopoe in Afghan Folklore and Magic,” Folklore 85 (1974) 173–193.
Düzgün, Ş.A., “Kur’an’ın Tevhîd Felsefesi,” Kelam Araştırmaları Dergisi 3 (2005) 3–21.
Ebstein, M., “Classifications of Knowledge in Classical Islamic Mysticism: from Eastern Sufi Sources to the Writings of Muḥyī l-Dīn Ibn al ʿArabī,” Studia Islamica 115/1 (2020) 33–64. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1163/19585705–12341406.
Endress, G., The Works of Yahya ibn ʿAdi. An Analytical Inventory (Wiesbaden: Reichert 1977).
Forūzānfar, B., Šarḥ-e aḥwāl wa naqd o taḥlīl-e āṯār-e Šayḵ Farīd-al-dīn Moḥammad ʿAṭṭār Nīšābūrī (Tehran: Anǧuman-i Āṯār wa Mafāḫir-i Farhangī 1975).
Ghomlaghi, F., “Analytical Comparison and Aesthetic Thought of Abu-Saeid Abu-Khayr on Attar and Mawlawi in Pir-e-Navazandeh Story,” Shafa-e-del 1/1 (2018) 123–146.
Godelek, K., “The Neoplatonist Roots of Sufi Philosophy,” The Paideia. Comparative Philosophy 5 (1998) 57–60. DOI: https://doi.org/10.5840/wcp20-paideia19985114.
Griffith, S.H., “Comparative Religion in the Apologetics of the First Christian Arabic Theologians,” Muslims and Others in Early Islamic Society (eds. I. Lawrence – R.H. Conrad; London: Routledge 2004) 175–200.
Halm, H., Kosmologie und Heilslehre der fruhen Ismailiya. Eine Studie zur islamischen Gnosis (Weisbaden: Steiner 1978).
Hillenbrand, C., “A Neglected Source on the Life of Hasan-i Sabbah, the Founder of the Nizari Assassin Sect,” Journal of the British Institute of Persian Studies 55 (2017) 3–10. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/05786967.2016.1277101.
Information und Dokumentation – Umschrift des arabischen Alphabets für die Sprachen Arabisch, Osmanisch-Türkisch, Persisch, Kurdisch, Urdu und Paschtu (Berlin: Beuth 2011).
Jaichi, S. [el-], Early philosophical Ṣūfism. The Neoplatonic Thought of Ḥusayn Ibn Manṣūr al-Ḥallāğ (Piscataway, NJ: Gorgias 2018).
Jaouiche, H., The Histories of Nishapur. ʿAbdalġāfir al-Fārisī, Siyāq ta’rīḫ Naisābūr; Reg. d. Personen- und Ortsnamen (Wiesbaden: Reichert 1984).
Johan, I.M., “Bird Symbolism in Persian Mysticism Poetry,” International Review of Humanities Studies 4/2 (2019) 695–716. DOI: https://doi.org/10.7454/irhs.v4i2.176.
Karamustafa, A.T., Sufism. The Formative Period (Berkeley, CA: University of California Press 2007).
Kars, A., “Two Modes of Unsaying in the Early Thirteenth Century Islamic Lands: Theorizing Apophasis Through Maimonides and Ibn ‘Arabī,” International Journal for Philosophy of Religion volume 74 (2013) 261–278.
Kars, A., Unsaying God. Negative Theology in Medieval Islam (New York: Oxford University Press 2019).
Khosroshahi, S. – Sedighi, A., “Translation of Persian Mystic Terms into English: A Case Study of Conference of the Birds by Attar,” Theory and Practice in Language Studies 7 (2017) 552–557.
Kościelniak, K., Tematyczna konkordancja do Koranu (Kraków: UNUM 2006).
Kościelniak, K., “Aspects of Divinization According to Farīd-al-dīn ʿAṭṭār Nīšāpūrī (died c. 1221),” Divine Men and Women In The History And Society Of Late Hellenism (eds. M. Dzielska – K. Twardowska; Byzantina et Slavica Cracoviensia 7; Cracow: Jagiellonian University Press 2013) 91–101.
Kröger, J., Nishapur Glass of the Early Islamic Period (New York: Metropolitan Museum of Art 1995).
