The ICJ’s Advisory Opinion on Kosovo as a Tool of Costly Counter-Secession
Asim Jusic
International University of Sarajevo , Bosnia and HerzegovinaAbstract
Secessions are costly. That does not mean that counter-secessions more generally, and international judicial opinions as tools of counter-secession specifically, are costless. The trajectory of the International Court of Justice’s 2010 Advisory Opinion (Opinion) on Kosovo’s declaration of independence is a case in point. Initially deemed as not unfavorable to Kosovo’s independence from Serbia, over time, the Opinion proved a useful counter-secession tool for the opponents of Kosovo’s independence. The current structure of the international legal system and the dynamics of power politics facilitated leveraging the Opinion as a mechanism of counter-secession efforts. It is shown that not even the sponsorship of a secessionist state such as Kosovo by an individual dominant power like the United States can override the structural impediment to recognizing new states: the absence of coherent norms on state recognition in international law. Moreover, the support of powers such as Russia and China has meant that Serbia, as a counter-secessionist state, could use the Opinion to sustain the lack of international consensus on Kosovo’s independence, engage in a campaign for Kosovo’s derecognition, and extract concessions from Kosovo’s main independence sponsors. Serbia’s use of the Opinion as a tool for counter-secession has proven costly, however, as its sovereignty has become beholden to the whims of great power politics in a similar way to which Kosovo is indebted to the main sponsors of its independence.
Keywords:
International Court of Justice, Kosovo, secession, recognition, derecognitionReferences
Al Jazeera. “Mapping Which Countries Recognise Palestine in 2024,” 2024. Accessed August 15, 2024. https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2024/5/22/mapping-which-countries-recognise-palestine-in-2024.
Auswärtiges Amt. “50 Years Germany in the United Nations – Article by Foreign Minister Annalena Baerbock.” German Federal Foreign Office, 2023. Accessed August 15, 2024. https://www.auswaertiges-amt.de/en/newsroom/news/-/2616204.
B92.net. “K. Albanians Hail ICJ Decision as Big Victory ,” July 22, 2010. Accessed January 9, 2025. https://www.b92.net/o/eng/news/politicsarticle?yyyy=2010&mm=07&dd=22&nav_id=68621.
Baftiu, Doruntina. “Kosovo*: Its Footnote Is Both A Blessing And A Curse.” Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty, April 21, 2024, sec. Kosovo. Accessed January 9, 2025. https://www.rferl.org/a/kosovo-independence-asterisk-serbia-recognition/32912630.html.
Barber, Tony. “Why Is the EU Soft on Serbia?,” January 13, 2024. Accessed August 16, 2024. https://www.ft.com/content/77900656-0a52-4e1f-8d88-8ed2d7ab7264.
Barlovac, Bojana, and Sabina Arslanagic. “World Reacts to ICJ Advisory Ruling on Kosovo.” Balkan Insight (blog), July 23, 2010. Accessed January 9, 2025. https://balkaninsight.com/2010/07/23/world-reacts-to-icj-advisory-ruling-on-kosovo/.
Bechev, Dimitar. “Russia’s Strategic Interests and Tools of Influence in the Western Balkans,” 2019. Accessed October 8, 2024. https://stratcomcoe.org/cuploads/pfiles/russias_strategic_interests_in_balkans_11dec.pdf.
Bothe, Michael. “Kosovo – So What? The Holding of the International Court of Justice Is Not the Last Word on Kosovo’s Independence.” German Law Journal 11, no. 7–8 (2010): 837–9. https://doi.org/10.1017/S207183220001885X. (Crossref)
Buchholz, Katharina. “Kosovo & Beyond: Where The UN Disagrees On Recognition.” Forbes, 2023. Accessed January 9, 2025. https://www.forbes.com/sites/katharinabuchholz/2023/02/17/kosovo--beyond-where-the-un-disagrees-on-recognition-infographic/.
Cakolli, Eugen. “Kosovo: Between Universal Non-Recognition and ‘Derecognitions’.”Kosova Democratic Institute, 2020. Accessed August 18, 2024. https://www.kas.de/documents/286052/0/Policy+brief+20-09-13+Kosovo+Between+universal+non-recognition+and+derecognitions+(Eng).pdf.
Centre for European Studies. “The End of WWII and the Division of Europe.” UNCChapell Hill Centre for European Studies, 2024. Accessed August 15, 2024. https://europe.unc.edu/the-end-of-wwii-and-the-division-of-europe/.
Cerone, John. “ Court’s Non-Opinion.” Opinio Juris (blog), July 26, 2010. Accessed January 9, 2025. https://opiniojuris.org/2010/07/25/the-world-court%e2%80%99snon-opinion/.
