The Weakening of Taxpayer Rights in the Exchange of Information between Tax Authorities
Abstract
Developments in international legislation and the growing digitalization of tax law support the development of global networks between tax authorities. We are witnessing an integration of databases that will lead to increasingly intense coordination of the fight against tax evasion at a supranational level. As in social networks and digital commerce, databases are increasingly enriched, contain increasingly precise information on the individual taxpayer and use common languages that allow for automated exchanges of information. While waiting for the creation of a global database – not conditioned by the constraints of reciprocity and abstractly usable by all authorized entities who need it – the first risks of limitation of the taxpayer’s rights are emerging. In fact, these phenomena have dark sides that are starting to emerge in use, at a national level and with respect to individual taxpayers, of interpolated databases. Moreover, a growing amount of information flows from heterogeneous and increasingly widespread sources, sometimes not protected by the requirements of professionalism, legality and public trust since data collection and entry can be delegated to economic entities, intermediaries and consultants. The absence of an authority responsible for the unitary management of global databases and for the resolution of their conflicts, the slow and timid affirmation (only in some national systems) of the taxpayer’s right of access to information concerning them, the difficult configuration of the faculty to request the correction of erroneous data and of the specular public power to remove the reported inaccuracies, weaken the system of protections gradually erected to protect the taxpayer’s position. In this way, the coordination of national systems that contemporary tax law creates is strongly unbalanced on the side of the protection of tax interests. International and European tax law should instead provide greater guarantees in favor of the taxpayers, defending their right to fair taxation.Keywords:
tax law, global networks, exchange of information, right of access, transparency, correction of erroneous data, taxpayer rights, proportionalityReferences
Baker, Philip, and Pasquale Pistone. “BEPS Action 16: The Taxpayers’ Right to an Effective Legal Remedy Under European Law in Cross-Border Situations.” European Court Tax Review 25, no. 5–6 (2016): 335–45. (Crossref)
Califano, Christian. L’arbitrato e gli strumenti di risoluzione delle controversie nel diritto tributario. Milano: Giuffrè, 2024.
Capaccioli, Stefano, Marco Fasola, Maria Pierro, Onofrio Signorile, and Giovanni Ziccardi. Fisco digitale. Cripto-attività, protezione dei dati, controlli algoritmici. Torino: Giappichelli, 2023.
Carpentieri, Loredana. “Le criptovalute dall’anarchia alle necessità delle regole.” Rivista Telematica di Diritto Tributario, February 2024. Accessed February 13, 2024. https://www.rivistadirittotributario.it/2024/02/13/le-criptovalute-dallanarchia-alle-necessita-delle-regole/.
Cecconi, Natalìa. “DAC 6: obbligo di notifica degli intermediari e tutela del segreto professionale dopo la pronuncia CGUE dell'8 dicembre 2022.” Tax news, February 2023. Accessed February 14, 2023. https://www.taxnews.it/Article/Archive/index_html?ida=594&idn=36&idi=-1&idu=-1.
Contrino, Angelo. “Banche Dati Tributarie, Scambio di Informazioni fra Autorità Fiscali e 'Protezione dei Dati Personali': Quali Diritti e Tutele per i Contribuenti?.” Rivista di Diritto Tributario, (May 2019). Accessed May 29, 2019. https://www.rivistadirittotributario.it/wp-content/uploads/2019/05/Banche-dati-tributarie.pdf.
Contrino, Angelo. “Spinte evolutive (sul piano sovranazionale) e involutive (a livello interno) in tema di bilanciamento fra diritto alla protezione dei dati dei contribuenti ed esigenze di contrasto dell’evasione fiscal.” Rivista di Diritto Tributario, (October 2023). Accessed October 23, 2023. https://www.rivistadirittotributario.it/2023/10/03/spinte-evolutive-sul-piano-sovranazionale-e-involutive-a-livello-interno-in-tema-di-bilanciamento-fra-diritto-alla-protezione-dei-dati-dei-contribuenti-ed-esigenze-di-contrasto-dellevasio/.
Corasaniti, Giuseppe. “Lo scambio di informazioni tra presupposti internazionalistici e prospettive applicative.” Corriere tributario 38, no. 18 (2015): 1361–6.
Cordeiro Guerra, Dorigo, and Antonio Viotto. L'attuazione della DAC 6 nell'ordinamento italiano, Profili teorici e prospettive future. Torino: Giappichelli, 2023.
Costanzo, Luca. “La tutela dei diritti del contribuente al crocevia tra cooperazione amministrativa e integrazione eurotributaria.” Rivista di Diritto Tributario, (December 2020). Accessed December 02, 2020. https://www.rivistadirittotributario.it/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/Costanzo.pdf.
Del Federico, Lorenzo. “Agreements, arbitration and protection of the taxpayer in the evolution of international tax law.” Rivista di Diritto Tributario Internazionale (2020): 51–68.
Del Federico, Lorenzo. “OECD Approach on Digital Transformation of Tax Administrations and New Taxpayer’s Rights.” In Digital Transformation of Tax administrations in the European Union, edited by Alvaro Antón Antón, Cristina García-Herrera Blanco, 153–76. Madrid, 2023.
