Prohibition of Discrimination Based on Sexual Orientation: Analysis of CJEU and ECtHR Case Law Concerning Human Rights
Monika Patrycja Bator-Bryła
Jan Kochanowski University in Kielce , Polandhttps://orcid.org/0000-0003-1703-8040
Abstract
This article analyses the importance of the prohibition of discrimination based on sexual orientation in light of the primary and secondary legislation of the European Union, as well as the case law of the Court of Justice of the European Union and the European Court of Human Rights. In the context of human rights protection, the prohibition of discrimination based on sexual orientation is a key element of modern judicial rulings in Europe. Both the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) and the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) play crucial roles in shaping the standards for the protection of LGBT+ persons by interpreting legal provisions and issuing judgments that influence national legislation. Both institutions emphasize the importance of equal treatment within the framework of human rights, and their rulings contribute to the elimination of prejudice and discrimination. The analysis of the case law of the CJEU and ECtHR demonstrates how LGBT+ rights are integrated into the broader context of human rights protection, which in the long term may lead to changes in social norms and legislation in member states. The prohibition of discrimination, including on the grounds of sexual orientation, undoubtedly constitutes one of the main social and economic objectives of the European Union. This is reflected in the incorporation of this matter into EU primary law, secondary law, and CJEU jurisprudence. The Treaty on the European Union (TEU) and the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (TFEU) identify equality as one of the Union’s values, mandate its promotion, and call for combating all forms of discrimination, prohibiting discrimination based on specified criteria. Furthermore, national measures can be examined in light of the treaty provisions only to the extent that they apply to situations not covered by the treaty’s specific anti-discrimination provisions. The author proposes the following theses: firstly, an analysis of CJEU case law reveals a noticeable dissonance between the application of national regulations by member states and EU law in the examined area, which significantly complicates the practical implementation of the prohibition of discrimination based on sexual orientation. Discrepancies mainly arise in national law due to improper drafting of national legal provisions or their erroneous interpretation by relevant national authorities. In particular, the author compares the regulations of member states with Council Directive 2000/78/EC establishing a general framework for equal treatment in employment and occupation. An analysis of the directive’s content, considering its interpretation by the CJEU, leads to the conclusion that member states implement the directive incorrectly, and the level of protection against discrimination based on sexual orientation is insufficient compared to the requirements of EU law. Member states are obliged to comply with EU law, which includes not only the duty of state authorities to respect directly applicable acts or implement them into national law but also the obligation to interpret and apply national law in accordance with the requirements of EU law. The second thesis results from the analysis of CJEU case law regarding the prohibition of discrimination based on sexual orientation. Although anti-discrimination directives form the foundation of the European Union’s anti-discrimination system, particularly in the areas of employment and occupation, the phenomenon of unequal treatment also occurs in other spheres such as access to goods and services or education. This necessitates the adoption of comprehensive legal measures to effectively combat discrimination. The study employs a comparative legal method, involving a comparative analysis of the legal acts of EU member states and the European Union regarding the prohibition of discrimination based on sexual orientation. The comparison of EU acts and national norms reveals the extent of the implementation of the provisions of EU law in this area within the legal systems of EU member states. The aim of this analysis is, among other things, to diagnose areas where these states have improperly implemented provisions of EU law or have incorrectly interpreted them. However, due to the limited amount of case law in this area, the author has limited the analysis to a few judgments. The second method applied is the analysis of the case law of the CJEU. CJEU rulings constitute a significant part of the study, compelling the author to use the comparative method to analyse judgments based on the same or similar legal grounds in analogous circumstances within the framework of the prohibition of discrimination based on sexual orientation.
The author presents the following theses: firstly, an analysis of CJEU case law reveals a noticeable dissonance between the application of national regulations by member states and EU law in the examined area, which significantly complicates the practical implementation of the prohibition of discrimination based on sexual orientation. Discrepancies mainly arise in national internal law due to improper drafting of national legal provisions or their erroneous interpretation by relevant national authorities. In particular, the author compares the regulations of member states with Council Directive 2000/78/EC establishing a general framework for equal treatment in employment and occupation. An analysis of the directive's content, considering its interpretation by the CJEU in limited rulings, leads to the conclusion that member states implement the directive inadequately, and the level of protection against discrimination based on sexual orientation is insufficient compared to the requirements of EU law. Member states are obliged to comply with EU law, which not only includes the duty of state authorities to respect directly applicable acts or implement them into national law but also the obligation to interpret and apply national law in accordance with EU law requirements[1]. The second thesis results from the analysis of CJEU case law regarding the prohibition of discrimination based on sexual orientation. Although anti-discrimination directives form the foundation of the European Union's anti-discrimination system, particularly in the areas of employment and occupation, the phenomenon of unequal treatment also occurs in other spheres such as access to goods and services or education. This necessitates the adoption of comprehensive legal solutions to effectively combat discrimination in a practical dimension.