Landolt, H., “ʿAṭṭār, Sufism and Ismailism, ʿAṭṭār and the Persian Sufi tradition,” ‘Aṭṭā r and the Persian Sufi tradition (eds. L. Lewisohn – C. Shackle; London; New York: Tauris 2006) 3–26.
Lassner, J., “Islamizing the Story of the Hoopoe,” Demonizing the Queen of Sheba. Boundaries of Gender and Culture in Postbiblical Judaism and Medieval Islam (ed. J. Lassner; Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press 1993) 97–101.
Lazard, G., “Les emprunts arabes dans la prose persane du Xe au XIIe siècle: aperçu statistique,” Revue de l’École nationale des langues orientales 2 (1965) 53–67.
Lettinck, P., Aristotle’s “Physics” and Its Reception in the Arabic World, with an Edition of the Unpublished Parts of Ibn Bajja’s “Commentary on the Physics” (Leiden: Brill 1994).
Lewisohn, L. – Shackle, C. (eds.), Attar and the Persian Sufi Tradition. The Art of Spiritual Flight (London – New York: Tauris in association with the Institute of Ismaili Studies 2006).
Lloyd, A.C., Anatomy of Neoplatonism (Oxford: Clarendon 1998).
Madelung, W., “Aspects of Isma‘ili Theology: The Prophetic Chain and the God Beyond Being,” Isma‘ili Contributions to Islamic Culture (ed. S.H. Nasr; Tehran: Imperial Iranian – Academy of Philosophy 1977) 53–65.
Madkour, I. – van den Bergh, S., “L’Organon d‘Aristote dans le monde arabe,” Etudes Philosophiques 10/1 (1939) 47–49.
Malamuda, M., “Sufi Organizations and Structures of Authority in Medieval Nishapur,” International Journal of Middle East Studies 26 (1994) 427–442.
Mattila, J., Philosophy as a Path to Happiness. Attainment of Happiness in Arabic Peripatetic and Ismaili Philosophy (Helsinki: Helsinki University 2011).
Mayrhofer, M., Etymologisches Wörterbuch des Altindoarischen (Heidelberg: Carl Winter Universitätsverlag 1996) II.
Meisami, J.S., Structure and Meaning in Medieval Arabic and Persian Lyric Poetry. Orient Pearls (Abingdon, Oxon: Taylor & Francis 2002)
Melchert, C., “Sufis and Competing Movements in Nishapur,” Iran 39 (2001) 237–247. DOI: https://doi.org/10.2307/4300606.
Milani, M., “Mysticism in the Islamicate World: The Question of Neoplatonic Influence in Sufi Thought,” Later Platonists and Their Heirs among Christians, Jews, and Muslims (eds. E. Anagnostou – K. Parry; Leiden: Brill 2023) 513–544. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1163/9789004527850_023.
Netton, I.R., Muslim Neoplatonists. An Introduction to the Thought of the Brethren of Purity (London: Routledge 2013).
ʿOmar, F. [al-], The Doctrines of the Māturīdīte School with Special Reference to as-Sawād al-Aʿẓam of al-Ḥakīm al-Samarqandī (PhD Diss.; University of Edinburgh; Edinburgh 1974).
Peters, F.E., “The Greek and Syriac Background,” History of Islamic Philosophy (eds. S.H. Nasr – O. Leaman; London: Routledge 1996) 40–51.
Pines, S., Studies in Arabic Versions of Greek Texts and in Mediaeval (Jerusalem: Magnes Press 1986).
Rafi, H. “Spirituality and Persian Literature: Manifestation of Mysticism in Attar’s The Conference of the Birds,” Spirituality across Disciplines. Research and Practice (eds. M. de Souza – J. Bone – J. Watson, Cham: Springer 2016) 25–38.
Reinert, B., “ʿAṭṭār Shaykh Farīd al-dīn,” Encyclopaedia Iranica (ed. E. Yarshater; London: Routledge & Kegan 1989) III, 20–25.
Ritter, H., “Philologika X, Farīdaddīn ʿAṭṭār I,” Der Islam 25 (1939) 134–173.
Ritter, H., “Philologika XIV, Farīdaddīn ʿAṭṭār II,” Oriens 11 (1958) 1–76.
Ritter, H., “Philologika XVI, Farīdaddīn ʿAṭṭār IV,” Oriens 13–14 (1961) 194–239.
