The Concept and Legal Nature of EU Values
Volodymyr Motyl
The Ivan Fanko National University of Lviv , Ukrainehttps://orcid.org/0009-0000-9470-4882
Abstract
Values are a fairly common concept that is used extensively at the everyday level and is the subject of study in many sciences, including philosophy, sociology, psychology, cultural studies, religious studies, economic theory, political science, etc. Following the substantiation of values as a separate philosophical category, a branch of philosophy that deals with the study of values – axiology – was formed. Values began to move into the field of law and were used mainly as categories of philosophy of law or axiology of law and only partially became the subject of study of constitutional law and legal theory, as their nature as legal categories remained questionable for a long time. The enshrining of the values on which the European Union (EU) is based in Article 2 of the TEU, together with the introduction of a special liability mechanism for the breach of values in Article 7 of the TEU, as well as the validation by the Court of Justice of the EU of the mechanism outlined in Articles 258–260 of TFEU in case of breach of EU values, has put on the agenda the issue of a paradigm shift in the legal nature of values. Have EU values become a part of law or a legal category? Have they become part of the EU legal order? The confirmation of the legal nature of values and their properties as a separate legal category of the EU’s legal system would have far-reaching consequences in the future shaping of the interpretation, application, and development of EU law, national legal systems of Member States and of third counties that cooperate with the EU. The absence of such a transformation and property of values would significantly reduce the potential for influence and significance of the core values of the EU. The article defines which values are the core values of the EU. The author draws a conceptual distinction from related legal concepts and categories, primarily principles and norms. The author formulates law’s main characteristics or attributes from the perspective of both Legal positivism and natural law doctrine, namely: normativity, binding nature, formal certainty, systematicity and coerciveness or liability, compliance with the ideals of freedom, justice, and fundamental human rights. It also analyzes the compliance of values with these attributes or key characteristics. The analysis confirms that the core EU values enshrined in Article 2 of the TEU meet these criteria, and the author concludes that values are a new category of law that has emerged within the EU legal order. The author uses mainly doctrinal legal and inter-disciplinary legal research methods to characterize the basic concepts of law and the concept of values, as well as to identify and formulate their main attributes. The comparative method is used to compare values with related legal categories, in particular principles and norms, to determine their common and distinctive features. Deduction techniques were used to identify the main characteristics of law from the perspective of Legal positivism and natural law doctrine and assess the compliance of the EU’s core values with these features.
Keywords:
value, EU values, European values, EU lawReferences
Alexy, Robert. Begriff und Geltung des Rechts. Baden-Baden: Agency SIR RGB, 2005.
Amelchenko, Natalia. Values of the United Europe. NGO “Agency for Legislative Initiatives,” 2013. Accessed November 24, 2023. https://parlament.org.ua/upload/docs/European_Values.pdf. [Амельченко, Н.А. Цінності об’єднаної Європи. О «Лабораторія законодавчих ініціатив», 2013.]
Astolfi, Roberta. “Value in Law: Concept and Application within the Legal System of the EU.” In Being a Citizen in Europe: Insights and Lessons from the Open Conference, edited by Sandra Seubert and Frans van Waarden, 169–83. Zagreb: 2015. Accessed June 20, 2024. https://www.uu.nl/sites/default/files/being-a-citizenin-europe-insights-and-lessons-from-the-open-conference-zagreb-2015.pdf.
Babiuk, Alla. “The Concept of Normative of Law.” University Scientific Notes 52, no. 4 (2014): 15–21. [Бабюк, А. “Поняття нормативності права.” Університет-ські наукові записки 52, no. 4 (2014): 15–21].
Bousel, Viacheslav, ed. The Great Explanatory Dictionary of the Modern Ukrainian Language. Kyiv: Perun Publishing House, 2003. [Цінності. Великий тлума-чний словник сучасної української мови. Київ: ВТФ «Перун», 2003].
Calliess, Christian. “Europa als Wertegemeinschaft: Integration und Identität durch europäisches Verfassungsrecht?,” JuristenZeitung, no. 21 (2004): 1033–45.
Calliess, Christian, and Matthias Ruffert. EUV/AEUV. Das Verfassungsrecht der Europäische Union mit Europäischer Grundrechtscharta. C.H. Beck, 2011.
Čepo, Dario. “European Values in Croatia and the European Union: The State Of Affairs.” In European Values and the Challenges of EU Membership Croatia in Comparative Perspective, 15–32. Zagreb: Centar za demokraciju I pravo Miko Tripalo, 2020. Accessed June 14, 2024. https://tripalo.hr/wp-content/uploads/2020/10/European-Values-and-the-Challenges-of-EU-Membership-1-70.pdf.