Keywords:
sexual orientation, prohibition, discrimination, European UnionReferences
Allen, Robin QC. “Article 13, Evolution and Current Contexts.” In Equality Law in an Enlarged European Union: Understanding the Article 13 Directives, edited by Helen Meenan, 38–72. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2007. (Crossref)
Alston, Philip, and Joseph Weiler. “An ‘Ever Closer Union’ in Need of Human Rights Policy: The European Union and Human Rights.” In The EU and Human Rights, edited by Philip Alston, 3–28. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1999. (Crossref)
Bell, Mark. “The Principle of Equal Treatment: Widening and Deepening.” In The Evolution of EU Law, 2nd ed., edited by Paul Craig and Gráinne de Búrca, 626–55. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2011.
Biondi, Andrea, and Paul Everson. European Union Law: A Very Short Introduction. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2016.
Bishop, Jonathan. The Prohibition of Discrimination in the EU: Comparative Perspectives. London: European Union Agency for Fundamental Rights, 2021.
da Costa, Miguel Eduardo. “Sexual Orientation Discrimination: A Global Perspective.” International Journal of Human Rights, no. 4 (2020): 15–30.
Council of Europe Publishing. “Discrimination on Grounds of Sexual Orientation and Gender Identity in Europe.” Jouve, Paris 2011.
Council of the European Union. “Outcome of Proceedings of the Council Meeting.” Brussels 2016.
Craig, Paul, and Gráinne de Búrca. EU Law: Text, Cases, and Materials. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2018.
Darbouche, Hamza, Adriana R.H. van den Bos. The Law of the European Union: A Comprehensive Study. Abington: Routledge, 2019.
Darbouche, Hamza, and Adriana R.H. van den Bos. The Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union: A Commentary. Oxford: Hart Publishing, 2020.
Dzienisiuk, Dorota. “Discrimination on the Grounds of Sexual Orientation and the CJEU Judgment in Case C-267/06 Tadao Maruko.” Ubezpieczenia Społeczne, Teoria i praktyka 121, no. 4 (2014): 38–53.
European Commission. “Proposal for a Council Directive on Implementing the Principle of Equal Treatment,” Brussels 2016.
European Commission. “Report on the Implementation of the Racial Equality Directive,” Brussels 2019.
European Union Agency for Fundamental Rights. “Comparative Analysis of Anti-Discrimination Laws in Europe.” Vienna 2021.
European Union Agency for Fundamental Rights. “Comparative Study on Equality Bodies.” Vienna 2020.
Foster, Nigel. European Union Law. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2019.
Foster, Nigel. Foster on EU Law. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2017. (Crossref)
Frantziou, Eleni. The Horizontal Effect of Fundamental Rights in the European Union: A Constitutional Analysis. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2019.
Fredman, Sandra. “Transformation or Dilution: Fundamental Rights in the EU Social Space.” European Law Journal 12, no. 1 (2006): 41–60. (Crossref)
Heinze, Eric. “Sexual Orientation and International Law: A Study in the Manufacture of Cross-Cultural ‘Sensitivity’.” Michigan Journal of International Law Michigan Journal of International Law 22, no. 2 (2001): 283–309.
Hervey, Tamara, and Kenner Jeff. Economic and Social Rights under the EU Charter of Fundamental Rights: A Legal and Comparative Analysis. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2016.
International Commission of Jurists. Sexual Orientation and Gender Identity in Human Rights Law. References from the Council of Europe and the European Union. Geneva 2007.
Johnson, Paul. “Sexual Orientation Discrimination and Article 14 of the European Convention on Human Rights: The Problematic Approach of the European Court of Human Rights.” European Human Rights Law Review, no. 4 (2023): 548–63. (Crossref)
Kadelbach, Stefan. “Union Citizenship.” In The Evolution of EU Law, eds. Paul Craig and Gráinne de Búrca, 2nd ed., 205–34. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2011.
