Transparency and Accountability in Local Public Finance: Evidence from Public Parking Fee Allocation
Kristina Misheva
Goce Delchev University, Stip , North Macedoniahttps://orcid.org/0000-0002-2327-7358
Kristijan Panev
Goce Delcev University, Stip , North Macedoniahttps://orcid.org/0009-0001-5418-5923
Abstract
Municipalities worldwide play a crucial role in delivering essential public services to citizens. However, securing adequate resources and sustainable funding remains a persistent challenge for local self-governments. Depending on the state system, local circumstances, societal needs, and policy priorities, municipal revenue structures vary significantly. Yet modern urban municipalities are generally guided by common principles such as equality, solidarity, efficiency, transparency, accountability, and the promotion of public well-being. The adoption of the European Charter of Local Self-Government in the 1980s established an internationally recognized legal framework for local governance and local financing. As a member state of the Council of Europe, North Macedonia adheres to the Charter’s core principles, which emphasize greater local fiscal autonomy and the responsibility of municipalities to manage both their revenues and expenditures independently of the central government. Despite the existing framework, Macedonian municipalities still rely heavily on central government transfers, with own-source revenues – such as property taxes, communal fees, and parking fees – making up a smaller share. Parking fees generally provide modest revenue, mainly funding public-space maintenance, traffic management, and minor infrastructure, and rarely support social welfare. Recently, some cities have introduced structured or solidarity-based parking fees for humanitarian or health purposes. This paper examines the core principles of local financing through an analysis of parking fees, focusing on the emerging practice of “humanitarian parking” as a case study. It employs a qualitative comparative case-study methodology that examines legal frameworks, policies, and practices of public ad solidarity-based parking fees in cities in Macedonia and Serbia, as neighboring countries that share a similar socio-demographic, economic, and legal context. Particular attention is given to the emerging model of “humanitarian parking” as a municipal policy instrument. The analysis assesses the impact of this model on local fiscal autonomy and examines empirical evidence on citizen attitudes, including levels of public support and the transparency of parking-revenue allocation.
Keywords:
local public finances, parking fees , solidarity parking fee, transparency , accountabilityReferences
Agreement between PE “Stipion 2011” – Štip and the Foundation for Information Technologies and Solidarity Fund. No. 0307-31/3.
Angelkovik, Mileva, and Marina Dimitrijevik. Poresko pravo Srbij. Niš: Pravni fakultet, University of Niš, 2009.
Annual Report on the Work of PE “Stipion 2011” – Štip with Financial Indicators for the Period 1 January 2023 – 31 December 2023, under the Programme for the Use of Public Space for Parking, No. 0102-166/5, 26 February 2024.
Annual Report on the Work of PE “Stipion 2011” – Štip with Financial Indicators for the Period 1 January 2024 – 31 December 2024, under the Programme for the Use of Public Space for Parking.
Baurmann, Michael. “Solidarity as a Social Norm and as Constitutional Norm.” In Solidarity, edited by Kurt Bayertz, 243–72. Dordrecht: Springer, 1999.
Bučar Ručman, Aleš. “Questioning Social Solidarity through the Perspective of Parking Violations in Spaces Reserved for Disabled People.” Current Sociology 68, no. 7 (2019): 990–1006. https://doi.org/10.1177/0011392119890667.
Council of Europe. “Serbia Ratifies the Additional Protocol to the European Charter of Local Self-Government on the Right to Participate in the Affairs of a Local Authority,” June 29, 2018. Accessed November 20, 2025. https://www.coe.int/en/web/congress/-/https-www-coe-int-fr-web-congress-staging-news-2018serbia-ratifies-the-additional-protocol-to-the-european-charter-of-local-self-government-on-the-rig?utm_source=chatgpt.com.
Goetting, Katharina, Ulf Liebe, and Sophia Becker. “From Parking Place to Public Space: A Factorial Survey Experiment on Public Acceptability of Parking Space Reallocation in Germany.” Climate Policy (2025): 1–19. https://doi.org/10.1080/14693062.2025.2539140.
Jelčić, Božidar, Olivera Lončarić-Horvat, Jure Šimović, Hrvoje Arbutina, and Nikola Mijatović. Financijsko pravo i financijska znanost. Zagreb: Narodne Novine, 2008.
Maksimova-Veljanovska, Aleksandra, Jovan Zafirovski, and Elena Nesovska. Finansovo pravo. Skopje: Praven fakultet “Justinijan Prvi”, 2024.
Mańczyk, Paweł. “Parking Fees for Layover of Motor Vehicles on Public Roads – Legal Analysis of Selected Issues.” State and Local Government Budget Law 9, no. 1 (2021): 95–112. http://dx.doi.org/10.12775/PBPS.2021.005.
North Macedonia, Ministry of Finance, “Fiscal Strategy of North Macedonia (2024–2028).” Accessed November 15, 2025. https://arhiva.finance.gov.mk/wp-content/uploads/2023/12/2024-2028-Fiscal-strategy-of-the-Republic-of-North-Macedonia.pdf.
North Macedonia, Ministry of Finance. “Fiscal Strategy of North Macedonia (2025–2029).” Accessed November 15, 2025. https://arhiva.finance.gov.mk/wp-content/uploads/2025/02/2025-2029-FISCAL-STRATEGY-OF-THE-REPUBLIC-OF-NORTH-MACEDONIA.pdf.
PE “PARKING SERVICE”- Niš. “Baby Parking Card.” Accessed November 21, 2025. https://www.nisparking.rs/sr/паркирање/остало/беби-паркинг-карта.
Pendovska, Vesna, Aleksandra Maksimova-Veljanovska, and Kiki Mangova-Ponjaviќ. Finansovo pravo. Kumanovo: Makedonska Riznica, 2010.
Popović, Dejan. Poresko pravo, 4th rev. ed. Belgrade: Faculty of Law, University of Belgrade, 2009.
Price List Amending and Supplementing the Price List of Services of Public Parking Areas Managed by PE “Stipion 2011” – Štip, No. 0202-200/3 (27 April 2023).
Report on the Amount of Financial Resources from the X-Humanitarian Parking Zone of PE “Stipion 2011” – Štip, No. 0503-287/1, 7 May 2024.
Semi-Annual Report on the Work of PE “Stipion 2011” – Štip with Financial Indicators for the Period 1 January 2025 – 30 June 2025, under the Programme for the Use of Public Space for Parking.
Szołno-Koguc, Joanna. “The Significance of Openness and Transparency for Accountability in Public Finances.” e-Finanse 14, no. 2 (2018): 58–66. https://doi.org/10.2478/fiqf-2018-0012.
Vickrey, William S. “My Innovative Failures in Economics.” Atlantic Economic Journal 21 (1993): 1–9. https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02299771.
Working Program of Public Enterprise “Parking-Service” – Niš for 2025 – No. 12896/24, 28 November 2024. Accessed November 22, 2025. https://www.nisparking.rs/sr/документи/category/34-известији-и-програми.
Goce Delchev University, Stip https://orcid.org/0000-0002-2327-7358
