The Role of the CJEU in Ensuring Migrants’ Security – Analysis of the Post-Crisis Case-Law
Anna Magdalena Kosińska
Katolicki Uniwersytet Lubelski Jana Pawła II , Polandhttps://orcid.org/0000-0002-0915-874X
Abstract
The current article presents the findings of the research on the case-law of the CJEU in the area of asylum and return migration law concerning protection of migrants’ rights. The analyzed case-law concerns the proceedings from the period after the escalation of the European migration crisis in April 2015. The presented study seeks to answer the question about the existence of a juridical standard for the protection of the right to migration security. The analysis also includes the examination of the relation between the necessity of providing security in migration processes and the obligation to ensure the protection of migrants’ fundamental rights.
Keywords:
Common European Asylum System, migration security, migration crisis, CJEU case-lawReferences
Alpes M.J , S.Tunaboylu, I.van Liempt, Human Rights Violations by Design: EU-Turkey Statement Prioritises Returns from Greece Over Access to Asylum, Policy Brief Issue 2017/29, Migration Policy Centre Robert Schuman Centre for Advanced Studies
Basilien-Gainche M.-L., “Immigration Detention under the Return Directive: The CJEU Shadowed Lights,” European Journal of Migration and Law, vol. 17 (2015/1)
Beijer M., “Active Guidance of Fundamental Rights Protection by the Court of Justice of the European Union: Exploring the Possibilities of a Positive Obligations Doctrine,” Review of European Administrative Law, vol. 8 (2015/2)
Brouwer E., AG Mengozzi’s conclusion in X and X v. Belgium on the positive obligation to issue humanitarian visas. A legitimate plea to ensure safe journeys for refugees, CEPS Policy Insights 2017 (March), Issue 9
Chalmerd D., G. Davies, G. Monti, European Union Law, Second Edition (Cambridge, 2011)
Costello C., The Human Rights of Migrants and Refugees in European Law (Oxford, 2016)
Freedman J., “Engendering Security at the Borders of Europe: Women Migrants and the Mediterranean ‘Crisis’,” Journal of Refugee Studies, vol. 29, no. 4
Ghezelbash D., “Refuge Lost. Asylum Law in an Interdependent World,” Cambridge Asylum and Migration Studies (2018)
Groenendijk K., “Recent Developments in EU Law on Migration: The Legislative Patchwork and the Court’s Appproach,” European Journal of Migration and Law, vol 16 (2014/3)
Ilik G., “The Doctrinaire Authority: The Court of Justice of the EU and the Fundamental Rights,” Singidunum. Journal of Applied Sciencies, (2013/10/2)
Ippolito F., “Migration and Asylum Cases before the Court of Justice of the European Union: Putting the Eu Charter of Fundamental Rights to Test?” European Journal of Migration and Law, vol. 17 (2015/1)
Kosińska A. M., “Ewolucja koncepcji bezpiecznego kraju pochodzenia w dobie kryzysu migracyjnego,” in W obliczu kryzysu. Przyszłość polityki azylowej i migracyjnej Unii Europejskiej, ed. A. Kosińska (Lublin, 2017)
Kosińska A.M., “The Creative Role of the European Council in the Area of Managing Asylum Migration and Return of Third-Country Nationals to Their Country of Origin in the Times of the Migration Crisis. Research on the Content of the EC’s Conclusions 2011–2017,” Yearbook of Polish European Studies (2018)
Kosińska A.M., B. Mikołajczyk, “Does the Right to Migration Security Already Exist? Considerations from the Perspective of the EU’s Legal System,” European Journal of Migration and Law, (2019/1): 83-116
Kornobis-Romanowska D., “Prawa podstawowe w orzecznictwie TSUE jako czynnik konstytucjonalizacji czy umiędzynarodowienia UE?” in Unia Europejska w roli gwaranta i promotora praw podstawowych, ed. D. Kornobis-Romanowska (Sopot, 2016)
Mikołajczyk B, “Mechanizm dubliński na rozdrożu – uwagi w związku z pracami nad rozporządzeniem Dublin IV,” Europejski Przegląd Sądowy, (2018/3)
Moreno-Lax V., “Accessing Asylum in Europe. Extraterritorial Border Controls and Refugee Rights under EU Law,” Oxford Studies in European Law, (2017)
