State as an Heir: Balancing Public and Private Interests in Georgia and Europe. Part I: Comparative Overview
Irakli Leonidze
Ivane Javakhishvili Tbilisi State University , Georgiahttps://orcid.org/0009-0002-6116-7878
Abstract
The Civil Code of Georgia establishes the state’s right to inherit heirless estates. According to the Georgian law, the state is referred to as the legal successor. Should we always consider the state as the legitimate successor, or is this only a necessity to maintain public order? Does the state have a legitimate public interest of heirless estate and how can this be balanced against the private interests? The following subjects will be discussed in this article from the perspectives of Georgia and European countries. The question of whether the state should assume ownership of the private property in the absence of heirs is a subject that has given rise to significant discourse on topics of justice, property rights, and the role of the state in private affairs. Numerous scholars have presented a range of arguments both in favour of and in opposition to the notion of the state becoming the recipient of property that lacks heirs. Given the legal nature of the problems, it is necessary to explicitly define the state’s status as a special legal heir in Article 1343 of the Civil Code of Georgia to prevent the confusion of rights and duties from leading to excessive state intervention in inheritance matters. European countries’ experience is very important for creating a new legal status of the state. Because of the problem of transferring an estate when there is no heir, balancing public and private interests is a most popular issue. The purpose of this paper is to examine the rights and obligations of the state as a legal heir under the different regulations and how these principles affect inheritance relations in socio-legal perspectives. It compares how this issue is addressed in other European countries’ legal systems and draws conclusions about the dual role of the state based on the different practice. This article aims to explore the theoretical possibilities about the state’s right on the heirless estate, offering valuable recommentations for the Constitutional Court of Georgia in justifying and making decisions on this issue.
Keywords:
state, heirless estate, heir, inheritance, Constitutional Court of GeorgiaReferences
Alexander, Gregory S., and Peńalver, M. Eduardo. An Introduction to Property Theory. Cambridge University Press, 2012. (Crossref)
Avsec, Franci. “Legal Framework of Agricultural Land/Holding Succession and Acquisition in Slovenia.” Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Law 16, no. 30 (2021): 24–39. https://doi.org/10.21029/JAEL.2021.30.24. (Crossref)
Berekashvili, Diana. “Mandatory Share in Inheritance Law.” PhD diss., Ivane Javakhishvili Tbilisi State University, 2020.
Bichia, Mikheil. “Some Features of the Development of Georgian Private Law from the 90s to the Present Day.” Law and World 8, no. 24 (2022): 75–104. https://doi.org/10.36475/8.4.6. (Crossref)
Boháč, Radim. “Inheritance Tax, Gift Tax and Real Estate Transfer Tax in the Czech Republic.” Societal Studies 2, no. 6 (2010): 94–105.
Chanturia, Lado. Commentary on the Civil Code, Book I (General Provisions of the Civil Code). Tbilisi: “Meridiani”, 2017.
Chanturia, Lado. Ownership of Real Estate. Tbilisi: “Samartali”, 2001.
Chikvashvili, Shalva. Inheritance Law. Tbilisi: “Meridiani”, 2000.
Christandl, Gregor, and Kristin Nemeth. “Austrian Succession Law Rewritten: A Comparative Analysis.” European Review of Private Law 28, no. 1 (2020): 149–72. https://doi.org/10.54648/erpl2020007. (Crossref)
Dutta, Anatol, Jürgen Basedow, Cathrin Bauer, Gerrit M. Beckhaus, Duygu Damar, Matteo Fornasier, Christian A. Heinze et al. “Comments on the European Commission’s Proposal for a Regulation of the European Parliament and of the Council on Jurisdiction, Applicable Law, Recognition and Enforcement of Decisions and Authentic Instruments in matters of Succession and the creation of a European Certificate of Succession.” Rabel Journal of Comparative and International Private Law (RabelsZ) 74, no. 3 (2010): 522–720.
Elinder, Mikael, Oscar Erixson, Sebastian Escobar, and Henry Ohlsson. “Estates, Bequests and Inheritances in Sweden – A Look into the Belinda Databases.” Uppsala Center for Fiscal Studies, Department of Economics, Working Paper 2014:14. Accessed March 4, 2025. https://www.diva-portal.org/smash/get/diva2:766280/FULLTEXT01.pdf.
Foster, Frances H. “The Family Paradigm of Inheritance Law.” North Carolina Law Review 80, no. 1 (2001–2002): 200–74.
Hall, Eamonn G. “The Common Law and Civil Law Notary in the European Union: a Shared Heritage and an Influential Future?.” Dublin: Institute of Notarial Studies, Institute of Notarial Studies, 2015.