Ritter, H., “Philologika XV, Farīdaddīn ʿAṭṭār III,” Oriens 12 (1959) 1–88.
Saani, J. – Salrai, M., “Study and Comparison of Mystical Themes in Poems of Attar Nishapuri And Ibn Farez,” Religion and Mysticism 68 (2021) 285–308.
Sadeghi, A.-A., “L’influence de l’arabe sur le système phonologique du person,” La linguistique 11/2 (1975) 145–52.
Sadeghi, L., “The Function of Macrofiction and System Mapping in the Interpretation of ‘Conference of the Birds’ by Attar Nishapuri (A Cognitive Poetics Approach),” Language Related Research 5/4 (2014) 125–147.
Schmidt, H.P., “The Sēmurw. Of Birds and Dogs and Bats,” Persica 9 (1980) 1–85.
Şeker, Y., “Sufi Attitudes and Approaches in the Transition from Rational Tawhid to Intuitive Tawhid,” Route Educational and Social Science Journal 3/2 (2016) 31–44.
Šerani, H.M., “ʿTaṣnīfāt i šaiḫ Farīdu l-dīn ʿAṭṭār,” Urdū 7 (1927) 1–97.
Shafieifar, F. et al., “A Study on the Influence of the Indian Religions (Hinduism, Buddhism, Jainism) on the Motifs of Nishapur Architectural Ornaments,” Bagh-e Nazar 18 (1981) 17–28. DOI: https://doi.org/10.22034/bagh.2021.244113.4636.
Shapoo, S.F., “The Understanding of Tawhīd in the Sufi Classical Period,” Jurnal Qalbu 5/9 (2018) 214–240.
Shayegan, Y., “The Transmission of Greek Philosophy into the Islamic World,” History of Islamic Philosophy (eds. S.H. Nasr – O. Leaman; London: Routledge 1996) 89–104.
Steingass, F., A Comprehensive Persian-English Dictionary. Including the Arabic Words and Phrases to Be Met with in Persian Literature (London: Routledge & Paul 1963).
Taefi, Sh. “Aspects of Practical Mysticism and Unity of Intuition in Attar of Nishapur’s Divan,” Persian Literature 7/2 (2018) 81–100. DOI: https://doi.org/10.22059/jpl.2018.239249.994.
Trego, K. “Ce qui se trouve là et ce qui est fait. Le nom de l’être et la réception d’Aristote dans la falsafa,” Quaestio 17 (2017) 111–131.
Uždavinys, A., “From Alexandria to Harran: the Neoplatonic and Sufi Wisdom,” Acta Orientalia Vilnensia 3 (2002) 119–128.
Walker, P.E. “The Universal Soul and the Particular Soul in Ismaili Neoplatonism” (ed. P. Morewedge, Neoplatonism and Islamic Thought; New York: SUNY Press 1992) 149–166.
Walker, P.E., Early Philosophical Shiism. The Ismaili Neoplatonism of Abū Ya qūb al-Sijistānī (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press 1993).
Walzer, R., Greek into Arabic (Oxford: Cassirer 1962).
Watts, E.J., City and School in Late Antique Athens and Alexandria (Berkeley, CA: University of California Press 2006).
Wilkinson, C.K., Nishapur. Some Early Islamic Buildings and Their Decoration (New York: Metropolitan Museum of Art 1986).
Zargar, C.A., “Sober in Mecca, Drunk in Byzantium: Antinomian Space in the Poetry of
ʿAṭṭār,” Journal of the American Academy of Religion 98/1 (2021) 272–297. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/jaarel/lfab002.
Zarrabi-Zadeh, S., “Sufism and Christian Mysticism: The Neoplatonic Factor,” Routledge Handbook on Sufism (ed. L. Ridgeon; London: Routledge 2020) 330–342.
Uniwersytet Jagielloński w Krakowie
Licencja
Utwór dostępny jest na licencji Creative Commons Uznanie autorstwa – Bez utworów zależnych 4.0 Międzynarodowe.
Autor/Autorzy udziela/ją Licencjobiorcy niewyłącznej i nieodpłatnej licencji, zgodnie z postanowieniami załącznika: LICENCJA NA KORZYSTANIE Z UTWORU
