The Proposed Polish Advertisement Levies – An Efficient Source of Public Income or Instruments of the Political Battle?

Michalina Duda-Hyz

University of Opole , Poland


Abstract

This article analyses the bill of 2nd February 2021 on additional revenues of the National Health Fund, the National Fund for the Protection of Historical Monuments and the establishment of a Fund for the Support of Culture and National Heritage in the Media Area. The draft legislation, the announcement of which has triggered an unprecedented blackout protest in private media as well as a mass anti-government protest on the Internet, provides for the introduction of new public levies called advertisement contributions and the establishment of a new state special-purpose fund – the Fund for the Support of Culture and National Heritage in the Media Area. The aim of the article is to identify and present those provisions of the draft act which have evoked most controversies and have given rise to the stiff social resistance to the proposal. The first part of the paper is devoted to the assessment of the regulations within the context of the objective of the bill that was declared by the drafters in the legislative rationale. The analysis carried out has supported the assumption that providing adequate finances for those special-purpose funds that are strongly involved in remedying the consequences of the SARS CoV-2 epidemic was not a genuine purpose of the bill. It also leads to the conclusion that there is no constitutional justification for such a special-purpose levy. In the second part, the controversies over technical components of the advertising levies have been presented and analysed. On the basis of this analysis, it is possible to conclude that some of the qualitative and quantitative elements of the so-called advertisement contributions may give rise to interpretative doubts. The implementation of the research objectives made it possible to formulate a thesis that the advertisement contributions, as drafted, would not be efficient instruments of fair taxation of digital economy but rather would form instruments for achieving certain political objectives.

Keywords:

digital services tax, digital advertising tax, contribution on advertising services, media protest

Balázs, Rigó Csaba and András Tóth. “The Symbolic Significance of Digital Service Tax and its Practical Consequences.” Public Finance Quarterly, no. 4(2020): 515–526. (Crossref)

Bunn, Daniel, Elke Asen, Cristina Enache. “Digital Taxation around the World.” Accessed July 20, 2021. https://taxfoundation.org/digital-tax/, pdf.

Cui, Wei. “The Digital Services Tax: A Conceptual Defense.” Tax Law Review, no. 73(2020): 69–111.

Cui, Wei. “The Digital Services Tax on the Verge of Implementation.” Canadian Tax Journal, no. 67(4) (December 2019): 1135–1152. (Crossref)

Čejková, Tereza. “Tax Absence in Relation to Taxation of Digital Services.” Public Governance, Administration and Finances Law Review, vol. 5, no. 2(2020): 5–16. (Crossref)

Dębowska-Romanowska, Teresa. “Pojęcie podatków i innych danin publicznych w świetle Konstytucji.” In Księga jubileuszowa Profesora Ryszarda Mastalskiego. Stanowienie i stosowania prawa podatkowego, edited by Wiesława Miemiec, 110–123.Wrocław: Wydawnictwo UNIMEX 2009.

Dębowska-Romanowska, Teresa. Prawo finansowe. Część konstytucyjna wraz z częścią ogólną. Warszawa: Wydawnictwo C.H. Beck, 2010.

Ernst&Young. “France issues comprehensive draft guidance on digital services tax.” Accessed May 1, 2021. https://www.ey.com/en_gl/tax-alerts/france-issues- comprehensive-draft-guidance-on-digital-services-tax.

Google. “Financial plan of the NHF for the year 2021 NFZ.” Accessed May 2, 2021. https://www.nfz.gov.pl/bip/finanse-nfz/.

Google. “Media pomogą w zwalczaniu skutków COVID-19. Przepisy o składce reklamowej w prekonsultacjach.” Accessed February 8, 2021. https://www.gov.pl/web/ finanse/media-pomoga-w-zwalczaniu-skutkow-covid-19-przepisy-o-skladce-reklamowej-w-prekonsultacjach.

Google. “The legislative rationale for the bill on additional revenues of the National Health Fund, the National Fund for the Protection of Historical Monuments and the establishment of a Fund for the Support of Culture and National Heritage in the Media Area.” Accessed February 1, 2021. https://www.gov.pl/web/finanse/media-pomoga-w-zwalczaniu-skutkow-covid-19-przepisy-o-skladce-reklamowej-w-prekonsultacjach.

Hornowska, Anna. “Commentary to art. 5”. In Ustawa o finansach publicznych.Komentarz, edited by Agnieszka Mikos-Sitek, 9. SIP Legalis, 2021.

Kofler, Georg and Julia Sinning. “Equalization Taxes and the EU’a ‘Digital Services Tax.’” Intertax, vol. 47, issue 2 (2019): 176–200. (Crossref)

Kosikowski, Cezary. “Reforma finansów w Polsce w świetle nowej ustawy o finansach publicznych.” Państwo i Prawo, no. 12(2009): 3–15.

Kucia-Guściora, Beata. “Commentary to art. 5.” In Ustawa o finansach publicznych. Komentarz, edited by Paweł Smoleń, 102–131. Warszawa: Wydawnictwo C.H. Beck, 2014.

Lieb, Jean-Pierre, Morgan Vail, Frederic Vallat at al. “France issues comprehensive draft guidance on digital services tax.” Indirect Tax Alert, 13 April 2020: 1–7.

Ministry of Finance. “Media pomogą w zwalczaniu skutków COVID-19. Przepisy o składce reklamowej w prekonsultacjach.” Accessed May 2, 2021. https://www.gov.pl/web/finanse/media-pomoga-w-zwalczaniu-skutkow-covid-19-przepisy-o-skladce-reklamowej-w-prekonsultacjach.

Olbert, Marcel, and Christoph Spengel. “Taxation in the digital economy: Recentpolicy developments and the question of value creation.” ZEW Discussion Papers, no. 19-010 (2019): 1–31. (Crossref)

Sawicka, Krystyna. “Formy prawno-organizacyjne jednostek sektora finansów publicznych”. In System prawa finansowego, t. II, Prawo finansowe sektora finansów publicznych, edited by Eugeniusz Ruśkowski, 35–80. Warszawa: Oficyna Wolters Kluwer business, 2010.

Stankiewicz, Janusz. Debudżetyzacja finansów państwa. Białystok: Temida 2, 2007.

Szołno-Koguc, Jolanta. Funkcjonowanie funduszy celowych w Polsce w świetle zasad racjonalnego gospodarowania środkami publicznymi. Lublin: Wydawnictwo UMCS, 2007.

Tax Foundation. “What European OECD Countries Are Doing about Digital Services Taxes”. Accessed July 6, 2021. http://taxfoundation.org/digital-tax-europe- 2020/.

Young Ran, Kim. “Digital Services Tax: A Cross-Border Variation of the Consumption Tax Debate.” Alabama Law Review, no. 131(2020): 131–145.

Download

Published
2022-09-09


Duda-Hyz, M. (2022). The Proposed Polish Advertisement Levies – An Efficient Source of Public Income or Instruments of the Political Battle?. Review of European and Comparative Law, 50(3), 219–237. https://doi.org/10.31743/recl.13039

Michalina Duda-Hyz  dudami@kul.lublin.pl
University of Opole

Dr. habil., Associate Professor, Faculty of Law and Administation, University of Opole, correspondence address: Pl. Kopernika 11a, 45-040 Opole, Poland.




License

Creative Commons License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.