Claes, Monica. “How Common are the Values of the European Union?.” Croatian Yearbook of European Law & Policy 15, (2019): VII–XIV.
Daci, Jordan. “Legal Principles, Legal Values and Legal Norms: Are They the Same or Different?.” Academicus International Scientific Journal, no. 2 (2010): 109–15. (Crossref)
Di Fabio, Udo. “Grundrechte als Werteordnung.” Juristen Zeitung 59, no. 1 (2004): 1–8.
Dolgowski, Karoline, and Dennis Traudt. “Das sind die Werte der EU! – Replik an Lucia Puttrich.” Jean Monnet Ssaar. Accessed November 28, 2023. https://jean-monnet-saar.eu/?page_id=141058.Finnis, John. Natural Law and Natural Rights. Kyiv: Centre for Educational Literature, 2021. [Финнис, Д. Естественное право и естественные права. Киев, Центр учебной литератури, 2021].
Frischhut, Markus. The Ethical Spirit of EU Values. Status Quo of the Union of Values and Future Direction of Travel. Innsbruck: Springer Cham, 2022. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-031-12714-4. (Crossref)
Giordan, Giuseppe. “Values.” In The Blackwell Encyclopedia of Sociology, edited by George Ritzer, 5176–80. Malden: Blackwell 2007. (Crossref)
Hart, Herbert. The Concept of Law. Kyiv: KNT, 2021. [Харт, Герберт. Понятие пра-ва. Київ: КНТ, 2021].
Hilf, Meinhard, and Frank Schorkopf. “Art. 2 EUV [Grundlegende Werte].” In Das Recht der Europäischen Union: EUV/AEUV: Loseblattausgabe. Kommentar, 72nd ed., edited by Eberhard Grabitz, Meinhard Hilf, and Martin Nettesheim, paras. 1–53. München: C.H. Beck, 2021.
Kant, Immanuel. Works in Six Volumes, vol. 4, part 2. Moscow, 1965. [Кант И. Со-чинения в шести томах. Т4.Ч.2., Москва, 1965].
Kelman, Mykhailo, and Vasyl Stratonov. General Theory of Law: Textbook, 6th ed., suppl. Kherson, OLDI-PLUS, 2020. [ Вид. 6-те, доп. Херсон: ОЛДІ-ПЛЮС, 2020].
Kelsen, Hans. Pure Theory of Law. Kyiv: Universe, 2004. [Кельзен, Г. Чисте правоз-навство. К.: Юніверс, 2004].
Kostytskyi, Vasyl. Selected Problems of the Theory of Law: A Textbook. Odesa: Helvetica Publishing House, 2022. [Костицький, В. Вибрані проблеми теорії права: підручник. Одеса: Видавничий дім «Гельветика», 2022].
Kozyubra, Mykola. “Principles of Law: Methodological Approaches to Understanding the Nature and Classification in the Context of Modern Globalisation Transformations.” Law of Ukraine, no. 11 (2017): 142–64. Accessed July 15, 2024. https://ekmair.ukma.edu.ua/server/api/core/bitstreams/22ed5ed8-a0c4-450da56b-cad459b8cf46/content. [Козюбра, М. “Принципи права : методологіч-ні підходи до розуміння природи та класифікації в умовах сучасних гло-балізаційних трансформацій.” Право України, no. 11 (2017): 142–64].
Leist, Oleg. The Essence of Law. Problems of Theory and Philosophy of Law. Kyiv: KNT Publishing House, 2021. [Лейст О.Э. Сущность права. Проблемы теории и философии права. Киев: изд. «КНТ», 2021].
Lypovets, Yuliya. “Legal Values as Ideals and Compromises.” PhD diss., National Academy of Internal Affairs 2021. [Липовець, Ю.І. “Правові цінності як іде-али та компроміси.” дис. на здобуття наук канд. юр. наук, Київ, Національ-на академія внутрішніх справ, 2021].
Muraviov, Victor. “The Acquis Communautaire as a Basis for the Community Legal Order.” Miskolc Journal of International Law 4, no. 2 (2007): 38–45.
Muravyov, Victor. “Principles and Values of the European Union and the Legal Order.” Actual Problems of International Relations, no. 138 (2019): 97–106. (Crossref)
Oxford Learner’s Dictionaries. Value. Accessed June 7, 2024. https://www.oxfordlearnersdictionaries.com/definition/american_english/value_1.
Perillo, Ezio. “National Identity Versus European Identity: From the Acquis Communautaire to the European Union’s Rule of Law.” Accessed April 30, 2024. https://free-group.eu/2022/03/07/national-identity-versus-european-identityfrom-the-acquis-communautaire-to-the-european-unions-rule-of-law/.