Coggins, Bridget. “Friends in High Places: International Politics and the Emergence of States from Secessionism.” International Organization 65, no. 3 (2011): 433–67. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0020818311000105. (Crossref)
Domenech, Berta López. “The Association of Serb Majority Municipalities: The Crux of Tensions.” European Policy Center, June 14, 2023. Accessed August 11, 2024. https://www.epc.eu/en/Publications/The-Association-of-Serb-Majority-Municipalities-The-crux-of-tensions~517b60.
Emini, Ardian, and Alfred Marleku. “The Prospects of Membership in International Organizations: The Case of Kosovo.” Acta Universitatis Danubius. Relationes Internationales 9, no. 2 (2016). Accessed August 11, 2024. https://journals.univ-danubius.ro/index.php/internationalis/article/view/3382.
EU Directorate-General for Neighbourhood and Enlargement Negotiations. “Kosovo Report 2023 – European Commission,” November 2023. Accessed August 16, 2024. https://neighbourhood-enlargement.ec.europa.eu/kosovo-report-2023_en.
Gajin, Dragan, and Asim Jusic. “International Court of Justice on the Legality of Kosovo’s Declaration of Independence: Analysis and Legal and Political Implications.”Democracy and Security in Southeastern Europe 2, no. 6/7 (2011): 117–24.
Government of the Republic of Serbia. “Written Comments of Government of the Republic of Serbia.” International Court of Justice, July 17, 2009. Accessed January 9, 2025. https://www.icj-cij.org/node/104818.
Government of the Republic of Serbia. “Written Statement of the Government of the Republic of Serbia,” April 17, 2009. Accessed January 9, 2025. https://www.icj-cij.org/sites/default/files/case-related/141/15642.pdf.
Griffiths, Ryan D. Secession and the Sovereignty Game: Strategy and Tactics for Aspiring Nations. Cornell University Press, 2021. (Crossref)
Griffiths, Ryan D., and Louis M. Wasser. “Does Violent Secessionism Work?.”Journal of Conflict Resolution 63, no. 5 (2019): 1310–36. https://doi.org/10.1177/0022002718783032. (Crossref)
Hilpold, Peter. “The International Court of Justice’s Advisory Opinion on Kosovo: Perspectives of a Delicate Question.” Austrian Review of International and European Law Online 14, no. 1 (2013): 259–310. https://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.1734443. (Crossref)
International Court of Justice. Accordance with International Law of the Unilateral Declaration of Independence in Respect of Kosovo, Advisory Opinion. I.C.J. Reports 2010 (International Court of Justice July 22, 2010).
Jusic, Asim. “Damned If It Doesn’t and Damned If It Does: The European Court’s Margin of Appreciation and the Mobilizations Around Religious Symbols.” University of Pennsylvania Journal of International Law 39, no. 3 (2018): 561–614.
Jusic, Asim. “The (Uncertain) Future of Kosovo’s Community of Serb Municipalities: Another Republika Srpska?.” Atlantic Initiative, 2024. Accessed August 28, 2024. https://atlantskainicijativa.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/04/Policy-Paper-Kosovo.pdf.
Ker-Lindsay, James. “Explaining Serbia’s Decision to Go to the ICJ.” In The Law and Politics of the Kosovo Advisory Opinion, edited by Marko Milanovic and Michael Wood, 9–20. Oxford University Press, 2015. (Crossref)
Ker-Lindsay, James. “Not Such a ‘Sui Generis’ Case after All: Assessing the ICJ Opinion on Kosovo.” Nationalities Papers 39, no. 1 (2011): 1–11. https://doi.org/10.1080/00905992.2010.532778. (Crossref)
Ker-Lindsay, James. “The Counter-Diplomacy of State Recognition.” In Routledge Handbook of State Recognition, edited by Gëzim Visoka, John Doyle, and Edward Newman, 295–305. Routledge, 2020. (Crossref)
Ker-Lindsay, James. “The Significance of Kosovo*.” E-International Relations (blog), March 3, 2012. Accessed January 9, 2025. https://www.e-ir.info/2012/03/03/the-significance-of-kosovo/.
“Kosovo Thanks You – Thank You from the Kosovar People!,” February 17, 2024. Accessed January 9, 2025. https://www.kosovothanksyou.com/.
Krause, Peter. “The Strategies of Counter-Secession: How States Prevent Independence.” In The Routledge Handbook of Self-Determination and Secession, edited by Ryan D. Griffiths, Aleksandar Pavković, and Peter Radan, 413–28. Routledge, 2023. (Crossref)
Kursani, Shpend. “Costs of International Recognition: Palestine’s and Kosovo’s Struggle with Negotiated Statehood.” Geopolitics 29, no. 1 (2024): 174–202. https://doi.org/10.1080/14650045.2022.2151903. (Crossref)
Lemay-Hébert, Nicolas. “State Fragility and International Recognition.” In Routledge Handbook of State Recognition, edited by Gëzim Visoka, John Doyle, and Edward Newman, 306–15. Routledge, 2020. (Crossref)
Ljubovic, Mirza, and Asim Jusic. “Kosovo’s Membership of International Organisations.”Business Law International 25, no. 2 (2024): 173–82.
