The Hungarian Retail Sales Tax in the Changing EU Context
Abstract
In the last twenty years, Hungary has had three periods of special taxes (introduced as a result of the crises), but before and after 2010, and after the recession following the COVID-19 epidemic and the Russian-Ukrainian war, there were different legal policy reasons behind special taxes (including the retail sales tax). This raises questions as to whether the regulatory solutions implemented to address market failures during the first period are playing the same role today as they did in the past, and how their role has changed over the years. The introduced taxes often remain part of the general tax system, i.e. they are applied on a permanent basis (rather than on a temporary basis, as is usual with special taxes), and in 2023 they already accounted for almost 14% of total tax revenue (a higher proportion than, for example, corporate tax), which puts their role in the tax system in a different light. The Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) has repeatedly examined the EU framework, but it appears that the control has been weakened, mainly due to the impact of the current crises. At the same time, the Hungarian Constitutional Court is bound by the limits of the debt brake when examining the constitutional framework. The study explores the regulation of the Hungarian retail sales tax and its EU context, in particular with regard to the changes triggered by the crises.
The introduced taxes often remain part of the general tax system, i.e. they are not applied on a temporary basis, and in 2023 they already accounted for almost 14% of total tax revenue (a higher rate than, for example, corporate tax), which puts their place in the tax system in a different light. The Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) has repeatedly examined the EU framework, but it appears that the control has been weakened, mainly due to the impact of the current crises, while the Hungarian Constitutional Court is bound by the limits of the debt brake when examining the constitutional framework.The study deals with the regulation of the Hungarian retail sales tax and its EU context, in particular with regard to the changes induced by the crises.
Keywords:
retail sales tax, crisis, Hungary, European Union, special taxesReferences
Csűrös, Gabriella. “Tax System in Hungary and Its Changes Due to the Crisis – Pioneer or Hazardous Method of Sectoral Taxation?.” In Tax Authorities in the Visegrad Group Countries: Common Experience after Accession to the European Union, edited by Marcin Burzec and Paweł Smoleń, 85–113. Lublin: Katolicki Uniwersytet Lubelski Jana Pawla II, 2016.
Csűrös, Gabriella, and Dóra Lovas. “The Boomerang Effect: Sectoral Extraordinary Taxes in Hungary (2006–2024).” International Tax Law Review, no. 2 (2023): 189–217.
Darák, Péter, and Dóra Lovas. ”Az adórendszer deszantosai: a különadók.” Jogtudományi Közlöny, no. 11(2023): 481–91.
Deák, Dániel. “Szankcionálható-e az árbevételre vetített progresszív adó?.” Jogi Melléklet, no. 9 (2020): 91–2. (Crossref)
Dóra Lovas. “Az Európai Unió Bíróságának energiaszektort érintő gyakorlata az EUMSZ 107. cikk (1) bekezdés fogalmi elemeinek vonatkozásában.” Kúriai Döntések–Bírósági Határozatok, no. 11 (2021): 1743–50.
European Parliament. “The legislative process.” Accessed March 1, 2024. https://www.parlament.hu/documents/10181/62157/T%C3%B6rv%C3%A9nyalkot%C3%A1si+folyamat%C3%A1bra+0509javitott/1600b677-8e26-4362-b1a0-b3f8ea8d92de?version=1.0&inheritRedirect=true.
Financial Times. “Spar supermarket accuses Hungary’s Viktor Orbán over retail tax.” Accessed March 15, 2024. https://www.ft.com/content/32d0d2be-d530-4708-ad8f-dc02ea410504.
Hajdú, Noémi. “Mi az Aldi kereskedelmi titka, amivel meghódította a magyarok szívét? A választ itt találja.” In Marketingkaleidoszkóp 2017. Tanulmányok a Marketing és Turizmus Intézet kutatási eredményeiből” edited by István Piskóti, 112–9. Miskolc: Miskolci Egyetem Marketing Intézet, 2017.
Horváth, M. Tamás, Ildikó Bartha, and Dóra Lovas. “A látható kéz -Támogatáselosztási jog válságok idején.” Magyar Jog, no. 7–8 (2023): 459–70.
Horváth, M. Tamás, Ildikó Bartha, and Dóra Lovas. “Mikor kakukktojás? Állami vállalattulajdon az energia- és nyersanyagpiacon.” Közjogi Szemle 15, no. 3 (2022): 22–34.
Jürgens, Ulrich. ”German grocery discounters: dynamics and regional impact. The case of Schleswig-Holstein (Germany).” Quaestiones Geographicae, no.4. XXXIII. (2014)): 17–26. (Crossref)
KSH. “Factsheet.” Accessed March 1, 2024. https://www.ksh.hu/gyorstajekoztatok/#/hu/home.
KSH. “Number of retail outlets by type of outlet.” Accessed March 9, 2024. https://www.ksh.hu/stadat_files/bel/hu/bel0002.html.
Mayer, Charles S., and Reza M. Bakhshandeh. “Global Vs. Local-The Hungarian Retail Wars.” Journal of Business & Retail Management Research 10, no. 1 (2015): 149–58.
Ministry of National Economy. “Those Who Can Afford It Pay: Hungary Introduces a Crisis Tax.” Accessed March 01, 2024. https://2010-2014.kormany.hu/download/d/15/10000/Az_fizet__akinek_van_mib__l___v__ls__gad__k.pdf.
Porfólió. “EU funds on the table in Brussels.” Accessed March 29, 2024. https://www.portfolio.hu/unios-forrasok/20230425/brusszel-asztalan-a-lidl-a-spar-es-az-aldi-magyarorszagi-kiszoritasanak-ugye-611380.
Sikos, Tamás T., and Csaba József Kovács. “Az élelmiszerdiszkontok helyzete, különös tekintettel a Coop-üzletlánccal Észak-Magyarországon folytatott versenyükre.” Területi Statisztika 60, no. 6 (2020): 688–713. (Crossref)
Spar. “Letter from spar to its employees in Hungary.” Accessed March 29, 2024. https://www.penzcentrum.hu/vasarlas/20240326/megszereztuk-a-spar-titkos-levelet-ezt-uzentek-a-kormany-haduzenete-utan-a-magyar-dolgozoknak-1148708.
The Fundamental Law of Hungary, Accesed March 29, 2024. https://www.parlament.hu/documents/125505/138409/Fundamental+law/73811993-c377-428d-9808-ee03d6fb8178.