Del Federico, Lorenzo, and Francesco Montanari. “OECD Approach on Digital Transformation of Tax Administrations and New Taxpayers’ Rights.” Rivista di Diritto Tributario Internazionale, no. 2 (2021): 7–29.
Del Federico, Lorenzo, and Franco Paparella, eds. Diritto tributario digitale. Pisa: Pacini, 2023.
Didimo, Walter, Luca Grilli, Giuseppe Liotta, Leonardo Menconi, and Fabrizio Montecchiani. “Combining Network Visualization and Data Mining for Tax Risk Assessment.” IEEE Access 8 (2020): 16073–86. https://doi.org/10.1109/access.2020.2967974. (Crossref)
Dorigo, Stefano. “L’ordinamento italiano e la cooperazione fiscale internazionale.” In Principi di diritto tributario europeo e internazionale, edited by Claudio Sacchetto, 155–78. Torino: Giappichelli, 2016.
Dorigo, Stefano. “L'impatto della Convenzione multilaterale BEPS sul sistema dei trattati contro le doppie imposizioni. Rivista Trimestrale Diritto Tributario, no. 3–4 (2018): 559–86.
Dorigo, Stefano, and Roberto Cordeiro Guerra, eds. Fiscalità dell’economia digitale. Pisa: Pacini, 2022.
Francioso, Chiara. “Tutela giurisdizionale e “prevedibile pertinenza” delle informazioni nella cooperazione amministrativa fiscale europea.” Tax news. Accessed October 14, 2021. https://www.taxnews.it/Article/Archive/index_html?ida=466&idn=33&idi=-1&idu=-1.
Kuźniacki, Błażej, Marco Almada, Kamil Tyliński, and Łukasz Górski. “Requirements for Tax XAI Under Constitutional Principles and Human Rights.” In Explainable and Transparent AI and Multi-Agent Systems, edited by Davide Calvaresi, Amro Najjar, Michael Winikoff, and Kary Främling, 221–38. EXTRAAMAS 2022, Lecture Notes in Computer Science, vol. 13283. Berlin: Springer, Cham, 2022. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-031-15565-9_14. (Crossref)
Lang, Michael, Pasquale Pistone, Alexander Rust, Josef Schuch, and Catherine Stringer. The OECD Multilateral Instrument for Tax Treaties. Analysis and Effects. Alphen aan den Rijn: Kluwer Law International, 2018.
Marinello, Alessandro. “Pubblicazione di Dati Personali dei Contribuenti e Rispetto della Vita Privata secondo la Corte EDU: La Difficile Ricerca di un Equilibrio tra Interesse Fiscale e Diritto alla Riservatezza.” Rivista di Diritto Tributario 32, no. 1 (2022): 12–36.
Mastellone, Pietro. “Lo scambio di informazioni tra amministrazioni finanziarie.” In Diritto tributario internazionale, edited by Roberto Cordeiro Guerra, 249–319. Milano: Wolters Kluwer, 2016.
OECD. “Tax Transparency and International Co-operation.” Accessed June 8, 2023. https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/international-standards-for-automatic-exchange-of-information-in-tax-matters_896d79d1-en.html.
Perrone, Antonio. “DAC 6, Efficacia dell’Accertamento Tributario e Trasparenza: Fino a Che Punto Sono Legittimi i Doveri di Disclosure?.” Studi Tributari Europei 10, no. 1 (2020): II-1–II-20.
Pistone, Pasquale. Diritto tributario internazionale. Torino: Giappichelli, 2024.
Pitruzzella, Giuseppe. “Dati Fiscali e Diritti Fondamentali.” Diritto Pratica Tributario Internazionale, no. 2 (2022): 666–91.
Quattrocchi, Andrea. “Le potenzialità̀ applicative della blockchain e dei database condivisi nell’attuazione della norma tributaria.” Rivista di Diritto Tributario, (November 2022). Accessed November 22, 2022. https://www.rivistadirittotributario.it/wp-content/uploads/2022/11/Quattrocchi.pdf.
Ruan, Jian, Zhiqiang Yan, Bo Dong, Qi Zheng, and Bin Qian. “Identifying Suspicious Groups of Affiliated-Transaction-Based Tax Evasion in Big Data.” Information Sciences 477 (March 2019): 508–32. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ins.2018.11.008. (Crossref)
Selicato, Gianluca. “Le comunicazioni preventive secondo la Direttiva 822/2018/ EU: dalla “collaborazione incentivata” agli “obblighi di disclosure.” Rassegna tributaria (2019): 112–32.
Weber, Dennis. The Implications of Online Platforms and Technology on Taxation. Amsterdam: IBFD, 2023. (Crossref)
Wöhrer, Veronika. Data Protection and Taxpayers’ Rights: Challenges Created by Automatic Exchange of Information. Amsterdam: IBFD, 2018. https://doi.org/10.59403/2tc43v0. (Crossref)
University of Bari Aldo Moro https://orcid.org/0000-0001-5174-0613