Milanovic, Marko, and Michael Wood, eds. The Law and Politics of the Kosovo Advisory Opinion. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2015. (Crossref)
Newman, Edward, and Gëzim Visoka. “The Geopolitics of State Recognition in a Transitional International Order.” Geopolitics 28, no. 1 (2023): 364–91. https://doi.org/10.1080/14650045.2021.1912018. (Crossref)
de Oliveira, Victor S. Mariottini. “Statehood for Sale: Derecognition, ‘Rental Recognition’, and the Open Flanks of International Law.” Jus Cogens 5, no. 2 (2023): 277–95. https://doi.org/10.1007/s42439-023-00075-y. (Crossref)
Orakhelashvili, Alexander. “The International Court’s Advisory Opinion on the UDI in Respect of Kosovo: Washing Away the ‘Foam on the Tide of Time’.”In Max Planck Yearbook on United Nations Law, 15th ed., edited by Armin von Bogdandy and Rüdiger Wolfrum, 65–104. Brill, 2011. (Crossref)
Papic, Tatjana. “De-Recognition of States: The Case of Kosovo.” Cornell International Law Journal 2, (2020): 683–729. (Crossref)
Papic, Tatjana. “The Political Aftermath of the ICJ’s Kosovo Opinion.” In The Law and Politics of the Kosovo Advisory Opinion, edited by Marko Milanovic and Michael Wood, 241–67. Oxford University Press, 2015. (Crossref)
Pegg, Scott. “How Parent States Prevent Recognition.” In The Routledge Handbook of Self-Determination and Secession, edited by Ryan D. Griffiths, Aleksandar Pavković, and Peter Radan, 429–42. Routledge, 2023. (Crossref)
Republic of Kosovo Ministry of Foreign Affairs. “List of Acknowledgments.” MPJD | MFAD. Accessed August 8, 2024. https://mfa-ks.net/lista-e-njohjeve/.
Roberts, Anthea. “Legality vs Legitimacy: Can Uses of Force Be Illegal but Justified?” In Human Rights, Intervention, and the Use of Force, edited by Philip Alston and Euan Macdonald, 179–214. Oxford University Press, 2008. (Crossref)
Ryngaert, Cedric, and Sven Sobrie. “Recognition of States: International Law or Realpolitik? The Practice of Recognition in the Wake of Kosovo, South Ossetia, and Abkhazia.” Leiden Journal of International Law 24, no. 2 (2011): 467–90. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0922156511000100. (Crossref)
Samorukov, Maksim. “A Spoiler in the Balkans? Russia and the Final Resolution of the Kosovo Conflict.” Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, 2019. Accessed October 8, 2024. https://carnegieendowment.org/research/2019/11/a-spoiler-in-the-balkans-russia-and-the-final-resolution-of-the-kosovo-conflict?lang=en.
Szewczyk, Bart M.J. “Lawfulness of Kosovo’s Declaration of Independence.” American Society of International Law Insights, August 2010. Accessed August 10, 2023. https://www.asil.org/insights/volume/14/issue/27/lawfulness-kosovos-declaration-independence.
Tierney, Stephen. “Legal Issues Surrounding the Referendum on Independence for Scotland.” European Constitutional Law Review 9, no. 3 (2013): 359–90. https://doi.org/10.1017/S1574019612001216. (Crossref)
Tudoroiu, Theodor. “Taiwan in the Caribbean: A Case Study in State de-Recognition.” Asian Journal of Political Science 25, no. 2 (2017): 194–211. https://doi.org/10.1080/02185377.2017.1334146. (Crossref)
United Nations General Assembly. “Request for the Advisory Opinion,” October 10, 2008. Accessed January 9, 2025. https://www.icj-cij.org/case/141/request-advisory-opinion.
United Nations. “About UN Membership.” Accessed August 23, 2024. https://www.un.org/en/about-us/about-un-membership.
United Nations. “Kosovo Status Talks Failed to Produce Agreement, Says Report to Security Council,” December 13, 2007. Accessed March 11, 2025. https://news.un.org/en/story/2007/12/243502.
Visoka, Gëzim. “The Derecognition of States.” In Routledge Handbook of State Recognition, edited by Gëzim Visoka, John Doyle, and Edward Newman, 316–32. Routledge, 2020. (Crossref)
Worster, William Thomas. “Law, Politics, and the Conception of the State in State Recognition Theory.” Boston University International Law Journal 27, (2009): 115–71.