Kälin, Walter. The Impact of the Charter of Fundamental Rights on EU Law. Oxford: Hart Publishing, 2018.
Kalisz, Anna, and Robert Krasoń. “Commentary on the Judgment of the Court of Justice of the European Union of 12 January 2023 in Case C-356/21, J.K. v TP S.A.” Przegląd Sejmowy 179, no. 6 (2023): 161–76.
López, Marta. Discrimination Law in the EU: An Overview. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press 2021.
Maliszewska-Nienartowicz, Justyna. “The Role of the Principle of Equality in EU Law.” Studia Europejskie, no. 4 (2011): 73–91.
Marengo, Isabella. EU Anti-Discrimination Law. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2019.
McCrudden, Christopher, and Sacha Prechal. “The Concepts of Equality and Non-Discrimination in Europe: A Practical Approach.” Oxford Legal Studies Research Paper, no. 4 (2011): 1–20.
Muir, Elise. EU Equality Law: The First Fundamental Rights Policy of the EU. Oxford:Oxford University Press, 2018. (Crossref)
Muir, Elise. “The Essence of the Fundamental Right to Equal Treatment: Back to the Origins.” German Law Journal 20, no. 6 (2019): 817–39. (Crossref)
O’Brien, Brian W. “The Scope of EU Anti-Discrimination Law: A Comparative Perspective.” European Law Review 46, no. 1 (2021): 68–82.
Papadopoulou, Lina. Sexual Orientation and Gender Identity Law in the European Union and Its Court of Justice. London: Routledge, 2021.
Petrova, Dimitrina. “The Use of Equality and Anti-discrimination Law in Advancing LGBT Rights.” In Human Rights, Sexual Orientation and Gender Identity in The Commonwealth: Struggles for Decriminalisation and Change, edited by Corinne Lennox and Matthew Waites, 479–505. London: Human Rights Consortium, Institute of Commonwealth Studies, School of Advanced Study, University of London, 2013.
Pudło, Anna. “Charakter zakazu dyskryminacji ze względu na orientację seksualną w prawie UE.” Roczniki Administracji i Prawa 16, no. 1 (2016): 49–66. (Crossref)
Pudło-Jaremek, Anna. “Zakaz dyskryminacji ze względu na orientację seksualną w prawie UE po wyroku TSUE w sprawie Egenberger.” Roczniki Administracji i Prawa 20, no. 2 (2020): 61–74. (Crossref)
Schiek, Diana. European Union Non-Discrimination Law and Intersectionality: Investigating the Intersection of Protected Grounds. Abington: Routledge, 2018.
Skalik, Melania. “Prawnomiędzynarodowe instrumenty ochrony osób LGBT. Wybrane zagadnienia.” Student Journal of Law, Administration and Economics 44, (2023): 79–94. Accessed July 5, 2024. https://repozytorium.uni.wroc.pl/Content/139887/PDF/06_M_Skalik_Prawnomiedzynarodowe_instrumenty_ochrony_osob_LGBT_Wybrane_zagadnienia.pdf. (Crossref)
Śledzińska-Simon, Anna. “The Principle of Equality and the Principle of Non-Discrimination in EU Law.” Studia BAS 26, no. 2 (2011): 72–85.
Sołtys, Agnieszka. Wykładnia prawa krajowego zgodnie z dyrektywami jako środek zapewnienia skuteczności orzeczeniom Trybunału Sprawiedliwości Unii Europejskiej (podjętym w trybie art. 267 TFUE) w polskim porządku prawnym,” in Zapewnienie efektywności orzeczeń sądów międzynarodowych w polskim porządku prawnym, edited by Andrzej Wróbel, 499–518. Warsaw: Wolters Kluwer, 2011.
Wróbel, Andrzej, ed. Traktat o funkcjonowaniu Unii Europejskiej. Komentarz, Vol. 1. Warsaw: C.H. Beck, 2012.
Zawidzka-Łojek, Anna. “Opinion on the Polish Government’s Position Regarding the European Commission's Proposal of July 4, 2008, Concerning the Council Directive on Implementing the Principle of Equal Treatment Regardless of Religion or Belief, Disability, Age, or Sexual Orientation.” Warsaw: Sejm Publishing House, 2016.
Zawidzka-Łojek, Anna. Zakaz dyskryminacji ze względu na wiek w prawie Unii Europejskiej. Warsaw: University of Warsaw Press, 2013.
Jan Kochanowski University in Kielce https://orcid.org/0000-0003-1703-8040