EU Medical Device Regulation – The Level of Convergence and Impact on Regulatory Complexity
Nika Gavrilović Jankovič
University of Ljubljana , Słoweniahttps://orcid.org/0009-0001-8215-6273
Bruno Nikolić
University of Ljubljana , Słoweniahttps://orcid.org/0000-0002-1763-4697
Abstrakt
Medical Device Regulation (MDR) entered into force in 2017 and became applicable in 2021. In the context of Europeanization and the European Union (EU) multilevel governance system, regulations are used as a means of unification. EU has gradually increased the degree of convergence in medical devices, even though medical devices pertain to the health sector, which is within the Member States’ competence. Despite MDR being a regulation, its preamble states that its aim is to harmonize rules for the placing on the market and use of medical devices on the EU market. This article analyzes the level of convergence introduced by the MDR and its impact on regulatory complexity. Our findings demonstrate that many relevant elements, such as mandatory CE marking, reached the level of unification, whereas some that are still to become legally effective, such as the European database on medical devices (EUDAMED), went further and reached the highest level – supranational and integral joint administrative capacities. Unlike the expected inverse correlation between EU convergence and regulatory complexity, our findings revealed that due to delays in bringing into effect certain unifying elements, de facto, MDR introduced additional constraints compared to the previous Medical Device Directive (MDD) framework. This leads to the main finding of this research, which is that the MDR convergence increase has led to a conflicting outcome – an increase in regulatory complexity.
Słowa kluczowe:
Medical Device Regulation, Europeanization, EU convergence, multilevel governanceBibliografia
Arnould, Arthur, Rita Hendricusdottir, and Jeroen Bergmann. “The Complexity of Medical Device Regulations Has Increased, as Assessed through Data-Driven Techniques.” Prosthesis 4, no. 3 (2021): 314–30.
Bergmann, Jeroen H.M. “The Emerging Field of Medical Regulatory Technology and Data Science.” Prosthesis 4, no. 2 (2022): 169–71.
Bouček, Vilim. Europsko međunarodno privatno pravo u eurointegracijskom procesu i harmonizacija hrvatskog međunarodnog privatnog prava. Zageb: Manualia Universitatis Studiorum Zagrebiensis, 2009.
Carl, Ann-Kathrin, and David Hochmann. “Impact of the New European Medical Device Regulation: A Two-Year Comparison.” Biomedical Engineering/Biomedizinische Technik (2023).
Daizadeh, Iraj. “The Impact of US Medical Product Regulatory Complexity on Innovation: Preliminary Evidence of Interdependence, Early Acceleration, and Subsequent Inversion.” Pharmaceutical Research 40, no. 6 (2023): 1541–52.
Gavrilovic, Nika. Europski pravni okvir za uređenje motornih vozila i analiza novosti koje donosi Uredba EU 2018/858 o homologaciji i nadzoru tržišta motornih vozila. Zagreb: University of Zagreb, Faculty of Law, 2020.
Hervey, Tamara, and Anniek de Ruijter. “The Dynamic Potential of European Union Health Law.” European Journal of Risk Regulation 11, no. 4 (2020): 726–35.
Lucio, Juan de, and Juan S. Mora-Sanguinetti. “Drafting ‘Better Regulation’: The Economic Cost of Regulatory Complexity.” Journal of Policy Modeling 44, no. 1 (2022): 163–83.
Nikolić, Bruno, and Polonca Kovač. “The European Administrative Space between Ideals and Reality.” In The Science of Public Administration, edited by Janez Stare and Mirko Pečarič, 621–41. Ljubljana: Faculty of Public Administration, 2021.
Stewart, Richard B. “Regulation, Innovation, and Administrative Law: A Conceptual Framework.” California Law Review 69, no. 5 (1981): 1256–377.
Weatherill, Stephen. “Competence Creep and Competence Control.” Yearbook of European Law 23, no. 1 (2004): 1–55.
Ziller, Jacques. “The Nature of European Union Law.” In Tratado de Derecho de la Union Europea, vol. 4, eds. José María Beneyto, Belén Becerril, and Jerónimo Maíllo, 5–7. Madrid: Aranzadi, 2011.
University of Ljubljana https://orcid.org/0009-0001-8215-6273