Peers S., “Irregular Migrants. Can Human Treatment be Balanced Against Efficial Removal?” European Journal of Migration and Law, vol. 17 (2015/4)
Weissbrodt D., M. Divine, “International Human Rights of Migrants” in Foundations of International Migration Law, eds. B. Opeskin, R. Perruchond, J. Redpath-Cross (Cambridge University Press, 2012)
Zoeteweij-Turhan M. H., A. Romano, “X and X v. Belgium: the need for EU legislation on humanitarian visa,” Sui Generis, (2017)
Basilien-Gainche M.-L., “Immigration Detention under the Return Directive: The CJEU Shadowed Lights,” European Journal of Migration and Law, vol. 17 (2015/1)
Beijer M., “Active Guidance of Fundamental Rights Protection by the Court of Justice of the European Union: Exploring the Possibilities of a Positive Obligations Doctrine,” Review of European Administrative Law, vol. 8 (2015/2)
Brouwer E., AG Mengozzi’s conclusion in X and X v. Belgium on the positive obligation to issue humanitarian visas. A legitimate plea to ensure safe journeys for refugees, CEPS Policy Insights 2017 (March), Issue 9
Chalmerd D., G. Davies, G. Monti, European Union Law, Second Edition (Cambridge, 2011)
Costello C., The Human Rights of Migrants and Refugees in European Law (Oxford, 2016)
Freedman J., “Engendering Security at the Borders of Europe: Women Migrants and the Mediterranean ‘Crisis’,” Journal of Refugee Studies, vol. 29, no. 4
Ghezelbash D., “Refuge Lost. Asylum Law in an Interdependent World,” Cambridge Asylum and Migration Studies (2018)
Groenendijk K., “Recent Developments in EU Law on Migration: The Legislative Patchwork and the Court’s Appproach,” European Journal of Migration and Law, vol 16 (2014/3)
Ilik G., “The Doctrinaire Authority: The Court of Justice of the EU and the Fundamental Rights,” Singidunum. Journal of Applied Sciencies, (2013/10/2)
Ippolito F., “Migration and Asylum Cases before the Court of Justice of the European Union: Putting the Eu Charter of Fundamental Rights to Test?” European Journal of Migration and Law, vol. 17 (2015/1)
Kosińska A. M., “Ewolucja koncepcji bezpiecznego kraju pochodzenia w dobie kryzysu migracyjnego,” in W obliczu kryzysu. Przyszłość polityki azylowej i migracyjnej Unii Europejskiej, ed. A. Kosińska (Lublin, 2017)
Kosińska A.M., “The Creative Role of the European Council in the Area of Managing Asylum Migration and Return of Third-Country Nationals to Their Country of Origin in the Times of the Migration Crisis. Research on the Content of the EC’s Conclusions 2011–2017,” Yearbook of Polish European Studies (2018)
Kosińska A.M., B. Mikołajczyk, “Does the Right to Migration Security Already Exist? Considerations from the Perspective of the EU’s Legal System,” European Journal of Migration and Law, (2019/1): 83-116
Kornobis-Romanowska D., “Prawa podstawowe w orzecznictwie TSUE jako czynnik konstytucjonalizacji czy umiędzynarodowienia UE?” in Unia Europejska w roli gwaranta i promotora praw podstawowych, ed. D. Kornobis-Romanowska (Sopot, 2016)
Mikołajczyk B, “Mechanizm dubliński na rozdrożu – uwagi w związku z pracami nad rozporządzeniem Dublin IV,” Europejski Przegląd Sądowy, (2018/3)
Moreno-Lax V., “Accessing Asylum in Europe. Extraterritorial Border Controls and Refugee Rights under EU Law,” Oxford Studies in European Law, (2017)
Peers S., “Irregular Migrants. Can Human Treatment be Balanced Against Efficial Removal?” European Journal of Migration and Law, vol. 17 (2015/4)
Weissbrodt D., M. Divine, “International Human Rights of Migrants” in Foundations of International Migration Law, eds. B. Opeskin, R. Perruchond, J. Redpath-Cross (Cambridge University Press, 2012)
Zoeteweij-Turhan M. H., A. Romano, “X and X v. Belgium: the need for EU legislation on humanitarian visa,” Sui Generis, (2017)
Kosińska, A. M. (2019). The Role of the CJEU in Ensuring Migrants’ Security – Analysis of the Post-Crisis Case-Law. Review of European and Comparative Law, 37(2), 97–120. https://doi.org/10.31743/recl.4830
Anna Magdalena Kosińska
kosiania@kul.pl
Katolicki Uniwersytet Lubelski Jana Pawła II https://orcid.org/0000-0002-0915-874X
Katolicki Uniwersytet Lubelski Jana Pawła II https://orcid.org/0000-0002-0915-874X