Petrov, Roman. “Acquis communautaire as a Component of the Phenomenon of the European Union Law.” European Law, no. 1 (2012): 54–66. [Петров, Р.А. “Acquis вступу як складова феномену права Європейського Союзу.” Євро-пейське право, № 1 (2012), 54–66.]
Rabinovych, Petro. “Principles of Law.” In Legal Encyclopedia in 6 vols., vol. 5, edited by Yuriy Shemhushenko, 128. Kyiv: Ukrainian Encyclopedia, 1998. [Рабінович, П.М. “Принципи права.” В Юридична енциклопедія в 6 т., т.5. Редкол. Ю.С. Шемшученко та ін. Київ: Укр. Енцикл., 1998, 128]
Seidl, Josephine. “Beitrittsverfahren und Sanktionen als Sicherungsmechanismen für die Werte der Europäischen Union.” PhD diss., University of Erfurt, 2017.
Strauss, Leo. Natural Law and History. KNT Publishing House, 2021. [Штраус, Лео. Естественное право и история. Киев, Изд. «КНТ», 2021].
Streinz, Rudolf. “Principles and Values in the European Union.” In Europarecht Beiheft: Beiheft 1. Liability of Member States for the Violation of Fundamental Values of the European Union, edited by Armin Hatje and Luboš Tichý, 9–22. Baden-Baden: Nomos, 2018. (Crossref)
Streletska, Iryna. “Value as a Subject of Socio-Philosophical Analysis (Methodological and Linguistic-Semantic Aspects).” PhD diss., Donetsk National University, 2008. [Стрелецька І.Г. “Цінність як предмет соціально-філософського аналізу(методологічний і лінгвосемантичний аспекти).” дис. канд. філос. Наук.: 09.00.03. Донецький нац. Університет, Донецьк, 2008.].
Thesing, Josef. Die Europäische Union als Wertegemeinschaft. Accessed June 10, 2024. https://www.kas.de/c/document_library/get_file?uuid=22e5a011-3e72-fa6e-5d74-77b0e8f79e61&groupId=252038.
Tomášek, Michal, and Václav Šmejkal. Commentary on the Treaty on the Functioning of the EU, the EU Treaty and the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the EU. Praha: Wolters Kluwer Czech Republic, 2024.
Tsvik, Marko and Olexandr V. Petryshyn, eds. General Theory of State and Law: Textbook for Students of Law Schools (Kharkiv: Pravo, 2009). [Цвік, М.В., О.В. Пе-тришин, ред. Загальна теорія держави і права: [Підручник для студентів юридичних вищих навчальних закладів]. Харків: Право, 2009].
Tychyna, Viktoriya. Legal Values of the European Union: A Textbook, Ministry of Education and Science of Ukraine. Zhytomyr: State University “Zhytomyr Polytechnic”, Pravo, 2023. [Тичина В. Правові цінності Європейського Союзу : навч. посіб. МОН України, Держ. ун-т «Житомир. політехніка». Харків, Право, 2023].
Voloshyn, Yuriy. “Principle.” In The Legal Encyclopaedia in 6 vols, vol. 5, еdited by Yuriy Shemshuchenko, 110–1. Kyiv: Ukr. Encyclopaedia, 1998. [Волошин, Ю.О. “Принцип.” В Юридична енциклопедія в 6 т. т.5. /Редкол.: Ю.С.Шем-шученко та ін. Київ, Укр. Енцикл.,1998].
Williams, Andrew T. “Taking Values Seriously: Towards a Philosophy of EU Law.” Oxford Journal of Legal Studies 29, no. 3 (2009): 549–77, https://doi.org/10.1093/ojls/gqp017. (Crossref)
Yushchik, Aleksei. Dialectic of Law. Book 1: General Doctrine of Law (Critical Analysis of General Legal Concepts). Kyiv: Law of Ukraine; In Jure, 2013. [Ющик А.И. Диа-лектика права. Кн.1: Общее учение о праве(критический анализ общепра-вовых понятий).ЧII. (Київ, Ред. Журн. «Право України»; Ін Юре, 2013)].
Zhebrovska, Krystyna. Universalism and Relativism of Legal Values in the Dialogue of Legal Systems: A Monograph. Odesa: Phoenix 2018. [Жебровська, К.А. Універ-салізм і релятивізм правових цінностей у діалозі правових систем: моно-графія. Одеса: Фенікс2018].
The Ivan Fanko National University of Lviv https://orcid.org/0009-0000-9470-4882