Jokhadze, Khatuna. “The Contradictory Nature of State Property Denationalization in Georgia.” PhD diss., Ivane Javakhishvili Tbilisi State University, 2008.
Kokhreidze, Leila. “Persons Participating in Inheritance Disputes.” Justice and Law 3, no. 42 (2014): 26–44.
Kowalik, Emil. “General Characteristics of Service of Procedural Documents in Polish Civil Proceedings Compared to Selected European Countries.” Review of European and Comparative Law 59, no. 4 (2024): 77–95. https://doi.org/10.31743/recl.17167. (Crossref)
Kramar, Slađana A., and Katarina Vučko. “A Guide to the Implementation of the Succession Regulation (EU) No. 650/2012.” Croatian Law Centre Electronic Edition, 2020.
Kreiczer-Levy, Shelly. “Inheritance Legal Systems and the Intergenerational Bond, Real Property.” Probate and Trust Law Journal 46, no. 3 (2012): 1–29. https://ssrn.com/abstract=2060184.
Liin, Urve. “Succession Law Procedure Coverage in Estonian Public Electronic Databases: Ametlikud Teadaanded and the Succession Register.” Juridica International, no. 21 (2014): 197–205. https://doi.org/10.12697/JI.2014.21.18. (Crossref)
Loladze, Besik, Zurab Macharadze, and Ana Pirtskhalashvili. Constitutional Justice. Tbilisi: “Forma”, 2021.
Lutska, Galyna, Oleksandra Karmaza, Vitalii Makhinchuk, Sergii Koroied. “The Analysis of the Implementation of Inheritance Law in Selected EU Countries.” Revista Amazonia Investiga 11, no. 49 (2022): 149–55. (Crossref)
Marguénaud, Jean-Pierre, Corine Namont Dauchez, and Benjamin Dauchez. The Legitimation of Civil Law Notaries by the Law of the European Convention on Human Rights, 2017.
Maxwell, Douglas. The Human Right to Property – A Practical Approach to Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 to the ECHR. Oxford: Bloomsbury Publishing, 2022. (Crossref)
Mccarthy, Frankie. Succession Law. Dundee: Dundee University Press, 2013.
Metreveli, Valerian. History of the State and Law of Georgia. Tbilisi: “Meridiani”, 2003.
Notaries of Europe. European Commission for the Efficiency of Justice, Working Group on the Evaluation of Judicial Systems – Specific Study of the CEPEJ on the Legal Professions: Notaries. Notariats of the European Union, 2018.
Popescu, Andrei D. Guide on International Private Law in Successions Matters. Onești: “Magic Print”, 2014.
Rajski, Jerzy. “European Initiatives and Reform of Civil Law in Poland.” Juridica International, no. 14 (2008): 151–5.
Ruggeri, Lucia, Ivana Kunda, and Sandra Winkler, eds. Family Property and Succession in EU Member States National Reports on the Collected Data. Rijeka: University of Rijeka Faculty of Law Research Collection of Reports, 2019.
Shengelia, Roman, and Ekaterine Shengelia. Family and Inheritance Law (Theory and Practice). Tbilisi: “Meridiani”, 2019.
Shengelia, Roman, Zurab Akhvlediani, and Lado Chanturia. Commentary on the Civil Code of Georgia, Book V (Family and Inheritance Law). Tbilisi: “Samartali”, 2000.
Spitko, Gary E. “Intestate Inheritance Rights for Unmarried Committed Partners: Lessons for U.S. Law Reform from the Scottish Experience.” Iowa Law Review 103, no. 5 (2018): 2175–203.
Vagni, Laura. “Article 33 – Estate without a Claimant.” In The EU Succession Regulation, edited by Alfonso-Luis Calvo Caravaca, Angelo Davě, and Heinz-Peter Mansel, 458–68. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2016. (Crossref)
Van Rhee, Cornelius H. “Case Management in Europe: A Modern Approach to Civil Litigation.” International Journal of Procedural Law 8, no. 1 (2018): 14–28. (Crossref)
Weigel, Sigrid. “Inheritance Law, Heritage, Heredity: European Perspectives What Should Inheritance Law Be.” Law and Literature, no. 20 (2008): 279–85. https://doi.org/10.1525/lal.2008.20.2.279. (Crossref)
Xu, Ting, and Jean Allain, eds. Property and Human Rights in a Global Context. Oxford: Hart Publishing, 2015.
Załucki, Mariusz. “Attempts to Harmonize the Inheritance Law in Europe: Past, Present, and Future.” Iowa Law Review 103, no. 5 (2018): 2317–38. https://ssrn.com/abstract=3232732.
Zoidze, Besarion. Inheritance Law of Feudal Georgia. Batumi: 1992.
Ivane Javakhishvili Tbilisi State University https://orcid.org/0009-0002-6116-7878
